Mini 1927: Breaking Bad Mafia - Game Over

[gerryoat]

Robb if you're really vig, you should shoot backhand. are you day or night?

UNVOTE:

Why the unvote? You don't believe my claim and you're calling for someone else to be vigged, so why did you unvote me?

I clearly said backhand was my sr as well

[Almost50]

Robb if you're really vig, you should shoot backhand. are you day or night?

UNVOTE:

Why the unvote? You don't believe my claim and you're calling for someone else to be vigged, so why did you unvote me?

I clearly said backhand was my sr as well

"As well". That's 100% correct. Now we need to LYNCH someone, while someone else gets VIGGED. Your SR "as well" is the one you want to SHOT, so who do you want LYNCHED if not me? And why NOT me still?

[iDanyboy]

I town-read Rob, Wisdom and Chick.

can you please explain why you town read us.

Also, who do you think the scum is that was on the venca wagon?

Thank you.

Rob, Because you are actively scum hunting.
Wisdom, His day one seems to weird to be scum and his vote progression feels natural.
Chick, That was mostly from his Day 1 play, but his defense of A50 (that the players scum reading him are 'reaching') doesn't sit right with me and goes to null/pos scum.

For the Vecna wagon it's either Chick or Gerry.
I think backhand is 3rd party poisoner, his remarks don't come from town but from 3rd party trying to tell town that he'll help them.

Onto A50, I believe his clam, his play reflects the cop check on Wisdom by saying he trust him and tries to understand his reads better. I don't think scum would crumb in there first post either.

VOTE: RobbRobb IS the 3P poisoner, and is trying to make us doubt Vax (the Poison Doctor)

I don't find this likely, we can just let him confirm his role by letting him Day kill someone tomorrow.

[Almost50]

And as for my reaction, WHAT reaction? Are you kidding me? Or are you just riding the hype?

@Wisdom/Chicka/Desp/Vax/Edo/Backhand (Dany & Moza can also weigh on of they want to, but I thought I'd save you the embarrassment bc I SR you both): Have I been toxic? Overly aggressive? Weird (beyond my usual, that is)? Am I mistreating gerry?? Your opinions matter to ME, so please respond to this (You cab do it in spoilers if you don't want to clog the thread). THANK YOU.

[Almost50]

Chick, That was mostly from his Day 1 play, but his defense of A50 (that the players scum reading him are 'reaching') doesn't sit right with me and goes to null/pos scum.

Sorry but I feel like reiterating here: I crumbed odd-night cop. Chicka soon expressed will to work with me. It hinted she got my crumb. I'm still alive today, so if she did get the crumb as I thought she did then why wasn't I shot over UZI/Poisoned over gerry, assuming Scum!Chicka?

So, it's either Chicka did NOT get the crumb (which makes her response to my 1st post a bit strange.. sort of), or she did and is NOT Scum, and that's why I'm still alive.

[Backhand]

I'm day but I can't use it until after day 2 lynch. So twilight day 2 and beyond as long as the thread is opened. My plan is using it twilight day 2 if I'm around.

I won't be shooting Blackhand.

Robb if ever you are possessed to shoot me, please let me claim first.

And seriously: Dany's concern over who the poisoner is as opposed to who the Mafia are is a massive scum tell why can you all not see this?

[Edosurist]

@Chickadee, why do you say that everyone suspecting a-fitty is reaching when the explanation you give for your townread is that they don't look like a50!scum? If others don't know what their scum play looks like from past experiences like you do, then they can't be expected to have the same perspective you do and wouldn't be "reaching."

^I wrote this before Almost claimed, and I believe him here. I'm still looking for an answer to this, though.
Robb and gerry are both wrong about A50. With the crumbs and the stream of consciousness that came from A50, I believe it.

I believe Vax is the poison doc, and though I was initially mad about him saving gerry, he made the right choice. Vax is the only one with the role-PM, so I'm gonna trust that 3P is unlikely. If there's no 3P, anybody targeted by the poisoner is town.
@Wis 733 You say it's already explained why gerry is still scum. I don't see it.

Simple answer at A50 re: has he been toxic.
@A50 Do you really think Chickadee found your crumb? I'd rather hear confirmation from her than from you on that.

Today I'd lynch Backhand, Robb, Dany. I'd take Desp later if Dany flips town, but otherwise Chickadee would fall next. Based on POE, things already look pretty good for us.

[iDanyboy]

Chick, That was mostly from his Day 1 play, but his defense of A50 (that the players scum reading him are 'reaching') doesn't sit right with me and goes to null/pos scum.

