TBD Mafia 2 [game over]

[chesskid3]

Because we establsihed long ago we arent lynching Alisae or Toby today and youre megafishing.

[Alisae]

dreal also asked a question about me to the mod and he never replied
I simply
don't
exist


Hell I don't even have to post right now
I can just
go away
and you'll forget all about my existance.

pedit: I can see how you got that conclusion tbh
it kinda makes sense
however take a look at the

very first vc

Anyways I have reason to believe Toby is something else.
I'm not really interested in sharing.

[drealmerz7]

this game is so boring
I'll be over here snoring

I'm willing lynch today:
bulbz, mulch, dunker, mario, snarkay

bulbz is scum because like chick said
he's hopping around from bed to bed
his excuses for shifting are weak and seem fabricated
I've not gotten a single town ping from him, it's all manipulated

alisae, the mod did reply to my question about you
I think the answer applies to toby too

[Alisae]

can you show me? I might have not saw it when I iso dived xyzzy

[Vecna]

Knowing whether theres a survivor faction, and how large it is, is only pro-town

Knowing who we can ignore, and not focus on for the lynches (also going forward) is only pro-town

And yes, I am fishing, because I want to know

[drealmerz7]

mod note, re post 1232: you should not assume that there is any relationship between whether a given user is in this game and whether that user has any effect on the game.

[drealmerz7]

vecna, it should be obvious who to ignore
toby who is a wildcard, and alisae, who is no more

[Vecna]

I still think theres something more going on there, but its clear that ali isnt in any type of mood to share that

[drealmerz7]

rather not focus on those jokas
help scumhunt
pass the blunt

[Vecna]

VOTE: Llamarbles

Back to this

[drealmerz7]

lynch bulbz with me
follow me to victory

[Desperado]

Also Alisae, you stated youre a survivor.....and that you can remove your name off the list (which it indeed is now)......is it just you by yourself, or do you have some other teammates in a survivor faction? (Toby)

Unvote

Vote: Vecna

1487 can die.

Is that just a strange leap in logic, seeing how he listed toby in his townreads-pile?

or do you have some other teammates in a survivor faction? (Toby)

0 town motivation for this

Theres actually plenty good reasons for that question, especially since a bunch of people have been calling for his head, and the similarities between the two slots make it quite plausible. Eliminating mislynches narrows our lynchpool.

Besides, whats wrong with just being curious about the setup

not to mention the fact that there was a survivor team in the first version of this game and it wouldn't be weird at all for xyzzy to have put another one in

[chesskid3]

Sooo who are you agreeing with

[Desperado]

vecna, obviously

[chesskid3]

and u think fishing for this is protown?

hmmmm yeah you can get tossed into the deathpile too

[Bulbazak]

Bulba "my role is confusing" at least doesn't count against him? For primary scumteam anyway.

Heck yes it was confusing! When the mod formats a role PM in such a way that you're not sure what alignment you are, there's something wrong. I had no idea whether I was town, scum, or some strange third party, a problem that was exacerbated by the entire PM being written in the mod's color, a deep red, with no coloration for role itself (green, red, etc.) or the name of the faction in front of the role. I had to read closely and pay special attention to my wincon just to figure out I may be town, and then I still had to ask the mod. Add to that, my role itself could have been better worded. I played half the day thinking I did one thing, and then found out that I did something similar but different.

726 from bulba is pretty bad. "Toby is town (for a lame speculative reason) but you can vig him if you want"
Bulba can you explain
A: why you think Toby's role strangeness is sufficient for him being a bad lynch
B: Why, if he is a bad lynch, vigging him (which has the same effect as a lynch) would be okay?

A.) Because he's essentially informationless. It doesn't matter whether the slot is controlled by a player, one of the mods, or is a sentient AI who just wants to find love, Toby is unlikely to have any bearing on the primary goal on finding and eliminating the scum in this game. Lynching it would essentially constitute lynching an empty slot, when our time could have best been used reading and figuring out the other players in the game.
B.) Because one of the functions of a vig is to eliminate contentious slots so that town doesn't have to deal with them. Policy players, empty slots, 3rd parties. Anything that would distract the town during the later stages of the game can be taken care of at night by a vig. There are also less strings attached to a player slot dying at night rather than being lynched. If there's a question over whether or not it's safe to lynch a slot, a vig can take care of that same slot with a smaller chance of the kill bringing on negative consequences.

Why is Bulba defending Eddie from chesskid. Eddie is clearly one of the best lynch options at this time. "wait until day 2" is yucky here.
Chesskid has joined Dreamer to form the Army of Sanity and Justice.

Chess lied about Eddie's activity on site in an effort to stimulate a wagon on him. There's no way that's coming from a town slot, and I can't see how you'd think so.

bulbz is scum because like chick said
he's hopping around from bed to bed
his excuses for shifting are weak and seem fabricated
I've not gotten a single town ping from him, it's all manipulated

Okay. How have I hopped around? Because I've mainly been on 3 people all game. And let's say that for some reason I was hopping around like some strange version of the Mafiascum easter bunny, how is that scummy?

not to mention the fact that there was a survivor team in the first version of this game and it wouldn't be weird at all for xyzzy to have put another one in

How would a survivor team even work? I thought the whole point of survivor was being by yourself and making it to the end. Would the whole team have to survive? A certain percentage? One? Inquiring minds want to know!

[EddieFenix]

Lycan drops a wall probably meant for GD. Eddie asks about it, doesn't seem to get a satisfying answer, and possibly drops it. What did you get out of that exchange, Eddie?

Bulbazak v dreamer v Lycan wasn't as interesting as hoped. Dreamer comes off town at least.

Why is Bulba defending Eddie from chesskid. Eddie is clearly one of the best lynch options at this time. "wait until day 2" is yucky here.
Chesskid has joined Dreamer to form the Army of Sanity and Justice.

Every time I'm considering not pushing Eddie out of the airlock he goes and does something like 1142

Who or what is GD? Like, I figure AD is ActionDan, but GD has me thrown for a loop. I need clarification for a proper response to your question.

Bulb covered the defending part.

As for 1142, I have my moments. I should do that more often, I know, but I tend to weigh on being the "nice guy" when playing games like mafia.

[Bulbazak]

GD=General Discussion

[drealmerz7]

bulba if you are having that much issue figuring stuff out
pretty sure this isn't the sort of game for you, I have little doubt

[Bulbazak]

No, you're the one saying I'm hopping around and that is bad. You need to defend that statement, dear sir, because this is the first time you've strayed into the realm of pure crap.

[chesskid3]

nah man you've been living there tho

[EddieFenix]

GD=General Discussion

With that information, I can answer better now. The post felt so far out of left field, I figure "alright, ask about what the fuck" was going thru Lycan's head when posting about it here in the scum game. Didn't -really- get anything meaningful from it, best to just take note of it and if something like that came from Lycan again, be sure to poke again at another time.

Also, Bulb, now that Lycan is gone, care to explain why/what exactly made you go after them now?

[Bulbazak]

Also, Bulb, now that Lycan is gone, care to explain why/what exactly made you go after them now?

Pressure.

[EddieFenix]

Also, Bulb, now that Lycan is gone, care to explain why/what exactly made you go after them now?

Pressure.

............that's it?

[Bulbazak]

That's it. Granted, things got a whole lot more interesting around the wagon, where a lynch would have given us a ton of info, but none of that came from the slot.