What we have to start with, is that one of Eddie/FL/
or Frog
is scum. I want to hear a scenario where none of them is (Thor claimed there is a chance?).
Why?
Because FL claims he got a "no result" from Eddie. Frog confirms that no one blocked FL last night, so the only scenario where a Loyaltown!CopFlavorLeaf gets the result, is when Eddie is scum. Scum FlavorLeaf could just speak the truth (loyal scum gets "no result" from town!Eddie), and scum!frog could lie that no one blocked FL. Realize that
none of them as townies have reason to lie.
I have trouble basing everything on TiaM's "claim", but I am going to trust it for now, because I do not think scum!TiaM has any reason not to claim night immunity for N1. I was sort of afraid of a BP-claim, but it didn't come.
Why was it so important for me to know that TiaM wasn't BP/commuter etc N1?
Because IF I assumed that Eddie was scum, visiting TiaM for a NK (and for specifically that) N1, there had to be a reason why TiaM (rb) didn't die.
I wanted to eliminate this simple step before continuing.
(There also has to be an explanation for Sunlit dying N1, and we should be fairly certain now that it was a scum-kill. SK was novice and I think most agreed that Vig could be too much)
Now I have already said I don't believe there to be any more protective/NK-immune roles other than Dunkers confirmed commuter, and either FL with his roleblockings and such or Eddie with Doc'ing.
It just feels excessive. So if you want to discredit this post or me overall, this is the first point to attack.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile")
Logical path A:
Eddie is a town doctor
. Notice that this path also suggests that frog is a town watcher, because Eddies claim was first, and frogs claimed night-actions support it. In this path Eddie is town, so scum!frog has absolutely no reason to back him up, when he could just avoid claiming anything on Eddies actions, rather than confirm them.
So if Eddie is town doc, frog is town watcher.
Eddies first action as Doc is to visit rb, and that also makes sense to me. He would want to protect the most obvious townie to him, and the most valuable player in his eyes. This path makes 100% sense to me as is and could also be the explanation for the consecutive no-kills. (as rb and frog are both very believable targets to me on those specific nights)
Logical path B:
Eddie is a scum doctor
. Now this is the weirdest possibility to me personally, but since it is allowed in normal games, I covered it in my mind. This would mean that N1 Eddie tried to save TiaM as scum too. I have reason to believe that unlimited-Doc in scums hands would want to keep his partner alive in a game where SK/Vig is a possibility, and therefore I believe that
if scum!Eddie saved TiaM -> TiaM is his scumbuddy
. The chances of getting towncred from saving town!TiaM N1 from a kill, from a role he didn't know existed for sure? Not reasonable, considering his partner could use the saving in the 1% chance his partner gets capped by the same potential Vig.
So scum!Eddie saving TiaM would surely mean scum!TiaM.
This is the least likely path in my mind, but there is a chance, and in the case where Eddie would be forced to flip a scum doc, we would definitely need to go for TiaM next, so easy game from there.
Logical path C:
Flavor Leaf is a town JOAT.
