Night and Day Mafia (Game Over)

[Creature]

Well, there's now the possibility that that scum was Nos with her factional boon...

[Bulbazak]

There's zero possibility here Creature. I am absolutely certain Math is scum. I'm certain enough to initiate a 1v1, and I don't do that lightly. The progression makes sense. Math's claims do not. They're scum. End of story. Stop play patty cake and vote.

[dramonic]

You don't go in knowing a set up

There wasn't any indication at night start to think bus driver.

A lot of your reasoning is ends justifying the means but that doesn't work because you don't know the results before you make the actions

Yes if Town has a redirector scum have a bus driver always

Set up 101.

Like wtf?

Please never mod a game

[Aronis]

You don't go in knowing a set up

There wasn't any indication at night start to think bus driver.

A lot of your reasoning is ends justifying the means but that doesn't work because you don't know the results before you make the actions

Yes if Town has a redirector scum have a bus driver always

Set up 101.

Like wtf?

Please never mod a game

cmon dramonic thats like common sense along with there being 1 scum for every 1.5 townies and scum getting one roleblocker for every town investigative.

[Titus]

Bulba, perhaps maybe clarifying how the guilty is rock solid is a good idea.

[Vedith]

Vedith why should we bring you into Light over Titus?

Because I want to use my power.

[dramonic]

You don't go in knowing a set up

There wasn't any indication at night start to think bus driver.

A lot of your reasoning is ends justifying the means but that doesn't work because you don't know the results before you make the actions

Yes if Town has a redirector scum have a bus driver always

Set up 101.

Like wtf?

Please never mod a game

cmon dramonic thats like common sense along with there being 1 scum for every 1.5 townies and scum getting one roleblocker for every town investigative.

pretty much. I'm sad mastin lied about the setup. For 18 players proper balance is obviously 11-7

[dramonic]

Actually that's a bit townsided

[Creature]

11-7?

[Vedith]

He's taking the Piss...

[mastina]

@mastin, if a player has a passive ability, is it deactivated in the light?

The opposite in fact.
If a player has a passive ability, it will only work when in the light.

[Aronis]

Actually that's a bit townsided

yeah, for 11-7 you're gonna need to give the scum 4 or 5 roleblockers and a 3-shot governor to make that balanced

[Creature]

You're overestimating town...

[Ginngie]

@mastin, if a player has a passive ability, is it deactivated in the light?

The opposite in fact.
If a player has a passive ability, it will only work when in the light.

Wow I'm stupid

[Aronis]

You're overestimating town...

overestimating???? are you crazy??? if anything I'm underestimating town

[Creature]

So rather you're saying "town should be more powerful to balance"?

[dramonic]

I cant tell if this is all going waaaay over crature's head

[Aronis]

So rather you're saying "town should be more powerful to balance"?

no, if anything I should give scum more power.
11-7 is pretty townsided
so scum definitely needs a 3-shot governor and maybe a doublevoter as well now that I think about it

[Aronis]

I cant tell if this is all going waaaay over crature's head

these people are still taking every word I say so seriously idgi

[Creature]

Then you're overestimating town.

[texcat]

I cant tell if this is all going waaaay over crature's head

these people are still taking every word I say so seriously idgi

That's cause you're a mason.

[Ginngie]

texcat, reads list, one sentence per person

plz and tnx

[mastina]

So I don't have a votecount prepared yet, but.

[mastina]

Gonna reserve a spot anyway.

[texcat]

texcat, reads list, one sentence per person

plz and tnx

Starting with town....
{A2} killed Nos
{Creature, QR} pushed/voted Nos lynch
{79CE, Dramonic} stuck in the dark with me and I seem to agree with a lot they are saying. None of us can see why Titus is obvtown.
{Vedith, Ginn, Aronis, TWIE} null to scum. Ginn will claim that they pushed Nos, but Ginn has pushed every single lynch. Vedith just spams. Aronis was my scum read from earlier and hasn't done anything to really improve his position. I hated TWIE's entry.

And then there's Mathblade, Titus, Bulba. And there's definitely scum there, but hell if I know. My gut says that Math is town and that Bulba and Titus are scum. My head says that Math's explanation for things makes no sense. Why redirect onto Rauth? Why the change from guilty, to maybe guilty, to must be scum?