Newbie 1826 Basketball Game Over

[mhsmith0]

Votecount 1.05

Deimos27 (1)

CheekyTeeky ,

XnadroxX (1)

Spartan117 ,

Assemblerotws (4)

zemaj , Plotinus , XnadroxX , Deimos27 , L-1

Plotinus (1)

Peaches ,

Not Voting (2)

Assemblerotws , Clemency ,

Day one deadline is Tuesday October 10, 6 PM PST. (expired on 2017-10-10 18:00:00)

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

[/size]

[Spartan117]

Rolling my eyes right now. The last time I had a wagon form on me this fast was when I literally crumbed scum and got caught on it. You're seriously calling a joke about the rare literature class that actually studies the Bible as literature alignment-indicitave enough to lynch me?

Is this all you have to say to all the people on your wagon right now? It's like you are not even trying to defend yourself....

UNVOTE: XnadrojX

[Assemblerotws]

Rolling my eyes right now. The last time I had a wagon form on me this fast was when I literally crumbed scum and got caught on it. You're seriously calling a joke about the rare literature class that actually studies the Bible as literature alignment-indicitave enough to lynch me?

Is this all you have to say to all the people on your wagon right now? It's like you are not even trying to defend yourself....

UNVOTE: XnadrojX

Let's look at the entirety of the wagon against me, shall we?

Heya everyone! New to this site, not the game, so I know some little bit, but I am woefully deficient at the meta here. More used to 48h day/24h night, so this will be interesting to say the least... Otherwise, I'm an open book, just ask if you would like to know more. (Also, apologize for no avvy, limited to phone atm, so it hard to find one I like that's the proper size without editing...)

Moving on:
Is that an OMGUS from Assemblerotws, without an actual vote on him? Looks like it to me. Any reason you're so nervous, Assemble? VOTE: Assemblerotws

not BP

(Never seen the BP/not BP in action before, hype! Ofc, only played in a Matrix6 once before, as far as I'm aware.)

Hi Zemaj!
Was that a serious vote on Assemble?

You might've noticed Spartan already claimed BP, so you don't need to claim "not BP" anymore. We're just looking to see if anyone will counterclaim, the point being that if no one does, we can confidently say that Spartan is confirmed town. This is because there is almost no chance scum would take the 1/6 gamble that we are in setup 1 and fakeclaim BP.
If you are a doctor or cop, proceed as outlined in Plotinus's 16. If you're anything else, you should keep it to yourself.

@Assemble, Clemency is interpreting your 6 differently than I did, and if he's right that could be a scumslip. So I'm interested to know what you meant by "sticking this game through to the end this time".

Hi Zemaj!
Was that a serious vote on Assemble?

Semi-serious, though it could easily drop the 'semi', depending on response.

While you were not the only one questioning his opening post, you

were

the only one to provide much solid reasoning. Next post he votes you. If that isn't OMGUS (without the OMGUSer getting actually voted first) I'm not sure what qualifies.

You might've noticed Spartan already claimed BP, so you don't need to claim "not BP" anymore. We're just looking to see if anyone will counterclaim, the point being that if no one does, we can confidently say that Spartan is confirmed town. This is because there is almost no chance scum would take the 1/6 gamble that we are in setup 1 and fakeclaim BP.
If you are a doctor or cop, proceed as outlined in Plotinus's 16. If you're anything else, you should keep it to yourself

I misread Spartan's claim. I was wondering why people were denying counterclaim. That clarifies, thanks.

Heya everyone! New to this site, not the game, so I know some little bit, but I am woefully deficient at the meta here. More used to 48h day/24h night, so this will be interesting to say the least... Otherwise, I'm an open book, just ask if you would like to know more. (Also, apologize for no avvy, limited to phone atm, so it hard to find one I like that's the proper size without editing...)

Moving on:
Is that an OMGUS from Assemblerotws, without an actual vote on him? Looks like it to me. Any reason you're so nervous, Assemble? VOTE: Assemblerotws

not BP

(Never seen the BP/not BP in action before, hype! Ofc, only played in a Matrix6 once before, as far as I'm aware.)

