<3
(Sorry for the incoming!)
In post 358, NotTheRealPaul wrote:i never said i sred u. i said i would IF u hadnt claimed bp. i said ur play was scummy not that u were scum. gawd skitters
1. ur maybe good with others but ur dead wrong here. my meta changes. if ur areogant enough to tell me what my meta is off two games where i played differently in both odk what to tell u.
2. already addressed above.
3. it is bcuz our votes were different. did u read or are u just tryna discredit me because i said ur reads are bad. if u need me to explain again: i dont like aphix's vote because a page earlier he seemed firmly against an MWAP lynch and then boom with no change in MWAP's behavior and nothing that imo couldve changed his mind he votes him. heck he even said he wouldnt vote MWAP and one page later he does and i dont get why.
I can describe my thoughts about madtatters. Jae already said a bit about dp's vote and i kinda agree. but looking back idk. tbh its kinda wierd jae didnt say the same thing to me bcuz mine was hella similar. so dp's vote isnt too bad rn.
madtatters quoted a pist by osuka that "changed" his mind but it didnt really add up to me based off the content of osuka's post. i'll get into ot more when im done with hw.
@aphix answer me im not going away.
pedit: i'll agree to disagree. im glad u find it concerning atleast. thats something we can both kinda agree on.
1. I never said you scumread me. I'm all but confirmed town, and you acknowledge that. That means that if you'd scumread my slot independently of that, you'd be reading it wrong, since you agree that I'm basically town here for mechanical reasons. And you never explained why my play is scummy. You're calling it scummy, but you're not backing it up. You're not even going with the old 'I get paranoid of skitter because I think her scumgame is good'.
2. I'm not being arrogant. I just know precisely what town!me is or isn't good at. Like, I'm bad with AtE and I get super paranoid that my townreads are pocketing me. And I'm very good with meta reads on someone I've correctly read before. You know this. I literally talked you out of getting mislynched like three times in 1797 for meta reasons. Your argument that I can't meta you is unfounded.
3. You literally said that everyone should be voting MWAP. You don't get to complain that their votes are bad after you asked them to vote that way.
4. Please explain your thoughts about madtatters.
5. Please explain your p-edit. How can you 'agree to disagree with me' about Jae but then agree with me that I find Jae's posting concerning? You're townreading them. Why do you think they're concerning?
In post 361, NotTheRealPaul wrote:the thing was with those votes it wasnt immediate. it felt like town tryna distance from wagon a lot because of the way they voted and "reasons". like MWAP was really against and i dont get why he changed. like he had support in that regard with jae. madtatters i just dont follow the thought process behind him not commenting on the scummy part to seeing osuka's pist and agreeing with it -and voting. like it just didnt add up the way he went from ignoring to sure.
Aphix's change literally came four hours after his initial post on the subject. It wasn't like he spent days hemming and hawing about his opinion. MWAP basically gamethrew in that initial post as either alignment, and I think I'd have voted them there for that. It was trolly and useless. If scum, she ruined the game for her partner. If town, she made town collectively waste a lynch, which is town's greatest resource. You yourself advocated for a policy lynch on them.
After the throw, MWAP turned toxic and started picking fights with people and personally insulting them. They needed to go. Aphix acknowledged that and lynched them for it. That's what changed.
