Okay, I'll try and do something useful, however my thoughts aren't great. My analysis of before stands up pretty much as it did, we start talking about strategy, then OMG, then roleclaiming, then we have a few lurker wagons, nothing special much. Throughout play what I've noticed is that OMG has an incredibly short temper and a tad confrontational, speaking of OMG there are two things I'd like to say.
Firstly, why would you like me or Oman dead?
Secondly, if that is the case why are you voting GS?
The second question also applies to Reyo, you call me an active lurker and call me scum for saying I really have nothing much useful to contribute, but you follow my style of play and continue to sit on the lurker wagon. If you think I'm scum then you should at the very least FoS me. I wonder why you didn't.
Okay, so onto what is important in mafia, suspicions. Now, as I have already stated, I haven't as of yet got any major suspicions on anybody, and yes I know there are a load of pages to trawl through but most of that is the arguments beween Reyo and OMG. What has struck me throughout that is OMG's poor temper and tendancy to say things that are misunderstood, according to him.
The main point I picked out from OMG is that he always fakeclaims, thus rendering lynch the liar pointless. From what I recall OMG said at the start is that the first thing to do in any situation is to discuss strategy, which Reyo was more than happy to do in this situation, however this seemed to anger OMG because he claimed he was being misunderstood. However his unwillingness to discuss this with Reyo seems a tad inconsistent with his earlier statements.
However there is one person who really wanted to kill such a discussion, this being Oman, who claimed that discussing such would at worst render it pointless because the scum would know whatt the town is planning, at best render the whole thing WIFOM, niether situation did he like so he preferred that stone left unturned.
When I think about it there have only been a few major contributors to this thread, these being Reyo, OMG (for better or for worse), Elias and to a lesser extent GW and I believe blaze has made some valuable input. Most of the rest have been very minor players in comparison, thus difficult to get a read off. Reyo has mostly been arguing with Elias and OMG. GW has been sitting around declaring various people innocent, Elias has been hovering here and there making various comments. I don't really get the stink of scum from any of them, however I don't think I've really seen GW square up to someone and pronounce them scum as of yet nor cast a vote, but rather has been allying with other major players calling them town. So if I might be so bold as to ask, GW, who do you think is scum?
After all of that what do I think? Firstly I agree that OMG may well be town, but I think he is a bit of a loose cannon, and his last couple of posts have not been at all helpful. Reyo strikes me as the most townie player so far and I want to see Ghostwriter making some accusations. As for who is scum? I'd like to see the lurkers make themselves known, so as to get a better read off of them, but I think Oman may be scum because of his attempts to kill off some of the strategy discussion, and some confrontational posts I believe, and I think that GhostWriter may be buddying up to Reyo and OMG.
FoS: Oman & GW
The [i]FoO[/i] is watching...