Did you not see the comment that I was doing RVS based off the Book of Job?

I do not counterclaim bulletproof.

Unvote

<snip>
@Zemaj, I asked because I thought your vote might've been RVS. Why do you think Assemble's vote on me was OMGUS and not normal RVS? Why do you call my 21 "solid reasoning"? Do you believe that an SE not doing RVS in his first post is alignment indicative?
<snip>

I'll answer most obvious question first: I think anything that could be taken even slightly amiss

could be

alignment indicative.

As I understand it, SE are weighted into Newbie games to give the newbs a general idea of the flow of things, and normal progression. To that end, a SE wouldn't just pop in, post a bit of chat, then cut out without at least going through the motions, I would think. Also comes to a point when he then pops back in, and just happens to RVS for the one person who called him specifically on what was at least slightly sloppy play. This is suspect in my book, and I strongly feel that ANY suspect posts should be pressed, as quickly as is possible.

As for that being 'solid reasoning', I meant that in that you actually put

some

reason, not just a nebulous statement alluding to a possible misplay or slip.

So yeah, I'm not going to piss in the wind with RVS when I have something tangible to go on. Call it personal preference... Or actual scum hunting over speccing and chatting, whichever works for you

As I stated earlier, I am at a loss for the meta specific to this site, so I'm just playing how I know... Probably be the death of me, but surviving to the end isn't my goal. Rooting out the scum, that is my goal.


Any particular reason you feel it necessary to question the guy pressing another player on an explained and (I believe) rational point?

Did you not see the comment that I was doing RVS based off the Book of Job?

I do not counterclaim bulletproof.

Unvote

A likely story...

Actually, TBH, no, I didn't. Red text up against the red trim washed out... Never noticed until I went back to reread your posts for that bit, and noticed trim line was wider than usual. Zoom did allow me to see it then, though.

Still, it is funny how that worked out for you, wouldn't you say? I like where my vote is FTB.

Spoiler: Zemaj

Any particular reason you feel it necessary to question the guy pressing another player on an explained and (I believe) rational point?

I needed you to explain your "rational point", because it really didn't seem so to me.

Moving on:
Is that an OMGUS from Assemblerotws, without an actual vote on him? Looks like it to me. Any reason you're so nervous, Assemble?

First you called Assemble's RVS vote OMGUS.

Hi Zemaj!
Was that a serious vote on Assemble?

Semi-serious, though it could easily drop the 'semi', depending on response.

While you were not the only one questioning his opening post, you

were

the only one to provide much solid reasoning. Next post he votes you. If that isn't OMGUS (without the OMGUSer getting actually voted first) I'm not sure what qualifies.

Then you said I provided much "solid reasoning", when all I did was ask why he didn't participate in RVS and then disappeared. You can see why this seems very off to me.
He explained the disappearance just fine.
I do, however, agree with your 52 that him not "going through the motions" like usual is a peculiarity, and it's great your vote got us out of RVS.

Still, it is funny how that worked out for you, wouldn't you say? I like where my vote is FTB.

How is is it "funny how that worked out" for him? Do you think he was lying?

@Assemble
You didn't respond to my 25.

Clemency is interpreting your 6 differently than I did, and if he's right that could be a scumslip. So I'm interested to know what you meant by "sticking this game through to the end this time".

@Xnadroj
Nice of you to finally tune in. What do you think of Zemaj and Assemble?

Deim, what did you get out of looking through assemble's previous games? Were you looking for something in particular? Did you find it?

Spoiler: response

You are mistaken if you think I looked very deep. He was the only player that had posted at the time, so I went through some of his games while I was waiting because I thought it'd be more useful than going through random ones. I wasn't looking for anything in particular.

However, one thing I noticed at school today:

He doesn't

always

RVS in his first post. At least in 1820 he was town and didn't RVS for many posts. I told zemaj it's peculiar coming from an SE. I never thought that meant it was AI, and now I'm even more confident.

