Kidney Mafia (Game Over)

[gerryoat]

Go post!

[gerryoat]

is that dunn or maria posting rn

[gerryoat]

i havent even read anything lol

[gerryoat]

i just said i didnt read i figured this was RVS so i just skipped. do i really have to read

[gerryoat]

lasagne has a baby bunny as an avi. more likely to sheep

[gerryoat]

is that dunn or maria posting rn

Dunn

damn. if it was maria i was gonna vote you and then leave

[gerryoat]

Oh I claim Town by the way, haha.

[gerryoat]

VOTE: zach

[gerryoat]

hebichan is mafia, but im gonna vote this for fun

[gerryoat]

I can be long, or I can be short.
I can be grown, and I can be bought.
I can be flashy, or left bare.
I can be round, or I can be square.

What am I?

[gerryoat]

only maf would be wrong

[gerryoat]

VOTE: hebichan

[gerryoat]

gerry = hair

wrong, but good guess

[gerryoat]

Hey Zach, do you townread me?

I have quite the wagon already, so if you don't, that vote seems rather odd.

send this slot to the shadow realm. this post was a scumclaim

[gerryoat]

if hebichan is not mafia then zach and dunn are maf together. or all 3 are maf. lol

[gerryoat]

VOTE: gerryoat

Gerryoat is trying

This is unprecedented

He's probably scum

how many times do people have to be wrong about bad meta before they realize its bad meta?

also i havent even been trying so far, so this post is really bad. rb might be mafia here

[gerryoat]

Hey Zach, do you townread me?

I have quite the wagon already, so if you don't, that vote seems rather odd.

send this slot to the shadow realm. this post was a scumclaim

Or, I'm trying to see where people actually read me.

You already think I'm scum though, so, whatevs.

Fine, I'm used to it.

I play weird because I don't know how people will perceive my posts, and I'm just letting the wagon roll. I'll claim at about 8 or so

.

Send this to the shadow realm soon pls

[gerryoat]

holy shit

gerry actually responding to posts

ok humour me, why are you diverting from the style of play ive seen you do as town multiple times now where you just enter thread, say "x is mafia" and disappear for 2 more days and then repeat "i really think x is mafia"

bad attempt to deflect, this is still scum.

but i will humour you. Because i don't play the same way as either town or mafia.

[gerryoat]

this is the most proactive and engaged ive seen you ever be in the 4 games exp i have with you

so why would that lead you to believe that i'm mafia?

[gerryoat]

why do you need her opinion on me?

[gerryoat]

@gerry

gonkbadoop taskmaster (hydra of schadd_ and gigabyteTroubadour)- SCUM PROBABLY
SlySly
hebichan- TOWN PROBABLY
Lycanfire
Bins- SCUM
POWERFUL WARRIOR (hydra of hiplop and The Bulge)
Spiffeh
Wings

gerryoat- HMMM KINDA SCUMMY

PeregrineV- TOWN

Arcade Pals (hydra of Dunnstral and MariaR)- HMMM

Hopkirk
torgonitoh
Lasagne Bot (hydra of kraska77 and Transcend)
Carcalilly
Can It (hydra of chamber and Cheetory6)
rb
Narna- good posting
TPFKAP
grapes
Zachstralkita- TOWN

where im at so far
gn

yes but why does her opinion matter to you

[gerryoat]

ok then

[gerryoat]

i dont get how being neighborizered = clear. or am i missing something

[gerryoat]

I'm setting up a masonry !!

so, how does that work. if they become mason they are town? if not they are mafia?

[gerryoat]

LasagneMaf

[gerryoat]

why is everyone so scummy my god

[gerryoat]

I'm The Only One.

[gerryoat]

maria is scum. she scum slipped

[gerryoat]

jury's oat on gerryout

s

[gerryoat]

We'll show them the true power of a shinobi

-MariaR

F U
2 pages in and my hydra partner has posted as me tunneled into someone and we have a spammer...Ah what a good day of mafia
~Maria

okay, if you're town. answer this. who is my fav EM user on this site.

[gerryoat]

We'll show them the true power of a shinobi

-MariaR

F U
2 pages in and my hydra partner has posted as me tunneled into someone and we have a spammer...Ah what a good day of mafia
~Maria

okay, if you're town. answer this. who is my fav EM user on this site.

yourself.

