Mini Normal 1929 - Game Over

[Scorpious]

Why didn't you protect them then?

I didnt know that until today, I am also very confident that Alban is town.

[Mulch]

Did you have a lock town read going into today

[Scorpious]

My scums atm are

Whymaf and you

Pedit-nothing worth risking my own life over

[Mulch]

Explain your scumread on me again?

[Mulch]

THis is dumb but I want to see what other people to say first.

[Mulch]

I don't know why y ou didn't protect your highets townread and utilize basically a cop. Your not a newbie.

[awesomeusername]

Need to think about this claim. I'm more skeptical of Scorpious than before, though.

@Scorpious: The way you'd use a weak doctor is to say (or I guess heavily crumb) beforehand who you're targeting, and then if you die town will probably figure out how. And if you live you have conf-town, which is really good. And since you're 1-shot you can out at that point. Tbh, it's probably even better if you die because then you catch scum.

[Mulch]

Ye...

[Mulch]

He joined in 2015...

[Mulch]

Llama better have a good fucking expanation for why they are white knighting Scorpy right now

[Steel]

UNVOTE:

[LlamaFluff]

Mulch please. If you are town don't get to into this and ruin a lot of solid traps we can set for scum. If scum doesn't know how to handle this claim we can come out way on top.

There are a TON of traps here but I need a keyboard to lay it out and I'm at the office where it's just phone

[Mulch]

Breaking my no posting from phone at work but... get off him. Scorp claim N1 action.

There will be terse posting once home

Do you have an actual reason or is this bullshit? One shot doc/weak doc is a perfect scumclaim. Does your role complement in some way? If not, how the fuck are you so confident this is real?


UNVOTE:

I'm assuming you have a good expanation for why that's some godsend of a claim that will get us off his wagon.

[awesomeusername]

After some thought, I

think

I believe it. I don't want to say more and mess up Llama's traps though.

[Mulch]

I"m interested to hear about these traps. lol

[Mulch]

Cause I can't think of any but maybe that's just cause I'm a dumbass lol

[Steel]

I've only read the claim so far, but if true it is likely optimal to let him use his shot. In some ways weak doctor is stronger than full doctor for one night. Similar to cop scum have to kill this tonight if its town or likely face one person being confirmed as town.

If he's scum lynching him today or tomorrow is nearly identical.
However lynching him tomorrow if he is town and hasn't therefore been killed should at least provide a confirmed town through his flip. Furthermore, if we do mislynch today his role may be judged along with others when massclaim happens. If there are not enough other claims for town pr then scorpious may be confirmed through deduction, conversely if there are too many town power role claims we may use that as a metric as well. Overall on more night gives multiple chances for things to work out for the better and little downside or risk.

Although the target should not be public in this case as that would give an option for the target to be killed instead if scorpious is town. I believe random selection of a target might be ideal, as if he is town his reads are somewhat public too. The best result overall may just be if he just dies if he's town as there isn't more to judge and consider but that's still better than mislynching him if that is the case.

[Steel]

@Scorpious: The way you'd use a weak doctor is to say (or I guess heavily crumb) beforehand who you're targeting, and then if you die town will probably figure out how

Such would be the case ordinarily, but with a claim in the open any subtlety is extremely unlikely to work now.

[Steel]

I really want to lynch llama here and I don't like the consensus scumreads on whymafia and awesome which it seems like the lynch might head to. Again I'm not a fan of his predecessors replace out here.

I would do alban on compromise but where I leave my vote today is likely the last time I'll be present until deadline so I won't be able to change it.

[Mulch]

I can lynch Llama if they don't give a good reasons for why they had unquestioned trust in Scorpy's claim immediately.

[awesomeusername]

Right now I prefer WM. I've been getting town-vibes from Llama recently.

[Mulch]

Right now I prefer WM. I've been getting town-vibes from Llama recently.

WHere

[awesomeusername]

It's kinda gut, but I liked his thoughts on the Scorpious wagon and that he's thinking about traps. We'll see in a moment if that latter reason is invalid, anyway.

[Mulch]

Thinking about traps is towny, saying that you are thinking about traps is scummy.

[awesomeusername]

Oh. Why?