DUNN NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO ;~; uhhhh hm going off this I have a lot of tr's I need to go back and read I was prob gonna vote fam but if that's a scum role...eh
I bet Maria is scum this game
~Firebringer
Na Maria isn't towny enough to be scum this game~
Charloux
MariaR goes for the uwu owo tsundere-dere look but you never know if she has a knife behind her back.~
*Keep in mind, I don't do this in order and I may add to things in a mismatched way, so if anything feels oddly worded or semi repeated, that is why.
*My reads do tend to change after completely analyzing everything.
*Higher up you are in each tier, the townier I think they are.
Town
-
Lean Town
-
Null Town
-
Null
-
Null Scum
-
Lean Scum
-
Scum
Drixx
- lol, he's town. I can't see Drixx making that claim as scum. Just can't. It's because it's Drixx, not because of the idea that it was claimed. The combination of those two, if that makes sense.
Dunnstral
- I've actually never seen Dunn be this proactive before. It worries me, but I am generally liking it. I agree with the Famethyst push he did. I do disagree with the PnT read. And the trajectory to his read on BFI was there and should have been expected really. Town. I generally always tend to gut read Dunn as town, but usually not this much. Yeah, basically where I feel his thoughts and reads are at make sense and feels like he's sorting, and changes his mind when he needs to. Town.
Penn and Teller
- I liked the stuff they posted on Drixx. The way they are questioning and challenging things comes off as sorting pretty well. They don't have a lot of posts, but I've generally liked pretty much everything they've done. This is a pretty solid town read for me.
MariaR
- So Maria's was scum against me recently, and I don't believe she would go for a mislynch on me unless there was a lot of support for it already. I haven't been able to post, and I've never been scum against Maria, so I actually think this makes sense coming from townMaria. The last game we played together I was town and came off as the town leader type, which I generally do, and if I'm not town leader, I'm definitely around and conversing with the town leader often. I expect this game is going to end up turning into the former. Lean town.
Mint Berry Crunch
- Yeah, his posts are pretty good. I like his near wall posts and think they make a lot of sense. Even the one where he votes me. He's right. I have not had nearly the amount of content as I should have been providing. I'm here now, I'm completely caught up. Ask me thoughts on anything. I'm putting everything out there. MBC's turnaround on Dunker seemed very natural, and the fact he called Dunker town, but not putting that in stone came off to me as a way that scum wouldn't get much credit if Dunker was lynched and they weren't on it, if Dunker flipped town. I felt like he really thought that Dunker was coming off as town, and was satisfied with moving on and sorting others for now. I see that as townie. Lean town.
Wake88
- Might be a horrible reason to town read someone, but based on 254 and him asking me about my thoughts on this seems like town to me. Wake and I had played a good amount years back, and this felt like a way to sort me and potentially get thoughts on another player at the same time, which came off very town. He asks a lot of questions, and I guess you could make a scum case for that, but I'm tone reading this as townWake. Lean Town, though. I actually like his "off the table" talk, kind of checking off everyone's willing to lynch and then sorting through. But I know you can make a scum case for this stuff, I guess, so that's why it's only lean.
Robbvna
- K, I don't feel like responding here. He's just voting a lurk sack, and by now, people should know that lurking is incredibly NAI on my part because I'm incredibly vocal as both alignments as well. He's not doing anything, but he's not doing anything scummy either. He's dead null, almost null/lean town, since if he's comparable to 2F, then he's probably town. TwoFace is one of those players that end up tunneling me every game. I've never been scum against 2F. Nuff said.
Dunkerdoodles
- You're different this game. You're more confident seeming about your reads than I've seen you. I don't know what I want to think about it yet. And I know you've probably learned since...you know what.
Aristophanes
- Don't have much on Aristo. I think I'm paranoid that he's scum this game due to a previous game and absolutely not wanting to lose to scumAristo here because of it. I don't know if he'd be sad about my silence if he was scum, though. I imagine he knows I would be pretty familiar with his play as well. Unless he tried to buddy up. Because of my paranoia I slightly see everything about Aristo kind of scummy, like his "Oh, I'd totally be okay with this!" reponse to Wake asking 3 other people if they would be okay lynching Dunker. Also, at the same time of this, I get paranoid that I'm only seeing this stuff as scummy because I'm paranoid. This is a null scum for me until I get more info.
ButFearItself
- K, so he commented on awkward meta defense by referencing other games is awkward. So this...as opposed to not referencing other games and using meta. What? Meta in itself requires other games...I also didn't like 256, specifically the comment to the mod. My only refrain from that is why would scum not do that elsewhere? Sounds like scum potentially trying to figure out SK stuff and have players talk about it that way. BFI comments on the vote hopping coming from scum when nowadays I feel town are much more likely to vote hop, tbh. He was targeting Dunn for not making sense, but I have a weird tendency to want to defend Dunn in every game I'm in. Despite all this, you can make a case for it all being NAI. Nothing is towny, but a lot is NAI, and I don't know if that means anything. The P&T push is pretty scummy, though. I'm stuck on the awkward meta defense comment. Lean scum. For the last few reasons.
Zachstralkita
- Zach hasn't really done much this game. Just simple statements with fluff in between. I didn't really like how he went about his Vedith/MBC reading. Like, I get what you're saying, but it looked as if you were doing it to make it well known you were now town reading the slot. Zach said he had a reliable way of town telling and scum telling, but I don't understand why that doesn't translate to MBC town telling/scum telling the same way. The fact that MBC said he wasn't going to be playing the same way pushes me a little weird too, as if he's actively playing differently, then those might not even exist. You have a lot of personality statements this game, if that makes sense. And all the posts are vague. This is likely scum. Thing that's holding me back? I always aggressively scum read Zach. Nonetheless, I still think it's scum.
Famethyst
- Made the "bad posts tend to come from scum" comment, and I believe I commented on that. Could be wrong. I do not agree with that at all. I feel town make worse posts than scum typically do, especially if scum aren't under any sort of pressure. I actually don't feel Fame has been doing much but stating things that have already been said, actually. The SK comment they made was odd. They also said "generally town pushes on lynchbait", which kind of contradicts the whole "bad posts tend to come from scum" mindset, I feel. I did kind of like this reads list, because I get the BFI thing, but if BFI ended up being town, then this actually turns into a pretty scummy list, and it just comes off as town before flips. Dunker is mislynch bait. This is probably scum. I'm going to full on scum read here. I did this after I did BFI. I guess if Fame is a SK, then BFI could still be scum, but I don't think they'd be scum together. Call it gut, but I feel this slot makes sense as potentially setting up to control the game, and live to the long run at that.
So you wanna be a master of MAFIA!!? Do you have the skills to CATCH THAT SCUM!!!? We all live...in a mafia world...and you can, too, if you do just one thing...
VOTE: Famethyst
I bet Maria is scum this game
~Firebringer
Na Maria isn't towny enough to be scum this game~
Charloux
MariaR goes for the uwu owo tsundere-dere look but you never know if she has a knife behind her back.~
Hydra of Aelita (Carny) and gigabyteTroubadour (Amethyst)