LMAO I CANT BELIEVE YOU GOT THAT RIGHT. ok u are town. i will fight till the end of this earth if someone tunnels you

[gerryoat]

does gerry really main genji?

i main dva. sometimes rein. sometimes hanzo

[gerryoat]

where does justice rain from?

above

[gerryoat]

does gerry really main genji?

i main dva. sometimes rein. sometimes hanzo

What are these things

overwatch characters. you should play

[gerryoat]

im less inclined to vote you when you have a bunny avi. unless you are abc

[gerryoat]

is still dont get how that role works, but w/e

[gerryoat]

gonna be hoenst, dont wanna read the last 10 pages i missed, but i'll do it while im eating in a bit

[gerryoat]

TL;DR version for a bit. did the masonry thing work or no

[gerryoat]

gonna guess no. so vote hebi plz

[gerryoat]

OH MY GOD IM 30 PAGES BEHIND. KILL ME. ill read after i come back from the store

[gerryoat]

i too vote ppl for no reason before they can catch up

[gerryoat]

killing implies a mafia action. are you saying you can kill?

[gerryoat]

Hi. This is the player formerly known as TPFKAP. I spent quite a while typing this up on Monday evening, but then found that I couldn't post. I've asked for permissions to be turned on, but they still haven't been turned on yet. I wanted to start from scratch without the baggage of my last runs here on MS, but I can't wait anymore so screw it.

So here is what I have through page 20.

Page 1

hebichan broke the silence.
gonkbadoop taskmaster smiled at her.

Zachstralkita stood up, shouted "ONE OF THEM IS SCUM!", and pointed his finger at hebichan.
gonk smiled ironically at him.

hebichan asked for a new liver and pointed her finger at gonk.
Zach, still pointing at Hebichan, laughed and said "I am a Miller".
gonk smiled at Zach and pointed their fingers at hebi.

PeregrineV woke up, and hebichan was still talking about livers.
Annoyed, he took a step towards Zach, intending to question him.
Arcade Pals burst onto the scene, immediately pointing their fingers at Zach saying "I KNOW HIM, HE IS NOT THIS WAY AS TOWN, HE IS SCUM" confident vote!
gonk jumped in between Arcade and Zach, demanding a source of information for Arcade's claims.

hebichan saw Arcade pointing at Zach. Then, shrugging her shoulders, she pointed at Zach too. Zach immediately offered a truce, which hebichan was eager to negotiate.

What are the relationships between gonk, Arcade, Zach, and Hebi?

Page 2-5ish

Zach is rambling.
gonk is defensive.
Arcade is bulldogging Zach.

LasagneBot makes smalltalk.
hebi cavorts with Zach.
Arcade Pals calls the pot black.

gonk defends Zach.
Zach playfights with "Dunn".
Zach softclaims for fun.

Hebi offers Zach a truce:
"Don't vote PV or Arcade Pals
and I might sheep for youse!"

Arcade fishes for PV's flavor.
gonk defends Zach.
gonk said he was sheeping Zach.

Zach softclaims again.
gonk praises Arcade.

Banter Banter,
Getting Tired,
Zach votes for Lycanfire.

Hebi votes for Lycanfire.
gonk suggests that Zach flavor claim.
Arcade agrees that Zach should flavor claim.
Zach refuses!
"Premature!" he scoffs!

Arcade tells the room "Dunn here"
gonk votes for Zach
gonk smiles and rolls their eyes at Arcade three times.

gonk convinces Zach to claim The Kidney.
gonk says there is no reason not to claim.
Zach claims.

gonk and Arcade appear to be working as a team.
Zach seems very defensive.
I guess hebi is happy the spotlight is off her for the moment.

Through page 20

Arcade

: Rolefishing, role speculation, distractions, "I'm keeping my vote here" post, claims, tells others to stop claiming.

gonk

: distractions, fluff, starts arguments but won't debate, votes hebichan but claims liver

Zach

: fluff, another claim, questions gonk on logic, but gets brushed off without an answer, comes back saying gonk is a townread, overreacts to rb, rambles on about his meta, posts image "the saddest thing about betrayal is that it never comes from your enemies". Calls out Hebi for her flip-flop, keeps arguing with the people voting for him. spends a lot of time defending himself.

Hebi

: claims with no prodding: flavor is part of the kidney, (page 1 suggests she needs a liver), under pressure from Spiffeh's vote, hebi gives up her lycanfire votes for Zach, hebi claims they were never on the same side and claims she doesn't have any better votes. hebi softclaims, challenges Spiffey to get a wagon going, but then asks Zach to stop voting for her.

In conclusion, I suggest we lynch Arcade and gonk. The others need keeping an eye on.

VOTE: gonkbadoop taskmaster

Sincerely,
TPFKAP
/tip * fkap/

i just happened to see this post. if it isnt satire, this is mafia

[gerryoat]

bro i said hebichan was mafia 40 pages ago, and just after seeing that post, i never want to change my vote till she is lynched this game

[gerryoat]

arcade is scum but i said i wouldnt vote them today. sad

[gerryoat]

arcade whats your read on hebichan

[gerryoat]

if you vote them then you won't be wagoned

why do people always say this. its always a bad reason regardless of situation. i never worry about being wagoned, as scum or as town

[gerryoat]

It'd make more sense for town to have a backup doc than two docs.

i was just in a game with 2 docs lol

[gerryoat]

OK SO, I've caught up. and why is everyone still so scummy

[gerryoat]

I would still prefer to lynch hebichan.

