Pretty sure last game with carca is the only game I've played with carca. I had her as scum on her entrance and she was scum.In post 164, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:You know as well I do that Lily has a scummy play style. You're acting like you aren't going to take that into account at all.In post 160, Chickadee wrote:Why? I've scum read people in the past for repeatedly doing anti-town things.
That doesn't disprove anything I said?In post 175, Chickadee wrote:Pretty sure last game with carca is the only game I've played with carca. I had her as scum on her entrance and she was scum.In post 164, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:You know as well I do that Lily has a scummy play style. You're acting like you aren't going to take that into account at all.In post 160, Chickadee wrote:Why? I've scum read people in the past for repeatedly doing anti-town things.
In post 177, Robbnva wrote:i'm sorry mod, I am just going to bow out now to save everyone from some frustration that will most likely happen. I am prepared to tunnel whymafia until his death just because of his "masons joke" because I legitimately think he is scum for it. Based on my history of games this will ultimately turn this game into a shit show with people arguing with me and insulting me so to prevent that from happening I am going to
request replacement
this slot is now an innocent childIn post 177, Robbnva wrote:i'm sorry mod, I am just going to bow out now to save everyone from some frustration that will most likely happen. I am prepared to tunnel whymafia until his death just because of his "masons joke" because I legitimately think he is scum for it. Based on my history of games this will ultimately turn this game into a shit show with people arguing with me and insulting me so to prevent that from happening I am going to
request replacement
Why do you find it bad?
I haven't answered any questions directed at anyone. I never do. I also don't do the latter. I reconsider and reevaluate all the time.In post 184, hebichan wrote:You respond for other people and tend to not really look at the slot after you've had your initial impression.
I'm sorry that I made you replace out Robb :/In post 177, Robbnva wrote:i'm sorry mod, I am just going to bow out now to save everyone from some frustration that will most likely happen. I am prepared to tunnel whymafia until his death just because of his "masons joke" because I legitimately think he is scum for it. Based on my history of games this will ultimately turn this game into a shit show with people arguing with me and insulting me so to prevent that from happening I am going to
request replacement
Feel like it would be hard to organizeIn post 191, penguin_alien wrote:Mm, something I was thinking about: we should make sure people leave planned list orders in the thread before night phase/pre-any hammers. Less important maybe in early phases, but if we have people with PR info dying later we want to know who they planned to pass stuff on to and who isn't choosing to share. Scum could have a way to interfere with the tape passing mechanic, but it's worth a shot.
Pros/cons?
i agree, but it's something we should try to do. i dont mind being first on the list so i know its being passed down.In post 193, WhemeStar wrote:Feel like it would be hard to organizeIn post 191, penguin_alien wrote:Mm, something I was thinking about: we should make sure people leave planned list orders in the thread before night phase/pre-any hammers. Less important maybe in early phases, but if we have people with PR info dying later we want to know who they planned to pass stuff on to and who isn't choosing to share. Scum could have a way to interfere with the tape passing mechanic, but it's worth a shot.
Pros/cons?
My point was more that people can leave their own planned list orders, not that we all have to agree on the same list order for everyone. Preferably spoiler-tagged so as not to clutter the thread, but details. It's not foolproof, as scum could have a way to intercept tapes or pre-empt the order in another fashion, but it gives us info.In post 195, gerryoat wrote:i agree, but it's something we should try to do. i dont mind being first on the list so i know its being passed down.In post 193, WhemeStar wrote:Feel like it would be hard to organizeIn post 191, penguin_alien wrote:Mm, something I was thinking about: we should make sure people leave planned list orders in the thread before night phase/pre-any hammers. Less important maybe in early phases, but if we have people with PR info dying later we want to know who they planned to pass stuff on to and who isn't choosing to share. Scum could have a way to interfere with the tape passing mechanic, but it's worth a shot.
Pros/cons?
