Given the randomised setup, I'm not going to be enormously convinced by any claim that can't be proven since it's trivial for someone to pick a possible role that matches their discard. I think she's still our best bet for hitting scum based on how she's been acting.
In post 267, Vaxkiller wrote:
I say we keep her alive and see what kind of NK's we got. Do NK's have flavor attached to them? If wolves are out there they will want her dead, if shes alive and there is wolf NK flavor then kill her.
In post 289, Vaxkiller wrote:I want to wait on chickadee and lynch someone who is not actively participating in the conversation here.
Plus Vax's sudden attempt to save her is fascinating and I want to see her flip because of it.
I'm not going to be able to participate too much, deadline is an awkward time for me.
Please become surer in the next 7 hours if you can
Could be seer and no wolves yeah. Means there's no way to check if her claim is legit though, like Mulch (I think) said - she can just claim anyone is not a wolf and she's pretty likely to be correct.
In post 276, Chickadee wrote:If I do live, I can at least find out if someone is a wolf or not. It will either be a guilty or a semi-clear on someone.
It's barely a clear at all. Like a tracker no visit - just because they didn't carry out the kill doesn't mean they're not scum. It's only really useful if it gets a guilty.
I think the chance of her being scum is high, and the potential loss of a seer is not dealbreaking enough to prefer a different lynch.
In post 309, Keychain wrote:Please become surer in the next 7 hours if you can
Could be seer and no wolves yeah. Means there's no way to check if her claim is legit though, like Mulch (I think) said - she can just claim anyone is not a wolf and she's pretty likely to be correct.
In post 276, Chickadee wrote:If I do live, I can at least find out if someone is a wolf or not. It will either be a guilty or a semi-clear on someone.
It's barely a clear at all. Like a tracker no visit - just because they didn't carry out the kill doesn't mean they're not scum. It's only really useful if it gets a guilty.
I think the chance of her being scum is high, and the potential loss of a seer is not dealbreaking enough to prefer a different lynch.
I did say SEMI-CLEAR. As in, we would know that person isn't a wolf.
Also, after my lynch, I invite you to check out my wiki and look at my town games. It's a grand display of D1 mislynches.
Yes, very much so. I don't have many scum games, but the ones I do have, two of them are perfect scum wins, and one I had replaced into a slot that was obvscum and about to be lynched and I survived 2 more days.
In post 313, Chickadee wrote:I just have a hard time getting into the swing of things as town.
So... if you hypothetically had the choice... you would discard a town role in preference of a scum role?
I can relate to not being able to get into the swing of things, as a general rule. I'm pretty fecking awkward. But it's not a good reason not to lynch you. Sorry.
We've less than five hours left. If you're around, do you mind giving your thoughts on each of the eight players that aren't you? Can be as long or short as you like. What has stood out about their play? Which way are you leaning on them?
Also
people
Deadline is rapidly approaching and a no lynch would be really bad
In post 313, Chickadee wrote:I just have a hard time getting into the swing of things as town.
So... if you hypothetically had the choice... you would discard a town role in preference of a scum role?
I can relate to not being able to get into the swing of things, as a general rule. I'm pretty fecking awkward. But it's not a good reason not to lynch you. Sorry.
We've less than five hours left. If you're around, do you mind giving your thoughts on each of the eight players that aren't you? Can be as long or short as you like. What has stood out about their play? Which way are you leaning on them?
Also
people
Deadline is rapidly approaching and a no lynch would be really bad
I would have much preferred to be any of the scum factions. But I was dealt two town roles.
And doing the work of listing out what I think of all the slots seems really pointless when y'all are going to lynch me anyway. But I'll do it. It's not going to help you, since I don't have much to say.
Please no one hammer me while I fulfill this one request.
If we had more time I think chick would live but deadline lynches suck
Pretty sure chick is L2 rn
THIS POST IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT.
Keychain - scum lean. gut
vonflare - Town feels. I like where he's pushing and questioning things.
Vaxkiller - Possible scum? interactions seem forced and awkward.
Creature - Town - seems invested in the game. This read is mostly gut.
WhyMafia - null
Agent Sparkles - null
Mulch - Might be scum....he used a paragraph...
Srceenplay - town lean? Gut
Like I said, not a lot of help to y'all. My gut does you no good.
Always useful to have, since I can't exactly ask after you're dead. Thank you. Everyone is leaning gut scum on me, sigh.
If you could go further into your Creature and Vax reads in particular, I'd be interested, but I've only got five minutes before I'm occupied for the next four hours.
vonflare wrote:If we had more time I think chick would live but deadline lynches suck
Pretty sure chick is L2 rn
I like this lynch but yeah, not great to be trapped at deadline. I'm more worried about a no lynch tbh
Creature I've talked about. In my experience, creature is largely uninvested as scum. He's even said that he doesn't like scum. He seems invested here, and given the set up, he very well could have had a choice in his alignment. He's in my town pile until given a reason not to be.
Vax, I just feel like his play has been clunky. His reads change too quickly and without explanation or questions.
In post 321, Keychain wrote:Creature doesn't seem hugely invested to me but okay.
What do you think about Vax suddenly trying to stop your lynch?
PEdit: case in point...
It does give him some town points in my book.
He's one of the few that have been looking at my claim rationally I think. But there's still a lot of other odd interactions there.
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Keychain
@Keychain I get that you don't want a no lynch, and I wouldn't either. I don't think my lynch particularly helps town though. Why are you pushing for my lynch so hard?
do you tend to last longer as scum?