Sorry but I feel like reiterating here: I crumbed odd-night cop. Chicka soon expressed will to work with me. It hinted she got my crumb. I'm still alive today, so if she did get the crumb as I thought she did then why wasn't I shot over UZI/Poisoned over gerry, assuming Scum!Chicka?

So, it's either Chicka did NOT get the crumb (which makes her response to my 1st post a bit strange.. sort of), or she did and is NOT Scum, and that's why I'm still alive.

Maybe, but I wouldn't rest your whole case on that.

[Persivul]

Vote Count 2.4

iDanyBoy (2) - Desperado, Backhand
Desperado (1) - Wisdom
Almost50 (2) - Robbnva, mozamis
Backhand (2) - iDanyBoy, Vaxkiller
mozamis (1) - Chickadee
Robbnva (1) - Almost50

Not voting (2) - Edosurist, gerryoat

With 11 players it's 6 votes to lynch

Day 2 will end in (expired on 2017-08-03 10:00:00)

Mod Notes:

None

[Edosurist]

I'm day but I can't use it until after day 2 lynch. So twilight day 2 and beyond as long as the thread is opened. My plan is using it twilight day 2 if I'm around.

I won't be shooting Blackhand.

Robb if ever you are possessed to shoot me, please let me claim first.

And seriously: Dany's concern over who the poisoner is as opposed to who the Mafia are is a massive scum tell why can you all not see this?

You still think that even if Vax says there's no 3P?

I agree with Dany's post just above the VC.

[Backhand]

Vax also said there wasn't a dayvig, and I believe robb. I'm not saying Vax is lying, just that he's reading too much into his role. A Mafia with two kills a night seems way too strong even with the power town has, and a Mafia kill on gerry makes no sense.

[Chickadee]

Catching up now.

[Almost50]

And seriously: Dany's concern over who the poisoner is as opposed to who the Mafia are is a massive scum tell why can you all not see this?

I can, and I've promoting a Danny lynch since D1. Bring life back to that wagon and consider my vote already on him. He's -by far- my preferred lynch (nothing personal, bud. I just think you're scum in this game and it's the way the game is played).

[Almost50]

What if I told you guys that MY role PM hints there being 3P? I get my results in the form mafia/not mafia or no result. Take that as you will because I'm tired of arguing about personal interpretations.

[Robbnva]

I'm day but I can't use it until after day 2 lynch. So twilight day 2 and beyond as long as the thread is opened. My plan is using it twilight day 2 if I'm around.

I won't be shooting Blackhand.

Robb if ever you are possessed to shoot me, please let me claim first.

And seriously: Dany's concern over who the poisoner is as opposed to who the Mafia are is a massive scum tell why can you all not see this?

My decision has been made already. You are safe.

[Edosurist]

@Backhand Vax wasn't wrong about the dayvig. Vecna wasn't actually a dayvig, so if anything I think that's a point for Vax. I'm not sure how Robb fits into that yet since he has to wait until D2 twilight. That makes him sound like a JOAT or something.

@Vax can you explain what exactly about your flavor suggests scum poisoner? I don't see a need to withhold that if you've already claimed your flavor name.

Hey A50, I'll hand you some momentum.

VOTE: iDanyboy

But regarding mafia/not mafia or no result, that's pretty standard for a cop. You'd get no result if you were roleblocked.

[Robbnva]

Vax is wrong. He said based on his role pm he didn't think there is a day vig.

I am a day vig (not joat)

Vax's issue is just reading into flavor and thinking that it means something. Clearly it doesn't.

Mod isn't going to reveal setup info in a role pm flavor.

[Edosurist]

K, well then. I was initially with you regarding revealing the setup in PM flavor, but I wanted to have some faith in him. I'll put that on hold for now.

[Almost50]

But regarding mafia/not mafia or no result, that's pretty standard for a cop. You'd get no result if you were roleblocked.

You're spot on. And if we only have Scum vs Rown, who do you think is more likely to have a RB?

VOTE: Danny

[Almost50]

VOTE: iDanyBoy

Just to make sure it counts

[Edosurist]

But regarding mafia/not mafia or no result, that's pretty standard for a cop. You'd get no result if you were roleblocked.

You're spot on. And if we only have Scum vs Rown, who do you think is more likely to have a RB?

VOTE: Danny

I mean, probably scum.
I'm confused. Are you still saying that your role suggests third party? I don't think it suggests anything.

[Vaxkiller]

I thnk it suggests you being unable to target someone

[Vaxkiller]

I believe there is a finite # of times the poisoner can poison. Thats why I dont think its 3rd party

[Vaxkiller]

But thats not 100%

[gerryoat]

VOTE: Backhand

Robb you should shoot a50. if he doesnt flip scum i will be legit shocked.