42 feels like you know that Clemency is town.

Spoiler: response

Could you elaborate on why you're interpreting it this way? If you look through Clemency's games you'll notice he is scumread in most (if not all) regardless of his alignment. I told him how he could improve his playstyle in order to be more easily accurately read by other players:

If you're town, I'd like to remind you to be proactive. It's extremely important for the game that town gets townread by other town.

Do you disagree with this statement? I, at least, can't read anyone if they don't provide content.

You seem pretty focused on assemble and your posts read as though you were pushing his wagon

Spoiler: response

Which posts read as though I'm pushing assemble specifically? I'm pressuring both sides of the argument, including zemaj:

Why do you think Assemble's vote on me was OMGUS and not normal RVS? Why do you call my 21 "solid reasoning"? Do you believe that an SE not doing RVS in his first post is alignment indicative?

How is is it "funny how that worked out" for him? Do you think he was lying?

I asked these questions because I didn't agree with his views on any of them.

I also currently have unanswered questions issued to Peaches and Xnadroj.

but you're still on the XnadrojX train. Do you have any serious reads yet?

RVS is esentially over, but I have nowhere else to put my vote and unvoting isn't doing anything. Xnadroj is an okay candidate for pressure since he has only posted twice and neither time with any content. I hope he comes back to give his views on the game soon.

I have an early town lean on zemaj for the following reason:

Spoiler:

Assume Zemaj is scum

If Assemble is town:
I don't think scum would make the play he made: Taking town out of RVS for the purpose of pushing a small peculiarity on a person that will eventually flip town? It would look bad.

If Assemble is scum:
I don't think scum would make the play he made: Taking town out of RVS for the purpose of pushing a small peculiarity on his scumpartner.
It's worth mentioning this scenario (S vs S) is technically possible as a form of distancing, but I don't think that sort of distancing would include a hardbus from the outset.

Plus: As scum he could've just replied to my question in 25 that his vote on Assemble wasn't serious, just RVS. And the game would've continued to stagnate.

So scum!zemaj just doesn't make as much sense to me as town!zemaj.

Ok as it stands I'm thinking assemble/Deimos scum team. Everyone else is town atm by default.

Not cc.

I'm scum read every game for being proactive. It's hard to make people town read you no matter what you do.

I never said you wouldn't be scumread even when you're proactive. Proactivity doesn't make you conftown, but it makes you easier to read. Do you disagree? As town, would you rather play in a game of nine passive players, or nine players who are all active and asking questions?

I'm not sure I like this post it feels like you're trying to impose a standard from which to make other people look scummy. I don't like that you reiterated that the bp claim helps town too. Your tone/intentions feel awkward and scummy.

Why do you think someone encouraging people to play in a manner that they believe to be pro-town comes only from scum?

Which post are you referring to by "reiterated the bp claim"? I didn't mention it once in 42.

Ok as it stands I'm thinking assemble/Deimos scum team. Everyone else is town atm by default.

Unless you're scum, you don't know the alignments this game for certain, so don't pretend you do. Who out of everyone left over is scummiest in your opinion? Who's most town?

Xnadroj, Seanod and Peaches waiting room. Everyone else has already RVSed.


Maybe we can talk about possible fixes to Matrix6 post-game, but it's not

entirely

obvious this strategy is better for town than scum.
I think it is, but I've seen a lot of opposition.

This post pinged me.

I'm scum read every game for being proactive. It's hard to make people town read you no matter what you do.

I never said you wouldn't be scumread even when you're proactive. Proactivity doesn't make you conftown, but it makes you easier to read. Do you disagree? As town, would you rather play in a game of nine passive players, or nine players who are all active and asking questions?

I'm not sure I like this post it feels like you're trying to impose a standard from which to make other people look scummy. I don't like that you reiterated that the bp claim helps town too. Your tone/intentions feel awkward and scummy.

