Night and Day Mafia (Game Over)

[A2]

Everyone but Math endorsed this.

EXPLAIN YOURSELF.

[Ginngie]

btw I'm a jailkeeper, claimed that in the light and jailed our homeboy Snarky, was the one that came up with there being a strongman

[A2]

Ginngie
WHY THE FUCK
ARE YOU CLAIMING
FOR NO REASON.

[Ginngie]

because I claimed in the light

[Ginngie]

scum already know, so everyone else gets to know as well

[A2]

Eh
tbh if scum already know might as well tell everyone.

[A2]

Dam
I got snipped.

[Creature]

Now we could like look for that strongman in the light side.

[Ginngie]

VOTE: BTD6

[Ginngie]

heavily leaning on BTD

my read here is that he's really just fence sitting, observing the chaos and every time he produces content, its about the leading wagon.

Like, CE wagon he talks about it, oh now Aronis is popular here's why, then texcat was popular.

He's also withholding his vote a lot. I mean, he voted in RVS, then unvoted and has never actually pushed anything.

In camn's revenge, he would directly fight and push scum reads and using his own reasoning.

What I'm seeing here is parroting and Information over Analysis.

Oh and the beetlejuicing.

I literally call him out for doing nothing, pops in the thread to make a comment about him doing nothing and then vanishes.

so conclusion, I have like, no actual reason to townread BTD off of his play.

[Titus]

Everyone but Math endorsed this.

EXPLAIN YOURSELF.

WE had three protectives claim to target Snarky. By tricking people we could see who posted already knowing the strongman rolecop guilty was a fake. The more someone posted like they believed us, the more likely they were to be town. It's not a lock solid case though. So we know scum have a strongman in light (or both Ginngie and Creature are scum and it's an RB but this is farfetched). Basically, it's a knows too much tell. It has to be someone here in light when N1 started as scum cannot use powers in Dark.

VOTE: Kelvin Hydra

Be back Sunday.

[A2]

I kinda wanted Math to explain why they didn't endorse it.
I understand the thought process behind the gambit.

but THREE protectives
are you serious?

[Bulbazak]

So you think that was the primary reason Kelvin was moved to the Light?

[Bulbazak]

So who suggested this gambit? I think I know, but I just want to confirm.

[Ginngie]

Basically what happened is:

I started Dawn saying there was scum because my role, it was a strongman
then we argued a bit
then Titus claimed she should have stopped the kill or there was a strongman/roleblock on her.
I jailkept Snarky so we couldn't both be roleblocked, ergo strongman.

or Titus is scum trying to gain a towncred gambit.

Then creature said he was also involved with Snarky.


Titus said wanted to do the role cop guilty thing or whatever, she started it while I was at work.

Math hates it because of this stupid ethic thing of never wanting to lie and how it only hurts town but I shut them up giving proof that it has worked in camn's revenge and made a player scumslip in a fakeclaim

[Bulbazak]

Cool. It was Titus. That's all I need to know. It means she's likely town here.

[Ginngie]

So you think that was the primary reason Kelvin was moved to the Light?

I thought about that last Night, it's all WIFOM making it NAI.

FKB is scum strongman, or FKB and Dr are both town and scum switched them to frame FKB and the strongman was already in the light.

So it's NAI because WIFOM.

Also Dr could be a Godfather who no longer would need protecting cuz strongman kills the cop. so scum switch to dark.

or two scum switching could also be a thing.

It is truly NAI and I will shoot down those that use it as reasoning because I just disproved it as a valid source for reads.

[Ginngie]

Cool. It was Titus. That's all I need to know. It means she's likely town here.

[A2]

Math hates it because of this stupid ethic thing of never wanting to lie and how it only hurts town but I shut them up giving proof that it has worked in camn's revenge and made a player scumslip in a fakeclaim

Yep. That's definitely Math alright.

[Bulbazak]

And this is where Nancy being gone is going to drive me crazy. She said in the Dark PT that there was a lot of evidence in thread that pointed to Kelvin being town, and that's why they were moved to the Light PT. Except, scum were the ones who did the moving. So I asked her why scum would move Kelvin to the Light PT if he was so obviously town. I haven't gotten a response yet.

[Ginngie]

And this is where Nancy being gone is going to drive me crazy.

All I can tell you is to be patient cuz life really did kick her while she's down :/

I haven't heard from her in a couple days and we talk every night

[Bulbazak]

I get that, and I didn't mean to sound insensitive. But that's essentially how the entirety of n1 went, and it's driving me bonkers. So for her to come in, drop a scumread on me, then peace out, when I've been trying to sync up with her all night, I end up being a little frustrated.

[Ginngie]

Yeah, there is no way for you to not be frustrated her.

When she gets to feeling better again, then I or we am going to press on that issue of obv!town going to the light argument because that didn't make sense to me at all.

Almost like take logic, and reverse it and there's your answer.

So, really the only thing you can do is just wait and out, but I promise your concerns aren't going to be ignored.

[QuantumRadius]

hey ginngie
you're forgetting someone
i was against the rolecop gambit for an alternate reason. i didn't approve of the methods used to reaction test the dark.

[mastina]

I heard the following on a classic rock station:

I would love to hear a second opinion on that.

(Hint: The only correct answer is that's absolute bullshit and the radio station has lost any/all credibility for calling itself a classic rock station.)