Mini 1945 | 13 Reasons Why ► — Game Over

[Carcalilly]

Mm, something I was thinking about: we should make sure people leave planned list orders in the thread before night phase/pre-any hammers. Less important maybe in early phases, but if we have people with PR info dying later we want to know who they planned to pass stuff on to and who isn't choosing to share. Scum could have a way to interfere with the tape passing mechanic, but it's worth a shot.

Pros/cons?

And what's your way of interfering?

[Chickadee]

I think everyone having one list is better, imo. causes less confusion.

I don't like that. Make your own decisions but I think it could be to our benefit to share

[penguin_alien]

Mm, something I was thinking about: we should make sure people leave planned list orders in the thread before night phase/pre-any hammers. Less important maybe in early phases, but if we have people with PR info dying later we want to know who they planned to pass stuff on to and who isn't choosing to share. Scum could have a way to interfere with the tape passing mechanic, but it's worth a shot.

Pros/cons?

And what's your way of interfering?

Ah, right, here's where I tell you I'm the scum tape hijacker, clearly. Oy. Are you being antagonistic for fun or just to avoid commenting on the actual idea?

Never played in a keyenpeydee game, but I'd assume the tape mechanic didn't get through review with zero way for scum to interact with it.

[gerryoat]

I think penguin is town.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Why is Penguin town?

[gerryoat]

I like her posts so far, plus i had forgotten about the tape thing until she brought it up

[alban]

Will start reading soon.

[WhyMafia]

Mm, something I was thinking about: we should make sure people leave planned list orders in the thread before night phase/pre-any hammers. Less important maybe in early phases, but if we have people with PR info dying later we want to know who they planned to pass stuff on to and who isn't choosing to share. Scum could have a way to interfere with the tape passing mechanic, but it's worth a shot.

Pros/cons?

Feel like it would be hard to organize

i agree, but it's something we should try to do. i dont mind being first on the list so i know its being passed down.

My point was more that people can leave their own planned list orders, not that we all have to agree on the same list order for everyone. Preferably spoiler-tagged so as not to clutter the thread, but details. It's not foolproof, as scum could have a way to intercept tapes or pre-empt the order in another fashion, but it gives us info.

That's fair. It holds people accountable.

[keyenpeydee]

Boonskiies replaces Robbnva! Welcome!

[keyenpeydee]

---

---

Vote Count

Vote Count 1.04

[2] WhyMafia

— Boonskiies, Bins,

[2] TheFuzzylogic99

— WhyMafia, Desperado,

[1] Carcalilly

— WhemeStar,

[1] gerryoat

— TheFuzzylogic99,

[1] hebichan

— Carcalilly,

[1] Bins

— Lil Uzi Vert,

[1] WhemeStar

— penguin_alien,

Not Voting

— alban, gerryoat, Chickadee, hebichan,

Mod Notes

— You are now listening to Tape 1, Side A (Day One). It will end in September 21, 2017

With

13

alive, it take

7

to lynch. Day One will end in

(expired on 2017-09-21 16:00:00)

.

[Boonskiies]

Will catch up later tonight.

Just had to replace into this; I work on this show.

[Boonskiies]

Unvote

[Carcalilly]

I think penguin is town.

agree

[gerryoat]

so does anyone have a serious vote yet

[hebichan]

Carcalilly was my closest thing to a serious vote.

Want to hear from replacement before I go further into an analysis.

[gerryoat]

for claiming VT in a role madness??

[WhemeStar]

my vote is

[hebichan]

for claiming VT in a role madness??

No that was the joke reason, just didn't like carca's attitude in general, but it seems to be a trend so I'm letting it go for now.

[Bins]

miiiine is

[WhyMafia]

the reason why its scummy is just because its just an easy way to look like youre comfortable when ur actually scared


right whymafia?

VOTE: whymafia

I'm confused. How is this serious. Your reasoning is something that I cannot argue with as it's basically solely based on your opinion rather than even tone. Additionally this seems lazy because you're basically vote parking for no good reason

[WhyMafia]

I'm happy with lynching bins

[Carcalilly]

I'm happy with lynching bins

im not...

[gerryoat]

I'm happy with lynching bins

im not...

why not

[Chickadee]

Reading back through, I have a town lean on Why. He's done things to make himself stand out, and that seems townish. That does not mean all the moves he's made have been townish, but thats how I'm sorting him for now.

Not liking bins but could be a playstyle thing. null so far.

Not liking Carca. @Carca why were/are you blindly following Why? Is your town read on Why that strong, or is your scum read of Bins that strong?

Fuzzy has done nothing substantial. RVS vote, and some potato jokes.

Gerry null town. Don't like his take on the list though. In fact, I dislike it so much I'll comment

I think everyone having one list is better, imo. causes less confusion.

If we all have one list, it has the potential for people to hoard tapes. So the first few on the list would see a lot, and the people at the bottom might never see any.

Gut town lean on Hebichan

Boonskies null town. Based on Robb, so will remain mostly null until I get more form boonskies.

Wheme null

Alban super null

Penguin prob town. I like her thought process so far, even if I don't agree with some of it. Seems genuine and wants to get things going.

LUV town.

Desperado null. I'm gonna need time to read this one.


FYI - this started out that I was going to read through and comment on tons of stuff, and then I lost steam and started simplifying everything. And I just realized I have way to many town reads. So I guess I'll be reconsidering some of this.

[Carcalilly]

Mm, something I was thinking about: we should make sure people leave planned list orders in the thread before night phase/pre-any hammers. Less important maybe in early phases, but if we have people with PR info dying later we want to know who they planned to pass stuff on to and who isn't choosing to share. Scum could have a way to interfere with the tape passing mechanic, but it's worth a shot.

Pros/cons?

And what's your way of interfering?

Ah, right, here's where I tell you I'm the scum tape hijacker, clearly. Oy. Are you being antagonistic for fun or just to avoid commenting on the actual idea?

Never played in a keyenpeydee game, but I'd assume the tape mechanic didn't get through review with zero way for scum to interact with it.

A little bit of fun and a little bit of letting you know that I found that post scummy.
I know that I make plans like that when I'm scum so I look helpful to town.