Why do you think someone encouraging people to play in a manner that they believe to be pro-town comes only from scum?

Which post are you referring to by "reiterated the bp claim"? I didn't mention it once in 42.

Ok as it stands I'm thinking assemble/Deimos scum team. Everyone else is town atm by default.

Unless you're scum, you don't know the alignments this game for certain, so don't pretend you do. Who out of everyone left over is scummiest in your opinion? Who's most town?

Lol look I find your tone and stances LAMIST as scumfuck. I'll be every bit as confident in my reads as I like; stop pushing people to conform to your opinions and style. Not sure if you're arrogant or just feigning ignorance; pushing people only works if they believe you mean it. Nit picking as a response to my push isn't going to make you more town in my eyes. Soz.

Xnadroj, Seanod and Peaches waiting room. Everyone else has already RVSed.


Maybe we can talk about possible fixes to Matrix6 post-game, but it's not

entirely

obvious this strategy is better for town than scum.
I think it is, but I've seen a lot of opposition.

This post pinged me.

Why?
This post was responding to Clemency's 27. I didn't think it was certain Matrix6 would be replaced because there's been controversy over how good the strat is.

I'm scum read every game for being proactive. It's hard to make people town read you no matter what you do.

I never said you wouldn't be scumread even when you're proactive. Proactivity doesn't make you conftown, but it makes you easier to read. Do you disagree? As town, would you rather play in a game of nine passive players, or nine players who are all active and asking questions?

I'm not sure I like this post it feels like you're trying to impose a standard from which to make other people look scummy. I don't like that you reiterated that the bp claim helps town too. Your tone/intentions feel awkward and scummy.

Why do you think someone encouraging people to play in a manner that they believe to be pro-town comes only from scum?

Which post are you referring to by "reiterated the bp claim"? I didn't mention it once in 42.

Ok as it stands I'm thinking assemble/Deimos scum team. Everyone else is town atm by default.

Unless you're scum, you don't know the alignments this game for certain, so don't pretend you do. Who out of everyone left over is scummiest in your opinion? Who's most town?

Lol look I find your tone and stances LAMIST as scumfuck. I'll be every bit as confident in my reads as I like; stop pushing people to conform to your opinions and style. Not sure if you're arrogant or just feigning ignorance; pushing people only works if they believe you mean it. Nit picking as a response to my push isn't going to make you more town in my eyes. Soz.

It's true that I want to be townread, but that applies for both alignments. LAMIST is only a scumtell when the accused is obsessed with

looking

town, more so than actively sorting and scumhunting. Which of my stances gives you that impression?
Whether you call it "pushing people to conform to your opinions" or not, I only recommend what I think is best for town. Telling everyone what your reads are on all the other players can be important if Assemble or I flip and you end up being wrong. It's not a lot of information, but there's no need to deny town it.

Finally, how am I nitpicking?
The only part I didn't respond to was:

Just saying in Clemency's defense that there are plenty of "right" ways to play mafia and very few wrong... I might be plagiarising mastin here.

How many ways mastin thinks there are of playing mafia right or wrong is irrelevant to whether proactivity is better for town than a lack of it.

Cheeky, why do you think Assemble is scum?

You should have asked me that straight away, instead of defending yourself so much, then I would have known you are town, or objective at the very least. I didn't like his opening. I found you LAMIST. When I look at the interactions between you in RVS, it feels unnatural, and like a plan scum discussed pre-game to distance themselves. I also don't like how you've been reacting to my push and my read.

What do others think about these entrances? Do they look related or not so? Does Assemble's 2nd post feel genuine?

Spoiler:

Afternoon, everybody!

This time I'm sticking this game through to the end.

I was reading through some of Assemble's previous games and came across Newbie 1820, in which Fenrir suggested this BP claim strategy. I've seen it in other newbie games on this site also.

Wondering if the IC/SEs can share some insight on if this is a good idea? Seems very promising to me.