[gerryoat]

gerryoat probably has a red pm

that is an obscene gesture in some cultures and i reported that post to the mods.

did you

thats a weird thing to say and not vote me

[gerryoat]

i'll give pork more posts, but yeah that one post was bad

[gerryoat]

whats your read on hebichan

[gerryoat]

VOTE: Arcade

i went back on my word. im a monster

[gerryoat]

Maria why do one of us always get lynched early, why can't we stay longer in a game together.

[gerryoat]

quicc hammer before they get bacc

[gerryoat]

gerry might be scum

its like a broken record, I hear someone say this exact words whenever i'm town.

[gerryoat]

UNVOTE:

[gerryoat]

If I die tonight, LUV is scum.

hate this line

VOTE: Game

[gerryoat]

actually wait. get this VOTE: porkens

[gerryoat]

@transcend

its time

[gerryoat]

Let the... PT checker check one of the doctor claims



I don't think you should lynch Game Replacement if you don't want to lynch Arcade Pals


do Carcalilly or Porkens, the slot that has supposedly scumclaimed.

ok.....vote pork if you arent already

[gerryoat]

If I die tonight, LUV is scum.

hate this line

VOTE: Game

Because you're scum together?!

wow you should be an detective.

[gerryoat]

NO MORE PORK. NO MORE PORK! SAY IT WITH ME!

[gerryoat]

All of gerryoat's posts are garbage

[gerryoat]

Carca, SlySly and Gerry all take home for garbage posting for me here.

Not just because gerry tunneled me for half of this day.

YOU ARE SHEEPING ME AND CALLING MY READS GARBAGE. WHAT...

[gerryoat]

hebichan, you think im mafia correct? you said it earlier. yet you join my wagon. why? at least explain that. i'll give you a chance

[gerryoat]

Actually I'm sheeping zach, I get its your wagon and all, but I just want to get a lynch in, and I do want to townblock with zach.

he's sheeping me....so....you are sheeping me...do you....understand this.....

[gerryoat]

As zach said, porken probably flips green, but also hasn't contributed nearly anything

WHAT LOL

[gerryoat]

I CANT DO THIS ANYMORE LOL

VOTE: HEBICHAN

IM NEVER UNVOTING. UNTIL I'M GONE OR SHES GONE.

[gerryoat]

Speaking of that image

Can It continues to discredit me with funny cutesy pictures, continues to do nothing, and everyone is letting it happen

then make good posts. you are trashing mine, but then get upset when someone does it to you lol

[gerryoat]

i can't follow hebichan's logic at all. even if shes was being bad town, at least i could follow her line of thinking regardless if it was bad or not. but it literally. makes 0 sense at all. all of her reads

[gerryoat]

Are you actually defending Can It's contribution here and acting like I'M the problem?

never said you were the problem. how about instead of saying my posts are garbage, you try and engage me? kinda like, i'm doing to you now?

[gerryoat]

zzzzzzz this is stupid. if hebi becomes a wagon again I'll push you over it LOL

You act like i CARE lol

[gerryoat]

I'd rather be lynched while being right then just jump on a wrong wagon to not be lynched

[gerryoat]

What I'm saying is that painting cute pictures to "address" my calling them out is causing people to overlook my points

You are Exhibit A (assuming you're town)

(Asssssuming i'm town) i still talking to you, which the pictures didnt stop me.

[gerryoat]

Nothing funnier than ppl that threaten to wagon someone as if that's supposed to scare them into doing something.

[gerryoat]

can someone that townreads hebichan tell me why in detail? maybe i'm missing something. my radar has been going off all game and I haven't seen not 1 post that makes me want to change my mind at all

[gerryoat]

it is really hard to get a picture on can it

hahaha

[gerryoat]

really though, can someone tell me why hebichan is town.

[gerryoat]

I don't get the scum reads on Pork.

he makes a long post about pages 1-10 and tries to justify obvious joking posts. and then his next and only post is to jump on a wagon who he thought would get hammered soon

[gerryoat]

It's not going to be as funny when you get to L-2 and are somehow confused as to why

pls dont vote me, im so scared

[gerryoat]

I don't get the scum reads on Pork.

he makes a long post about pages 1-10 and tries to justify obvious joking posts. and then his next and only post is to jump on a wagon who he thought would get hammered soon

Eh.

And he didn't say anything when he naked vote so how did you come to this conclusion?

well, it's pretty obvious.

