Large Normal 206: World Record Mafia! (GAME OVER)

[Nero Cain]

@ 2mil

that's simply not how town thinks. Town goes "hey all this ppl are scummy" If anything, a high # of town reads and a small scumlist is from scum. I think you could easily be scum here.

@osuka

boon is likely scum and if not I would be that much stock in his reads anyway.

[TwoInAMillion]

@ 2mil

that's simply not how town thinks. Town goes "hey all this ppl are scummy" If anything, a high # of town reads and a small scumlist is from scum. I think you could easily be scum here.

@osuka

boon is likely scum and if not I would be that much stock in his reads anyway.

That's rediculous, it's one thing to be suspicious of everyone, it's another thing to want to lynch over half the players. If you want to correctly figure the game out, you need to know who is town, and who is scum, not just say everyone is scum.

[osuka]

2mil has a point but so does nero

day 1 reads are generally shit, however. I think this engagement could very well be tvt but i'm not entirely sure

[Nero Cain]

That's rediculous, it's one thing to be suspicious of everyone, it's another thing to want to lynch over half the players

she never said anything about willing to lynch half the players.

[TwoInAMillion]

If you have a read list and you have someone as scum or probably scum that means you are willing to lynch them in my book.

[Nero Cain]

when you know there is going to be a three to one town scum ratio.

this also felt a little odd. 21 players are almost assuredly 5 scum. Its like he was avoiding giving the number so it doesn't look like a slip.

[osuka]

come on nero at that point you're just fishing

that wording is really innocuous

[Nero Cain]

fishing is a pretty relaxing past time. I used to go fishing my family alot of times when I was a kid.

[Flairs]

Vote: Flairs

He has more scum than town on his read lists, which makes no sense.

I can rename the tiers if it makes more sense for you

People I'm more or less confident calling town:
(People who I'm kinda confident in calling town but they haven't posted much so I'm on the edge)
People who have things stopping me from calling town:
People who don't post so I'm calling them scum for now:
People who I think are scum and I'm willing to lynch:

[Boonskiies]

If we're saying that's not how town thinks, I have stated this exact same play style in multiple town games, so that's really a crap reason if that's the case that is being made.

[Boonskiies]

Guessing wavemode has a decent chance of flipping scum.

Yeah, his recent posts showed he was posting without reading.

[Nero Cain]

If we're saying that's not how town thinks, I have stated this exact same play style in multiple town games, so that's really a crap reason if that's the case that is being made.

huh?

[Boonskiies]

You said small number of scum reads and high town comes from scum. I tend to think the opposite. When i'm scum, I generally like to keep at least 3 or 4 lean scum reads, a bunch of null, and then a small/medium amount of town reads.

[Boonskiies]

when you know there is going to be a three to one town scum ratio.

this also felt a little odd. 21 players are almost assuredly 5 scum. Its like he was avoiding giving the number so it doesn't look like a slip.

Why are you assuming 5 scum before flips? I tend to never assume the game isn't multi ball in a large day 1. In that case 3-3 scum teams would make sense.

[Nero Cain]

when you know there is going to be a three to one town scum ratio.

this also felt a little odd. 21 players are almost assuredly 5 scum. Its like he was avoiding giving the number so it doesn't look like a slip.

Why are you assuming 5 scum before flips? I tend to never assume the game isn't multi ball in a large day 1. In that case 3-3 scum teams would make sense.

I said nothing about it being MB. 5 scum in a 21 player is a pretty common.

[Nero Cain]

You said small number of scum reads and high town comes from scum. I tend to think the opposite. When i'm scum, I generally like to keep at least 3 or 4 lean scum reads, a bunch of null, and then a small/medium amount of town reads.

So Flaris is a scum read for you now?

[Boonskiies]

I know you said nothing. That was my point. You auto assumed it wasnt.

Nah, Flairs is a boon babe. He can claim Miller after a guilty and ill believe him.

[Nero Cain]

Why should I

NOT

think its single ball?

[Boonskiies]

Why should I

NOT

think its single ball?

Why should you? I generally never assume it isn't, in any game. I feel I've been a part of more large games with multi ball than not.

[Nero Cain]

b/c there's nothing to suggest it's MB unless we start seeing multiple kills per night and even then it could be sk/mafia which is/isn't MB depending on your how far you wanna stretch the definition. I feel like your speculation that this is a 3-3-15 setup is from scum thats on a 3 man team and knows its way too small to be the only team.

[Boonskiies]

There's nothing to suggest it isn't.

[Boonskiies]

As scum, what point would I have to bring that up in a 3 man scum team?

[Boonskiies]

And I never said it was multi ball, you yet again missed the point. There's nothing that suggests either way, so we shouldn't assume it's anything.

[Boonskiies]

My point is that neither is more likely than the other.

[osuka]

My point is that neither is more likely than the other.

Qft

At this point you couldn't possibly know what the setup is unless you have hidden knowledge (e.g. You're neutral or scum)