Night and Day Mafia (Game Over)

[79 CE]

I have read your ISO. I see only two posts that contain any reasoning, both very early in the game. There is the nonsense of the fake claim, there is buddying Titus. Your ISO is almost entirely empty of reasoning of any kind.

[79 CE]

@Aslan I think BTD is probably town; why are you scumreading the slot?

[Vedith]

So because you don't agree with my reasoning, it's nonsense?
I strongly believe the red writting is a scum tell. When the brain see's something, it sticks with it and Aronis thought he was posting without harm.

Regardless if you don't like my reasoning, I have reason.

The other part is from the fake claim. I do not believe Aronis as scum from that what so ever. I made this very clear yesterday. And it makes me feel that Rauth is possible scum with him as it's not believable that Aronis just guessed a players role type.

I think majority of my posts second half were about scum reading Aronis. This is why I disbelieve you read my ISO.

[79 CE]

Vedith someone using red writing is not a scum tell. The second-half mentions of Aronis are all to do with the claim.

[Vedith]

Vedith someone using red writing is not a scum tell. The second-half mentions of Aronis are all to do with the claim.

It is a scum tell.
And I believe it to be true.

Again, just because you don't agree, doesn't mean that I can't scum read them for it.

[Vedith]

If you felt that it wasn't a valid scum read, why did you have me as town?

[79 CE]

Vedith what if I were to tell you that using two commas in your sentence just there is a scum tell for me and therefore I am scumreading you and am going to tunnel you for the remainder of the game?

[Vedith]

Vedith what if I were to tell you that using two commas in your sentence just there is a scum tell for me and therefore I am scumreading you and am going to tunnel you for the remainder of the game?

Do you think I'm scum for using 2 commas?

[79 CE]

Imagine that I do.

[Vedith]

Then your read is wrong.
What about it? If you said you scum read me because you saw me kill someone, I'm still going to claim your read is wrong.

[79 CE]

Why is my read wrong? You dropped a scumtell.

[Vedith]

Because I know I'm town.
It doesn't mean your scum read on me isn't real, it just means it's wrong.

If you think I'm wrong on Aronis, you need to explain why.
Other than saying I don't have a scum read on him.

[79 CE]

I think your red-text scumtell is hot garbage and any competent mafia player will tell you the same. Your tunnel is equally hot garbage as long as that's your justification for it and your tunnel compromises the majority of your ISO, which makes the majority of your content this game hot garbage. I'm looking for a reason to townread you and all I see is hot garbage.

[Vedith]

Well thank you for your feedback.
I'm still right.

Why did you town read me when you joined in?

[79 CE]

Just to be clear, I'm not calling you incompetent; the assumption that any competent mafia player will you that your scumtell is bad means that you are not part of the group "any competent mafia player" is not an accurate one. I think if you are town you have an extremely mistaken scumtell that you have managed to somehow find valid; it does not necessarily reflect your ability as a player, it only reflects that you are stuck with a very bad piece of information that from outside perspective would not require much to see how mistaken it is because of how obviously bad that information is. I think you need to realize that your scumtell is not valid. The color of text that a player uses is not indicative of their alignment.

pedit when I joined in?

[QuantumRadius]

Crack shot theory is that wagon is on scum so there's less arguing going on as compared to wagoning town and everyone was fighting?

I took great notice in QR scumreading me hard as fuck and then once I claimed she instantaneously took every word I said as the truth and nothing but the truth and hasn't pushed me since.

Granted, no one has because people are smart D2 for some reason, but anyway, I would think a number one or two scum read would mean you'd be highly sus of claims and push them regardless and that hasn't happened. Really I haven't seen any true involvement from QR since the gambit.

I have my reasons for not scumreading you as hard anymore, i would prefer not to share
activity wise, I'm sorry, the irl is insanely busy

VOTE: QR

why

I AM A BAD MOD.

*hugs*

if it helps I think that you're scum based on a short skim of your iso <3

I've got a PbPa somewhere you might be interested in

Vedith someone using red writing is not a scum tell. The second-half mentions of Aronis are all to do with the claim.

It is a scum tell.
And I believe it to be true.

Again, just because you don't agree, doesn't mean that I can't scum read them for it.

oh dear god
FONT COLOR IS NAI

[79 CE]

Vedith please explain to me why you think using red text is a scumtell and where you got this idea from?

[Vedith]

They saw red on their PM, therefore it was on their mind.
As I said, you can tell me I'm wrong with that, but instead you should be telling me why they're town, because I'm more likely to review that.

[79 CE]

Where have you seen a player who uses red text flip scum?

[Creature]

Sorry RC, you replaced a very scummy slot.

[Vedith]

I haven't seen a player use red in their opening post.

I have seen scum make minor mistakes and town make minor slips going by what they have seen in their role PM... Because it's on their mind.

Again. You have more chance to explain to me why Aronis is town, rather than why my read is wrong.

So, go for it, woo me. Why is Aronis town?

[79 CE]

Creature, mind sharing your reads? I only have a little time before I sleep.

[Creature]

Let me see:

Bulbazak town
Ginngie town

[Creature]

Rautherdir town surely
Aronis town I guess

[Creature]

QuantumRadius town too