[gerryoat]

still havent got 1 person to tell me why they think hebichan is town

[gerryoat]

her reaction to narna's gambit clears her in my eyes

"OMG MASON ME WITH UR NON BELIEVABLE ROLE!! IM TOWN!!"

that?

[gerryoat]

arcade pals had gerry

what is THAT supposed to mean.

[gerryoat]

arcade pals had gerry

what is THAT supposed to mean.

It means that no one has liked your posting this game. I thought that should be very apparent from the multiple people calling you out.

you had a wagon, i havent. thus my posting better

[gerryoat]

i will miss you can it

[gerryoat]

only vote that wagon is missing is pork's

[gerryoat]

>brags about her wagon

>says the wagon is shit a few posts later

lol

[gerryoat]

i wish i asked can it to make a paint read about me. this game will forever be on my list of regrets now

[gerryoat]

hebichan, can you link me a town game of yours that you've completed? i'll give you one more chance. if i see posts that are similar here, i will unvote you

[gerryoat]

im trying really hard to find a reason for you to be town, maybe it's the snivy avi. i must support fellow pokemon users

[gerryoat]

ok ill look at it tomorrow i guess

[gerryoat]

i like lynching 2 shot claims. but i dont wanna lynch maria or dunn. help

[gerryoat]

trust me gerry i was in a 42 player game with her and i wanted to lynch her since like page 3

she wasn't scum lol

IN FACT you were supposed to hydra me and maria but you DIPPED

pedit: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

LOOOL that game. i didnt even know how to use the site then. we should all hydra something tho again

[gerryoat]

trust me gerry i was in a 42 player game with her and i wanted to lynch her since like page 3

she wasn't scum lol

IN FACT you were supposed to hydra me and maria but you DIPPED

pedit: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

LOOOL that game. i didnt even know how to use the site then. we should all hydra something tho again

i still have the elitism account and its pw, i wouldn't mind giving it another go

i haven't had a legit epicmafia hydra on this site yet soooo

ok lets do it

[gerryoat]

I mean, tunneling me from page one doesn't really feel like you're trying to town read me all that hard, and I sort of scum read you at this point, so suspect away?

Like, I love komeada, so I'm not going to take this game too personally but the fact you only seem to read every other post and tunnel me for things other people are doing worse isn't making me super fond of reading your posts.

P-edit I feel like the rb slit has a decent shot of being scum.

its just you have posts that i usually scumread from people and its been multiple ones. hard to ignore. i've outed other scumreads, and even flipped my vote off you at one point.

[gerryoat]

i also mess up in games cause i dont go with my first gut, and then i see something that changes my mind. so maybe that's why i've been tunneling you

[gerryoat]

After deliberation with myself (because im crazy), i've determined that there is likely 2 scum teams.

[gerryoat]

I'm fairly confident.

[gerryoat]

did anyone know TPFKAP was in this game? because i didnt until i just looked at activity overview lol

[gerryoat]

the more you know

[gerryoat]

Unless you're confident because you're scum and think people are scummy but not in your qt.

see, like this post. its just so bad. but ill wait i read some of your town games to see if its worth making a long case on you

[gerryoat]

if i was mafia it would likely be obvious from how many partners i have if there was a 2nd scum team or not. town would have that thought, and wouldnt make a post like you just did. because they would think it out.

[gerryoat]

Ok. let me put it in easier terms. Your statement makes no sense because: If I was mafia, I wouldn't just think it was multiball because someone was scummy. I would think it because

1. If I only have 2 partners it's likely multiball.

2. If my faction has a unique name thats not just mafia, it's likely multiball

do you understand yet why your statement made no sense?

[gerryoat]

hi dunn, whats your read on transcend, hebichan and game replacement

[gerryoat]

how many more pages until we break a day 1 record. imma be honest, i'm going for it again.

[gerryoat]

we need like 1000 more posts nvm lol

[gerryoat]

from the look of things. I see one of: Arcade, pork, carc, game being lynched today.

[gerryoat]

Out of those,I'd prefer: Pork > Game > Arcade > Carc

How would everyone else rank that list?

[gerryoat]

honestly havent even read carc, but his wagon is suspect af

[gerryoat]

her*

[gerryoat]

nvm i can see why people are voting her now lol

[gerryoat]

nvm i can see why people are voting her now lol

You aren't convincing me you were actually reading the game until now.

i clearly was reading when i was pointing out all the flaws in your posts, so idk what you mean. and i've been here this whole time. look at the activity log.

[gerryoat]

nvm i can see why people are voting her now lol

You aren't convincing me you were actually reading the game until now.

i clearly was reading when i was pointing out all the flaws in your posts, so idk what you mean. and i've been here this whole time. look at the activity log.