There is a relatively new strategy first proposed in a Newbie game by Radiant Cowbells. It is quickly becoming the standard way to begin Newbie games (at least until they change the setup to something other than Matrix6).

We are going to mass-claim "1-Shot Bulletproof"(BP) or "Not BP". To do this properly we need everyone to claim immediately.

Your next post needs to contain either a claim of 1-Shot Bulletproof or "Not BP"

.

Do not claim (or no-claim) any other role at this time

.

Reasons

:
1) Scum often attempt to fakeclaim bulletproof. By claiming early, your claim has maximum credibility and take that avenue away from Scum in the later game.
2) Although it does not technically confirm the player as town due to the possibility of a Jailkeeper only setup, the lack of a counterclaim gives the bulletproof townie considerable leverage because scum fakeclaiming bulletproof have terrible odds at doing so successfully.
3) If there is no Bulletproof Townie, that information will help us in the next phase of breaking the game.

Then what?

If there is a BP claim, there are three roles that can counterclaim it - BP, cop, and doctor.

If you are the real bulletproof or a cop, the correct way to counter a fake bulletproof claim is simply to say, "I counterclaim.", regardless of which of those two you are.

If you are a doctor, wait until everyone else has refused to counterclaim before you speak up! Ideally, the cop will counterclaim and you can stay in the shadows protecting them.

If there is no bulletproof claim, the next step is Tracker claim, which we can deal with if/when we get there.

I want to know why an SE didn't RVS and just disappeared after making a single post that wasn't even game related.

I want to know why an SE didn't RVS and just disappeared after making a single post that wasn't even game related.

Referring to Assemble's entrance.

I want to know why an SE didn't RVS and just disappeared after making a single post that wasn't even game related.

VOTE: Deimos27
Do not question what you cannot understand.
Busy with a school assignment involving the Book of Job, so now I'm doing RVS based on it.

Hi Zemaj!
Was that a serious vote on Assemble...

@Assemble, Clemency is interpreting your 6 differently than I did, and if he's right that could be a scumslip. So I'm interested to know what you meant by "sticking this game through to the end this time".

Then we see the not subtle discrediting of Clemency from Deimos and then the way he seems overdefensive when called out by me. There are multiple layers I didn't like in his first response to me. I'll go into that more when others have responded to the entrances.

What do others think about these entrances? Do they look related or not so? Does Assemble's 2nd post feel genuine?

This town is making me sad :/ I would love people's thoughts on this, even if your conclusion is that Cheeky is a paranoid nutball...

Well OK Plotinus came in very townily I guess so I think they're town. Is that a round-about way of calling my vote bad and if so, why is it bad at that point of time?

It's not really calling it bad because I didn't really like your entrance either; also thought that you were making excuses. But it is pointing out the hypocrisy that you're scumreading someone for something very similar to what you yourself have done: making excuses for future bad play. That said,

OH waitr I'm blind they're clear.

UNVOTE: Spartan

I'm kind of townleaning this? I feel like scum would be paying more attention to who is clear.

What do others think about these entrances? Do they look related or not so? Does Assemble's 2nd post feel genuine?

This town is making me sad :/ I would love people's thoughts on this, even if your conclusion is that Cheeky is a paranoid nutball...

I think that it is pretty unlikely for scum to plan out their RVS in that degree of detail. In other queues where players are more likely to know each other and there aren't so many unknown players as there are in newbies, you might see some pregame discussion of which players are threats and how to deal with them.

But, uh, with my track record lately I don't want to shut down something you're pursuing with a repeat of the BEC incident.

Cheeky, is it too early for me to be townreading Clemency? Because I kinda am.

Prodding Assemblerotws, Spartan117, Peaches, zemaj

"You know nothing, Job. I am so far above you that you cannot understand a tenth of what I do." That was the purpose of my RVS vote, joking about how I was an SE and Deimos only a newbie.

