Mafia 75: Return of the Mafia! TOWN WINS (really late)

[Battle Mage]

I can dig this train of thought.

Unvote, Vote: Matt_S

Also noticing a connection to Lloyd, albeit a weaker one. If Matt_S comes out scum, I know who I'm voting for tomorrow though.

this makes me MUCH happier with my vote.

BM

[Matt_S]

If you want, I can claim now and save us time. It's not hard for me to prove it.

[skitzer]

So your saying you've breadcrumbed your role?

Don't claim just yet, there's a decent bandwagon, but I don't think you should claim just yet.

[Matt_S]

Shh. I'm hunting role fishers.

[RossWilliam]

if your willing to claim sp free;y, your role isn't that special? I'm confused. Maybe I'm still newbie. What's a role fisher? is it a scumtell?

[Matt_S]

if your willing to claim sp free;y, your role isn't that special? I'm confused. Maybe I'm still newbie. What's a role fisher? is it a scumtell?

Role fishers are people who try to get others to claim. They are usually scum who are trying to find power roles to kill.

[RossWilliam]

ah. well if you're dangling it like so, I expect they'll deduce that you're not a power role. I don't see the point

[Imat]

But he has a role that is easily proven. So he is a Power-Role. Perhaps hes tired of all the attention. Perhaps that in itself is Scummy. This is an interesting turn for you, Matt.

[Matt_S]

How you choose to interpret my actions is up to you. And how you interpret everyone's reactions is up to you.

[Antithesis]

ah. well if you're dangling it like so, I expect they'll deduce that you're not a power role. I don't see the point

Its called double reverse psychology...


with a twist.

[armlx]

Sounds like Matt is trying to bluff us into not pursuing it further. Not buying it.

[Andycyca]

Sounds like Matt is trying to bluff us into not pursuing it further. Not buying it.

Agree, why shouldn't he claim?
------------------------

Ok i guess i can deal with that explanation now. Right, BWers, lets move on to Matt S. and this time i want a serious wagon, as his play definitely warrants it.

Any particular post or his overall?

[JordanA24]

From now, UnofficialRulerOfEveryone replaces QuickBen, and farside22 replaces Nanosauromo. Please welcome both.

Vote Count update

d

upcoming shortly

.

[curiouskarmadog]

unvote

for now.

[Battle Mage]

So your saying you've breadcrumbed your role?

Don't claim just yet, there's a decent bandwagon, but I don't think you should claim just yet.

Why would you make this post?
you clearly dont want him to claim, yet you ask him whether his post meant he was breadcrumbing...

If he says 'yes', then we can all go and find out his role anyway.
If he says 'no' then we can conclude that he has a confirmable role, which scum will probably kill. Its equivalent of a power role claim.

Of course if Matt was trying to hunt rolefishers, he certainly succeeded. Just about everyone who has posted since, has done so.

Im not going to be the exception. Matt if you want to save us a load of time, you may aswell claim now. Especially if you are a power role, as we dont want you getting quickhammered.

BM

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Unvote

the vote from QuickBen at least until I catch up

[Albert B. Rampage]

Unvote

the vote from QuickBen at least until I catch up

Shadowlurker is that you ?

And how many more players need to be replaced ?

3 more players, with no more offers to replace as of yet

[farside22]

Hi all I will try and catch up with this today.

[Peers]

unvote

Not sure who the scum is, but fairly sure I've got no reason to have my vote here yet...

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

Unvote

the vote from QuickBen at least until I catch up

Shadowlurker is that you ?

And how many more players need to be replaced ?

Are you calling me a lurker? I just replaced QuickBen and the vote simply got transferred, so I unvoted, that's all.

[Albert B. Rampage]

SL is a banned player.

[farside22]

GS wrote to CDK
curiouskarmadog wrote:


vote GSGold, for jump on a beginning bandwagon without really scum hunting... looking forward to your answers.


Well, my answer is that your questions present a very solid point that I did not think about. I'll leave it to the Vig, then.

Unvote, not voting for anyone else at the moment.

Charity Post 80 is just a vote with nothing else. Votes for someone else then comes on saying she doesn't know what to do or how to vote with all the discussion going on. Post 300 - no idea to vote for. Is she reading anything?

CDK:
jesus, we are knee deep in newbies.
killa, he could be soft claiming a Vig (townie that can kill) or he could be just making a joke.
do you really think scum would just come out and say that?

This is a big assuption you are making on one person who is acting strange.

Actually voting without reason is constructive as it's easy to spot trends. FOSing without reason is a lot more low key and inciting.

I forgot who wrote this, but not voting and not contributing is anti-town. Scum are just as likely to vote without comment as anyone.


Lloyd: Post: 152 votes VanDamien with no explaination. Post 240 is pure BS> Lloyd revotes, doesn't provide any back up or real comments
Post 325 does not mention suspects just keeps looking at VanDamien. Post 454 calling my replacement a hypocrite with his hypocritical vote.

RC: Post 155 - what did you not like about TSPN comment in paticular.

TSPN: Post 189 they called you a hypocrite because of vote. Means you should look for scum and not lurkers Duh!

thenextepisode: Does he even have an opinion on scum - post 214.Post 218 is meaningless considering it's page 9 and some people are scum hunting. Post 245 is OMGUS! We finally get something, but still feel eh towards his attempts.

Khelvaster: Post 243 how does a person not helping in scum searching or conversation consistute town play?

CKD: Post 71 starts off good. Makes points about BM and others voting against him. post 266 is contraditory since you have been the main voice in protecting BM. Post 282 good point that most people should have known

TLP: Post 485 thinks its okay not to post much saying "1 peron a bit inactive won't harm". Doesn't seem to be really reading the game. Post 509 is basically following along with no thought of his own. Post 524 unvotes when pressed for comments. (look to see if game has deadline). Nope none found at this time.

Agree that oEJo seems to switch from one vote BW to another with little to nothing really said. Mostly reading wishy-washy.

@CKD: Did you start the vote on nano based on his comment that he didn't see what RC was getting at with a vote and no comment?

Unvote: Vote: TLP
FOS: oEJo

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

TSPN: Post 189 they called you a hypocrite because of vote. Means you should look for scum and not lurkers Duh!

Ah, but its much easier to find scum when people aren't lurking. Also, I find tlp more scummy than matt_s, so my vote is going to stay there for now.

[Battle Mage]

SL is a banned player.

But he already knew that. Didn't he?

Still waiting on Matt's claim.

BM

[UnofficialRulerOfEveryone]

SL is a banned player.

O.K. and no I'm iaretheman, but after weeks of inactivity, a very annoying computer dump, a new e-mail address, and a forgotten password I just decided to start over.