You haven't read carca at all before now to your own admission? And reading my posts specifically to tunnel me isn't the same as reading the game.

obviously i've read some posts but i havent iso'd them. doesnt mean i havent been reading the game.

[gerryoat]

nvm i can see why people are voting her now lol

You aren't convincing me you were actually reading the game until now.

i clearly was reading when i was pointing out all the flaws in your posts, so idk what you mean. and i've been here this whole time. look at the activity log.

You haven't read carca at all before now to your own admission? And reading my posts specifically to tunnel me isn't the same as reading the game.

obviously i've read some posts but i havent iso'd them. doesnt mean i havent been reading the game.

I've brought them up several times to you specifically, why would you only look at it now if you were honestly trying to solve the game?

because I think you are mafia, i dont care for your reads lol

[gerryoat]

i dont think i need to point out the contradiction there.

[gerryoat]

has posted very little content.

[gerryoat]

PV asking the important questions

[gerryoat]

i think we still have like a week

[gerryoat]

at this point, i just want a lynch. let me check something before i vote

[gerryoat]

VOTE: Game Replacement

this is mafia, i think. dont like the carc wagon, even though carc's posts have been bleh. i can see them flipping town. prob lynchbait for scum.

[gerryoat]

would rather game replacement.

[gerryoat]

Carca is lynchbait. Spiffeh is prob town for can it interactions. Arcade pals, meh. i kinda dont wanna lynch it. can we lynch Game Replacement? lol

[gerryoat]

Going on vacation. Will check in sometimes.

This is you every game minus the vacation. Lol

[gerryoat]

LMAO

[gerryoat]

Lynch game. Before we break a record

[gerryoat]

We could just all settle on hebichan as the lynch. That would be great

[gerryoat]

I think carca is one of the biggest. But I think that's bad town

[gerryoat]

But you new immigrants have brought your shit culture with you

Spotted the Trump voter

[gerryoat]

Holy shit Narna just got banned. Apparently was exposed as a white nationalist.

Fucking scumbag.

EBWOP.

LMAO IS THIS LEGIT?

[gerryoat]

See what happens when you sheep the goat. You lynch mefia. I'll catch up in a sec. But there are a few slots I wanna turbo lunch

[gerryoat]

See what happens when you sheep the goat. You lynch mefia. I'll catch up in a sec. But there are a few slots I wanna turbo lunch

*hands you a copy of LLD's "How to bus bad scum partners for EZ town cred."*

I pray you are cleared somehow cause I'm vig shooting you after I read

[gerryoat]

LOL Maf shot the miller claim. i didnt know this was a GT game

[gerryoat]

anyways in terms of flavor i think we can infer that all mafia roles have negative connotations to them such as blood disease and all town roles don't such as kidney and white blood cell.

I can agree with this, also i think there is more than 1 maf team based on that scum PM. do you agree?

[gerryoat]

I have town reads on Transcend, Vecna, Arcade Pals, hebichan, gerryoat

I can´t understand the TR on Arcade or on Hebichan at all.

[gerryoat]

VOTE: Lycan
I'm shocked that flipped scum this needs to die he isn't scumhunting he just tunnels on us to get out of it. He doesn't even try that hard to get us lynched or explain why we're scum this is flipping scum.

why wouldnt you vote your most likely guilty result right away even if you werent sure if you should claim the result or not¿¿¿¿

[gerryoat]

VOTE: Arcade Pals

This is a bad vote based on the sequences of posts that happened beforehand to this vote. Arcade just said they had a guilty and he quick votes the bandwagon. But then again, I´m still curious on Arcade.

[gerryoat]

What if SlySly and Arcade are scum buds

whoa you read my mind

[gerryoat]

anyways in terms of flavor i think we can infer that all mafia roles have negative connotations to them such as blood disease and all town roles don't such as kidney and white blood cell.

I can agree with this, also i think there is more than 1 maf team based on that scum PM. do you agree?

why did you think it was multiball before that scum pm?

cause i´m a smart goat. baaaaa

[gerryoat]

fwiw zach was sus of gerry iirc

i led on maf. bad dog. i literally helped swing a bw over obvious lynchbait. I wouldn´t have a reason to do that as scum. If somehow Carc flips scum this game, then maybe I can see your case as to why I can be scum. For once I TR you though

[gerryoat]

I wanted Narna's masonry to be real so I could make a giant masonry between 5 people...

Seriously, why would I want a masonry as scum?

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.......

[gerryoat]

Hey I think we have a redirector. I think it makes a lot of sense for certain reasons that should not be said rn

[gerryoat]

UNVOTE:

I don't like how people who were calling for our lynch instantly believed our result

Hey I think you´re town or at least not mafia if there is a 3rd party. But before I can welcome you to the non´scum club. I need to know why you voted lyca right away instead of your potential guilty, even though you werent sure whether you wanted to out it or not

[gerryoat]

I'm a Town 2-shot Parity Cop.