VOTE: Assemble L-3

I'm starting to wonder if Deimos is scum for how they pushed me for what I made clear was a reference to the Book of Job, where God goes on a long diatribe that can be basically summed up as "You know nothing, Job. I am so far above you that you cannot understand a tenth of what I do." That was the purpose of my RVS vote, joking about how I was an SE and Deimos only a newbie.

Hi Assemble, what are you studying that would lead to an assignment on the book of job? Where did Deimos push you after you explained your RVS vote? Why would scum or town do that?

Pedit - nice Clemency but as there are 2 scum roles the answer is always 2/9. @Plot yes he's town.

The chances of rolling scum twice in a row is 1/20. The chances of someone being scum here when they've rolled scum in a previous game is 2/9.


@Plot, pls no you can townread me for literally anything else I've done but TRing me for being retarded is just.... weird. I mean , being retarded is NAI and I can (and often am) be retarded as either alignment. So are you calling my vote bad or not? Also I never implied I wanted to be excused from being scumread, I just said I'm going to ruin the game. I mean you could interpret it othwerwise I guess, but if you want to take my word for it, that was not my intention.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Assemble

96 pings me because it's inaccurate and basically a discredit. Feels like self-conscious player.

Assemble, your entire ISO is just 7 posts of which almost none is useful, game-advancing content.
Do you continue to have zero reads on anyone?
Are there IRL reasons you're being so inactive?

I'm starting to feel like Assemble is the scummiest player in this game.

I think if something were going on IRL Assemble would either be V/LA or have mentioned it already. An SE flying under the radar like that actually feels really scummy.
Just look at his ISO. It's all lurky non-content, and apart from his very first post (which was nothing but a greeting) and very latest post (which was inaccurate and right after a prod), he hasn't posted at all except when directly questioned or attacked. And even those posts haven't included anything but the necessary response. He's done zero sorting or scumhunting, apart from maybe his latest "wondering" about my nonexistent push on his RVS vote.

Zero

.

Recent posts from Xnadj feel pretty town, Assemble is where I want my vote.
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Assemble

L-1

Since the IC hasn't yet explained this:

Do

not

hammer before stating an intent to do so and asking for a claim.
Ignoring the above is equivalent to a scumclaim.

75% people scumreading me thinking my actions were intentional when I've already said it was a stupid-ass mistake, 25% a guy who replaced out when he couldn't push a lynch on me. If there's anyone who still thinks I intentionally attacked Deimos, come forward and tell me why so I can answer you properly.

[CheekyTeeky]

Wtf 127, did you really just wall all that for no reason? Grrr. You're missing the current point Assemble. The point is that your actions changed during RVS based on people questionning them as scummy. For instance Deimos asked you why you didn't RVS (which Deimos later admitted you don't always do based on your meta), then you RVS. Later Zemaj says your RVS looks like OMGUS, and then you unvote... your voting actions look like you're appeasing people rather than using your vote to scum hunt. There is no town reason to let people dictate who, when and why you vote. Why were your actions like this in RVS? Why are you so far off point? If you're town you're making a mess of us reading you properly.

Seriously you just put together a shizz load of posts, with a sentence about percentages on a point that is, again, irrelevant. You haven't provided any insight into the posts, it looks like you're trying to distract us from the fact that you're unwilling to provide us with any reads or useful info.

[Assemblerotws]

Wtf 127, did you really just wall all that for no reason? Grrr. You're missing the current point Assemble. The point is that your actions changed during RVS based on people questionning them as scummy. For instance Deimos asked you why you didn't RVS (which Deimos later admitted you don't always do based on your meta), then you RVS. Later Zemaj says your RVS looks like OMGUS, and then you unvote... your voting actions look like you're appeasing people rather than using your vote to scum hunt. There is no town reason to let people dictate who, when and why you vote. Why were your actions like this in RVS? Why are you so far off point? If you're town you're making a mess of us reading you properly.

Seriously you just put together a shizz load of posts, with a sentence about percentages on a point that is, again, irrelevant. You haven't provided any insight into the posts, it looks like you're trying to distract us from the fact that you're unwilling to provide us with any reads or useful info.

