Normal 1934: Civilization Mafia Mafia (Endgame)

[Vecna]

We should get him to live communicate with a bunch of people at once - I feel that if he's town and he gets into a flow of talk with people his thought process will make his allignment very blatantly clear.

Id say we should try to set that up to be able to decide if where this current lynch is going is the correct course of action.

Tchill, you down for that?

[Robbnva]

I wish those kinds of conversations would happen every game

[Vecna]

In my mind I have this triangle-shape like this;

Tchill - Korts
\ /
Monkey


And where there is probably 1 scum in the 3. Monkey being scum, ruling out the other 2 as being scum, Tchill being scum ruling out the other 2 as scum etc. Based on the way these 3 slots have been interacting. Korts has been rather critical of Monkey, both of them have been quite on Tchill. The way all of their interactions have been feel rather genuine, and either TvS or SvT - but not really like theyre scum teammates putting on a show.

[Vecna]

Well that triangle shape got dun fucked up

[Sunlit Diamond]

This game feels strange.... I'm having trouble engaging, and it's not for lack of content considering how much people have written.

I need to do a reread and a thorough analysis and see if that changes things. These take me a while because of work and kid, but I'll get it done today.

p-edit: that triangle makes a lot of sense to me Vecna. I'll keep it in mind as I read.

[Robbnva]

that's probably my fault Sunlit. That seems to be a common occurrence in games where I am the aggressor.

[Ginngie]

Yo Robb, you scumread Eddie right.

They're partners!AF with TChill.

Flip TChill today, Eddie tomorrow.

*finger guns*

[Robbnva]

How are they partners? Nobody even agrees Eddie is scum so if you think he's scum maybe you can convince people to listen

[Vecna]

im not sure whether im buying that you genuinely think you alteady caught 2 scum this early gin....

[Ginngie]

How are they partners? Nobody even agrees Eddie is scum so if you think he's scum maybe you can convince people to listen

Lol 393 read the game

If you see me actually make a noteworthy post, read it

[Ginngie]

im not sure whether im buying that you genuinely think you alteady caught 2 scum this early gin....

I don't, I caught all 3.

Again, read 393

[Grendel]

Vecna Aristophanes

- Gotta love replacing into a slot that hasnt done much and is already under suspicion

Wait are you saying that you were town reading the slot you subbed into before you got in here? Why, Ari did nothing this game?

I agree that Eddie, and Rob are TvT tho.

I just don't like people saying I'm not doing a good job convincing others when nobody has even attempted to convince me. I'm also not interested in tchill anymore.

Eddie/massive and idk who is my 3rd. Maybe black or korts but idk. Monkey doesn't impress me either but my gut says he's town for now and idk what my gut is even using to decide that.

I just can't see past Eddie rn so maybe this game break will help. But if he isn't lynched and we lynch a townie I'm gonna be pissed.

When I get a chance to sit down later tonight I can talk more about my Eddie/Percy read. Will you be here for that?

[Robbnva]

i don't leave until tomorrow morning at 5 am so probably can see what you have to say. Though if it is a post explaining why they aren't scum i'll be honest and probably not put much weight in it. I don't think anything can change my read of that slot

[humaneatingmonkey]

I'm gonna make everyone's jaw drop and pre-emptively say (even before publishing my analysis) that while Korts and I aren't the best of friends, I townread him. Korts is just naturally hostile and I'm naturally a monkey.

[humaneatingmonkey]

Robb's sorry story is off. I don't buy that he's upset. That's a huge shift in tone which nullifies any townread I had with him so far? I think it's a very calculated AtE?

But if you really are, I'll make a sidenote and say that I'm your friend outside of this game. It's not really a player vs player but a slot vs slot—except when it gets personal. And I have nothing personal against you, Rob.

[Robbnva]

so I am using ate in all of the games I am playing? gtfoh

[Vecna]

That monkey avatar is just too damn adorable

Also, im quite sure using your play in other games (that are very much ungoing) is some sort of rules-violation

[Robbnva]

don't really care. if people are going to low blow discredit me and say i am using this as a strategy they can piss off and the mod can replace me.

[Vecna]

Yeah, see in the original Civilization game a guy used that exact same line....and he was scum. It does happen, and if you bring it up in the game, it affects the game and is going to be discussed.

Not saying that you are scum, or making it up, or anything - but that is just the way it is. AtE is a used strategy in this game

[Eddie Cane]

UNVOTE:

going to enjoy my v/la weekend and reassess if I should even be playing mafia anymore since everyone thinks I am such a shitty player.

you aren't a shitty player necessarily. you should seriously try rereading your iso next to mine and Persephones. it's ok to come back and admit you were wrong, and it isn't impossible to convince me you're town. you already commented something like people townreading the scummiest player, but that should be a hint to you you should at least reevaluate.

I'll reply to more later lunch break isn't enough time for the wallposting a post restriction somewhat requires

[Sunlit Diamond]

Do you think Percy trying to add reason to his RVS a bit odd? Like as if he's trying hard not to make his vote scummy?

Well I don't consider it an rvs vote. I just never understand why people vote me for saying "sup", because this isn't the first time it's happened. Getting people to explain what their issue is I feel helps me better understand them. Right now I don't like percy's response and the old me would probably go into a death tunnel, but with limited posts and lack of cares right now I'm not going to dwell on it.

I'm rereading. I just got here.

Dude, if you enter every game with 'sup' and people vote you for it, then get your shit together, stop bitching, and use it as a reaction test. Go back and read through your old games and actually catalogue which alignment responded which way and see if there’s a pattern. USE IT.

Seriously why are you complaining about something that has so much potential?

[Robbnva]

@ eddie - please don't give me advice on how to play

@sunlit - the responses to my "sup" have been from both town and scum. It's non AI.

can't really use it as a reaction test either for reasons too complicated to explain, and shocker reasons that people don't agree with me on.

[Eddie Cane]

or act 9. that works too.

[massive]

We're getting derailed trying to give Robb advice and we aren't actually hunting scum.

After reading Vecna's posts this page, maybe nancy was right about Aristo after all.

[Tchill13]

So yall want me to hold a talk show? Lol