My action fails if I target Godfather, Mason, Innocent Child, Traitor, or Miller

I pick 2, results are if they are the same alignment.

I targeted gerryoat & hebichan: no result.

Flavor: Lymphocyte

UNVOTE: hebichan

o fuk you found out im godfather!!

[gerryoat]

That was way too early of a claim and very convienient

[gerryoat]

So Gerry is not the same alignment as Hebi?

reading is hard

[gerryoat]

wait why the hell would you target me and hebichan¿¿ like we literally tunneled each other all day

[gerryoat]

fwiw zach was sus of gerry iirc

i led on maf. bad dog. i literally helped swing a bw over obvious lynchbait. I wouldn´t have a reason to do that as scum. If somehow Carc flips scum this game, then maybe I can see your case as to why I can be scum. For once I TR you though

I helped swing a vote off arcade onto GR.

You tried to get a wagon on me more than GR.

i settled on scum, swhile you were trying to lynch obvious lynchbait. so your question makes no sense

[gerryoat]

And ...


I also believe slysly due to the miller

Let's go ahead and stop being dipshits now

Fucking god damned morons.

who is your scum pool

[gerryoat]

wait why the hell would you target me and hebichan¿¿ like we literally tunneled each other all day

I townread you, I SR hebichan.

I searched for mason, IC and miller crumbs and targeted where I found nothing.

Okay, i believe you

[gerryoat]

I dunno

I have to be on not mobile to give an adequate scum pool.

who do you scumread the most

[gerryoat]

That wasn't a hammer I think.
But this is.

VOTE: Arcade

Night! \o/

based on context, i think arcade might be town. (again)

[gerryoat]

Fuck you transcend.

u chill too

He's the one calling me an idiot. Don't tell me to chill.

everyone R E L A X.

[gerryoat]

torgonitoh help

who of game replacement and tpfkap is the scum? 1 must die now

Neither are scum.
Grapes or Carca.
Carca dodging the thread now she isn't being pushed. That's typical scum her!

Scum in Zach/Bins/LUV too.

He bussed at least one of Grapes-Carca-Bins-LUV

Not Carca imo. so One of Grapes-Bins-LUV is scum

[gerryoat]

Also I take back that TR on Arcade. He was willing to ¨hammer¨ Arcade but not put them in the scumpool while trying to save himself. maybe im just overthinking but yeah

[gerryoat]

its so easy to tie me to vedith, i know

but yeah he just completely fooled me and i didnt want the doc to die
vedith is so completely readable idk how i always get it wrong

Bins

B - Bins
I - Is
N - Now
S - Scum

[gerryoat]

Please don't trust anything flip scum say lol

This post screams mafia to me

[gerryoat]

Just learned there was someone named hopkirk in this game. learn something new every day

[gerryoat]

(Thats my distance post. how did I do?)

[gerryoat]

Town: ME!!!!!!!!!!!!, Transcend, Carca,
Don´t wanna lynch: Arcade, Hebichan (sadly), PV, Sly, Can it slot (cba to look to check who it is now)


just posting this for myself later since i prob won´t be on a computer again until later

[gerryoat]

Please don't trust anything flip scum say lol

This post screams mafia to me

Do you think Luv takes the angle of "I'm lol hammering everything that gets to L1 except for GR" if they're buddies? Because that seems really bold.

I wouldnt lolhammer my mafia doctor lol

[gerryoat]

I was kidding about being a day vig. But, it´s likely we have a vig in this game. and another mafia team or 3rd party as i said. Only reason for there to be a mafia doc obviously.

[gerryoat]

I´m just surprised only one person died tonight. Especially after a mafia doc got lynched, you´d think there would be at least a vig shot

[gerryoat]

I was kidding about being a day vig. But, it´s likely we have a vig in this game. and another mafia team or 3rd party as i said. Only reason for there to be a mafia doc obviously.

You are correct about this

But only one kill tonight is \_O_/

yeah that was my next post lol

[gerryoat]

I very much want Uzi Vert vigged tonight fwiw

i concur with this statement

[gerryoat]

I have trouble believing we have both a vig and another scum team when only 1 person died though

could be ª reason for this

[gerryoat]

I very much want Uzi Vert vigged tonight fwiw

That would not be wise Doggo!

[gerryoat]

So I am pretty sure that the attack on Zach did not come from Mafia and that they shot me

I feel like based on how you play you woulda just said that right away as town and tried to lead lol. why not just say that right away

[gerryoat]

This is starting to feel like a role madness

[gerryoat]

Wait RC replaced Gork? that means RC is prob town, damn.