I'm not an early game player, but I have still managed to provide some reads (see my twice-expressed scumread on zemaj, though I botched it the first time).
You do have a point with the appeasement, though. I'm probably still a little paranoid after being lynched in LYLO by someone whose only justification was that I apparently looked scummy due to my lurking, never mind the holes in the other guy's claim you could drive a wagon through.

[CheekyTeeky]

see my twice-expressed scumread on zemaj, though I botched it the first time

This is valid. Could you elaborate on the Zemaj read and tell us your thoughts on others at this point? Here's where I am atm - top is town:
Spartan (conf.)
Clemency
Zemaj
Plot
Deimos
Peaches
XnadrojX
Assemblerotws

[mhsmith0]

RadiantCowbells replaces zemaj effective immediately.

[RadiantCowbells]

Is it cute in here or is it just me

[CheekyTeeky]

Lol hey rc, it's just you

Who's scum?

[RadiantCowbells]

Not me

I haven't read. I'll read when I get home!

[RadiantCowbells]

Are you scum

[CheekyTeeky]

Are you scum

Still no I'm starting dread the day I am lol.

[RadiantCowbells]

I scumread you but I don't trust my ability to read you.

Please help me townread you?

[RadiantCowbells]

Unless you're scum, then please lie down and let me lynch you

[Clemency]

This is what I was afraid of.

[RadiantCowbells]

Oh no

Do you not want to play with me?

[CheekyTeeky]

I scumread you but I don't trust my ability to read you.

Please help me townread you?

This means I'm town lol. You should know that by now.

[RadiantCowbells]

Will you dance with me?

[CheekyTeeky]

Aww of course, which dance?

[RadiantCowbells]

What kind of dances can you dance?

[Clemency]

Oh no

Do you not want to play with me?

We all love you, but we know how well you can play scum.

[RadiantCowbells]

Well, Cheeky will know what alignment I am by the way that I dance. Guilty feet, after all, have got no rhythm.

[Plotinus]

my arm is better but now i'm sick lol. I'll be here intermittently all day though.

What do you base your Clemency townreads on, Cheeky & Plot?

Response to the part of this that I snipped: okay, fair enough.

Response to this question: Cheeky and I, and now RC (hi RC!) just got out of Clemency's first scumgame. He had a lot of trouble just posting and figuring out what to say and how to pretend to scumhunt. He blamed this on how he'd been treated in his first game, saying people had nitpicked him too much for expressing opinions. He could express reads when prompted but only reads that lukewarmly agreed with the person he was talking to. He could not generate game advancing content without being prompted to do so.

In this game, he has generated some reads, all by himself,and shared them unprompted he can and does post without people saying hi to him first, and his reads have a little depth and paranoia in them. He probably has learnt some from his first experience playing scum but I think he may be outside of his scumrange already.

The chances of rolling scum twice in a row is 1/20. The chances of someone being scum here when they've rolled scum in a previous game is 2/9.


@Plot, pls no you can townread me for literally anything else I've done but TRing me for being retarded is just.... weird. I mean , being retarded is NAI and I can (and often am) be retarded as either alignment. So are you calling my vote bad or not? Also I never implied I wanted to be excused from being scumread, I just said I'm going to ruin the game. I mean you could interpret it othwerwise I guess, but if you want to take my word for it, that was not my intention.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Assemble

96 pings me because it's inaccurate and basically a discredit. Feels like self-conscious player.

I should have replied to this when it happened but I really didn't have time and I wanted to reply to things in order. It's not okay to use the r word in general and it's also against the site rules.

I was calling your vote hypocritical. Saying you're going to ruin the game with bad reads is making an exuse for not trying harder to get good ones, letting yourself off the hook pre-emptively. It's parallel to your reason for voting Cheeky. I think it's a decent reason as far as reasons go early on and I don't think hypocrisy is a scumtell.

will get to more stuff in a bit

[Spartan117]

Will you dance with me?

Can I join this dance?

[mhsmith0]

.