[gerryoat]

Okay, I will believe the shot thing for now, RC why do you think mafia hit you? I have a reason, but I wanna hear yours

[gerryoat]

Nah.

Vote: Hebichan

Sadly we shouldn't vote her today. It's not optimal.

[gerryoat]

transcendog, lets nuke the LUV slot

L - Lets
U - Unite
V - Votes

VOTE: LUV

[gerryoat]

LUV or Bins should be the lynch today.

[gerryoat]

Carca, I get you. I feel it too. But she's not the lynch today

[gerryoat]

VOTE: Bins

this or LUV gets lynched today

[gerryoat]

you realize game replacement just mentioned the names of the people who were online as he got lynched


you do realize this

why are you putting any weight in this

even without that, you are still scummy from yesterday.

[gerryoat]

>still thinking carca is scum

>lol

[gerryoat]

she might be on a different scumteam, but idk

[gerryoat]

she might be on a different scumteam, but idk

scumslip?

yes, i scumslipped saying that you might be on a different scumteam than vedith

[gerryoat]

but carca is prob bad town. now if we could get more bin votes. that would be swell

[gerryoat]

ok i keep thinking i have the mental fortitude for this but i really dont

btw i didnt realize trans outted the fact he roleswapped which ive been well aware of that since like d1 and wanted to take the bullet but thought the way i handled rb's claim kind of would have made it too obvious that i didnt have a cc so :/ - meaningless but as scum i would probably have shot there and the fact that i was well aware this was occurring should be obvious from my iso

i wanted to take a week long vla and have schadd man the hydra but i dont really want to do that without giving some stance of my own since i havent had the chance to compile my thoughts in a long time. but not having time for mafia also means not having time for real life and i really need to sort myself out rn. idk

i dont really see what was really terrible about the one post i made this dp tbh? im not really going to harp about it though

looking at the playerlist though i feel like we're working with a really tight POE right now - hebi, lycan, gerry, pv, hopkirk, toroginitoh, trans, raybells, vecna, and grapes all seem like really horrible lynches to me at the present so im trying to work from that but every time i read i just feel lost in things like the claims

like? claims alone slysly's role and AP's role dont really make sense to me. with the survivor claim and the masonry i think it makes perfect sense for scum to have some way of figuring out the masonry, and slysly's role cant do that as well as AP's. slysly, from an informed perspective, can basically only find survivors and gets false positives on the roles that scum would actually want to find (traitor, masons, ic i guess?), while ap is basically the opposite in that they can get an actual result on a mason (though it's the same as a survivor neighbor) and having the ninja passive lets them choose between not having to establish fake claims or getting towncred for claiming something unusual. i dont really understand why theres hesitancy to lynch here besides them being prs. i'd vote them rn but schadd thinks it's wasted effort and i guess i can respect that. the best compromise would probably to leash AP onto carcalilly or a future vt claim and work from there - maybe have slysly parity her against someone (not sure if the mechanical play here is to parity vs someone obvtown like transcend or vs someone who needs to be sorted)? i recognize i'm not really in a position to call any shots but im really not happy with where claims are and if im wrong and both ap and slysly are town then that means theres a lot we can get out of playing our cards right as a town.

anyway

VOTE: tpfkap

ive been looking through isos though and i think this is the right call - schadd hasnt gotten back to me though

i think it takes a very specific kind of... bad... to think that the transcend slot is still scum here or even insinuate that kraska/rb could be scum theatre. i dont know if it's me personally knowing the context of that drama but rb has a very strange and disgusting vendetta against kraska and has harassed her offsite - him thinking that kraska was "attacking" him or some shit is flat out wrong and the way he reacted to kraska's obvious counterclaim showed a very specific kind of scum detachment that doesnt make sense in theatre. had i had the chance to talk during d1 about this (irl not mafia reasons prevented me obv) this is what my GR case would have been - rb picking completely incorrect reasons people interact with him they way they have comes from not having the need to actually engage with the gamestate and understand people. this is besides the fact trans and kraska have both been playing to their town metas strongly and both are not very good at hiding their metas from me

tpfkap trying to reach ('doctor is a scum role in this setup') and keep trans in the lynchpool i feel is a scum thought process - most of her pushes as well seem like very obviously not-mafia slots to me. im also having a hard time following some of the reasoning behind the scumreads and how they actually translate to scumreads - like my slot's, for example.

He manipulated you into claiming your flavor between day 1 and day 20 (a few hours?)
Gonk buddied up to you right away by following your vote on hebi.
Gonk jumped in to defend you against Arcade's meta case.
Gonk continued to defend you and sheeped.
After you had softclaimed twice, suddenly gonk starts praising Arcade.
Then, after you and hebi agreed to a Lycanfire wagon, gonk suggested you flavor claim.
Arcade agreed.
You said no.
Arcade says "dunn here",
and gonk votes for you and shoots smilies at Arcade.
gonk says there is no reason not to claim, and you do.

like im struggling to see how this warrants... any sort of read?

you could argue that my thought process was inconsistent or something (i dont really like the insinuation i defended zach but then attacked him?? i wanted dunn to substantiate his thought process because having played with zach i saw zero reason to make that sort of meta call on him, then zach started to act weird when i asked him to flavor claim so i scumread him...), but that sort of call is never made. instead the scumminess of my slot comes from me pressuring a miller to claim flavor which is???? not scummy? like it's one thing to randomly pressure someone to claim a role but it's fucking flavor - all it does is check the validity of a claim (and kidney didnt make sense to me as a miller). there isnt any follow through to actually substantiate why any of this is scummy. it's surface level thinking.

i dont really care about the pr claim. it's bullshit i've seen from scum plenty of times and have zero qualms pressuring there if the person is going to play like a scumfuck

if schadd disagrees with me then he's free to move my vote but this is where i'm at. PW/spiffeh could also use resolution at some point - i think schadd and i are at odds (i'm liking spiffeh less and have been ok with the last posts in PW's iso) so i'd rather have us converse about that first though.

anyway,

@mods giga head is going to be v/la for like the next week. again i just need to sort myself out and i really dont have the time for mafia anymore and worrying about getting prodded/not contributing enough is starting to affect my mental health. schadd will take over while i try to sort my shit out and get back on my feet again

if raybells or vecna or trans are on in the next half hour or so we can talk, i realize i havent been pulling the weight i know i can and i dont really mind you think i'm scum as a result because my head is not entirely in the game like it has been during all of my scum games on this site besides my first but that's a really shitty tell for me if that's what you're reading into.

pedit:

but carca is prob bad town. now if we could get more bin votes. that would be swell

i've been coming around on carca!town but i dont really have an issue with bins - can you like sparknotes her for me

tl;dr

[gerryoat]

I LUV a BINS lynch

[gerryoat]

fkin hell, stop with these bad votes people. the people you voting MAY be scum, but it's suboptimal to lynch them today. do an optimal lynch aka: LUV or Bins

[gerryoat]

Never seen you put this much stock into flipped scum Gerry lol

it doesnt have to do with him flipping scum, and this is part of the reason I think you're scum. youre just shading instead of trying to come to a solution.

[gerryoat]

can you sparknotes bins for me gerry i dont really see anything wrong with her and iirc schadd thinks shes town

for one she hard protected mafia doc for little to no reason.

[gerryoat]

I did a quick iso on bins to try and find a reason not to lynch her and it only made me wanna lynch her more. sorry

[gerryoat]

Not sure why you're expecting me to solve the game as if it's LYLO/MYLO or we've caught all the scum lol

Pretty devasted from the GR flip so I soft reset.

If I didn't know any better I'd say your pushing this hard because you can't push Hebi anymore..

mooooooooreeeeee shhaaaaaaaadddddiiiiinnnnnnnnnggggggggg

[gerryoat]

whyyy would there be 2 scum docs. if anything its prob 1 scum doc and one jailkeeper on the other team. or BP

[gerryoat]

arcade isnt being lynched today, deal with it. lets have productive discussions, not on slots that wont be lynched today

[gerryoat]

people who think it's multiball: show your work

just seems like that type of game to me. plus RC already claimed 3rd party already, even tho the claim is prob BS. i still think there is a 3p or 2nd mafia team

[gerryoat]

VOTE: arcade pals


fwiw i was joking but continue i guess

ive never seen someone scumclaim so hard in one post but here we are

[gerryoat]

hebichan is just godawful town at this point, and it pains me to say so. i cant even see mafia saying half the things she spews.

[gerryoat]

POWERFUL WARRIOR. You should just VOTE BINS. Cause looking how things are going today, you are most likely the settle lynch

[gerryoat]

VOTE: gerryoat

Got a chance to sit down and read some stuff and feel really good about a lynch here.

Decided that Sly will be easier to sort tomorrow; but in the meantime I'd like to know why he voted arcade pals at daystart when he had the result he did, and why he hesitated to vote hebichan.

idk if you're bad at mafia or scum

[gerryoat]

i mean i think he might be but i need like a solid case that isn't meta to want to push there

DEAR GOD. EVEN WHEN IM OBVIOUS TOWN I GET SCUMREAD. LOL

[gerryoat]

I literally pushed people onto scum, and i get scumread. it's fine. i know i wont be the lynch today

[gerryoat]

I'm not softing anything, it's just obvious