Large Normal 207: Theatre Mafia

[Mulch]

Xandroj could be a great wagon. Thoughts?

I’m so paranoid of Mulch right now. I feel I shouldn’t be town reading him. Paranoia in mafia is the worst.

This is a good thing. I'm towny as scum

This just points a giant middle finger to everyone reading you as scum

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Mulch




Also, I wasn't really looking at the wagons, I was just skimming and I thought Dunker looked worse than Una.

What's scummy about my statement?

VOTE: XnandroX

[Mulch]

OK I'm lazy to quote up 25 pages of Boonskiies doing weird shit and people responding with weird shit and the amount of self-meta and NAI shit flying about is confusing me so I just did a quick skim and came up with a few preliminary reads.

Acid and Mulch is likely town here, even if I don't agree with most of what Mulch said. Raskol town too probs.

Boonskiies has just been playing according to how he plays basically every game, I don't want to read him for now.

I think Una and Dunker are scum, their posts seem to be less "hey look, there's scum" and more "Hey [insert player here], I think you're right"

VOTE: Dunker

Making a more thorough post when I actually get to analysing the important things. If anyone can tell me where the main highlights are please tell me because when I said skimming I literally meants glossing over anything remotely insignificant.

This is a bad post, especially consider Dunker went out and flat out accused 3 people of being scum.

[Mulch]

If you referred to self meta as NAI shit, why did you just scumread me for it?

[Dunkerdoodles]

OK I'm lazy to quote up 25 pages of Boonskiies doing weird shit and people responding with weird shit and the amount of self-meta and NAI shit flying about is confusing me so I just did a quick skim and came up with a few preliminary reads.

Acid and Mulch is likely town here, even if I don't agree with most of what Mulch said. Raskol town too probs.

Boonskiies has just been playing according to how he plays basically every game, I don't want to read him for now.

I think Una and Dunker are scum, their posts seem to be less "hey look, there's scum" and more "Hey [insert player here], I think you're right"

VOTE: Dunker

Making a more thorough post when I actually get to analysing the important things. If anyone can tell me where the main highlights are please tell me because when I said skimming I literally meants glossing over anything remotely insignificant.

This is a bad post, especially consider Dunker went out and flat out accused 3 people of being scum.

i agree with this

[Dunkerdoodles]

actually on second thought i think xan is town, scum doesnt post that.

[texcat]

Between Fykus and Theta, he would have gotten a scum result whether or you were actually scum. That's what happens when a modified Jailkeeper, a Rolestopper, and a Loyal player all hit the same target.

what are your reads?

+1

Assembler, your iso is remarkably thin. You've talked a lot more about previous games than this game. You told us you were rereading in order to form some reads, but what happened?

If we are thinking about lynching a lurker, I'd suggest this one.

[Mulch]

Between Fykus and Theta, he would have gotten a scum result whether or you were actually scum. That's what happens when a modified Jailkeeper, a Rolestopper, and a Loyal player all hit the same target.

what are your reads?

+1

Assembler, your iso is remarkably thin. You've talked a lot more about previous games than this game. You told us you were rereading in order to form some reads, but what happened?

If we are thinking about lynching a lurker, I'd suggest this one.

Can vouch he’s always like this. It’s about random chance he flips scum, perhaps a bit higher though will all the townreads I have

[Boonskiies]

I wouldn’t say it’s random. I feel like there’s a distinct difference between his scum game and town game. He asks a lot of pointless question, and kind of aggressively when he’s scum, but posts about the same. He might have been able to change it up, but I’m not necessarily seeing his posts as “forced”.

[UnaBombaH]

Whoo, finally able to post tonight!
Will still be busy the following days, but try to more or less keep up from now on.

Something I noticed while re-reading: Dunker + XnadrojX felt like an obvious pairing until:

I think Una and Dunker are scum, their posts seem to be less "hey look, there's scum" and more "Hey [insert player here], I think you're right"

VOTE: Dunker

Making a more thorough post when I actually get to analysing the important things. If anyone can tell me where the main highlights are please tell me because when I said skimming I literally meants glossing over anything remotely insignificant.

I was going write off pairing them, but...BUT. Less than 24 hours later:

VOTE: mulch
choo choo

..and less than 6 hours apart:

This just points a giant middle finger to everyone reading you as scum

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Mulch


Also, I wasn't really looking at the wagons, I was just skimming and I thought Dunker looked worse than Una.

Backpedaling on his vote, hiding his "poor read" behind "just skimmed", and satisfied with his part of distancing?

actually on second thought i think xan is town, scum doesnt post that.

..but doesn't unvote or move his vote over.

My biggest issue with this is the fact that it feels SO obvious, but maybe that was the aim all along?

VOTE: XnadrojX

[UnaBombaH]

Actually: NOT SURE OF THE VOTECOUNT, CAN WE GET ONE AS SOON AS POSSIBLE? (ty )

[Mulch]

I don't really see it like that. And I could see where Dunker is coming from

[Boonskiies]

I don’t know what I think of Jordan right now. I’ll look at my past games with him, because I feel like I always tend to misread him and then mislynch him. It could be the other way around, though, but Mulch is making me overly paranoid right now, so I’m going to try to read Mulch off of reading other players.

[Mulch]

so I’m going to try to read Mulch off of reading other players.

Which dosen't work.

[Boonskiies]

I think I like Una for town now, though.

[Mulch]

I think I like Una for town now, though.

I can see this. Uh, but he also has fooled me in the past so *shrug*

[Boonskiies]

so I’m going to try to read Mulch off of reading other players.

Which dosen't work.

It does if I POE and figure out if i think Jordan is a mislynch or not, and if you’re the one pushing the scum agenda or town tunneling, but if something pings me on the side, like if I see scum trying to take advantage of your push on Jordan, then I would probably be more comfortable town reading you. However, Una is in that spot that I just stated, but I do see TownUna there because of it. Yes, this does imply I am lean towning on Jordan.

[Boonskiies]

I think I like Una for town now, though.

I can see this. Uh, but he also has fooled me in the past so *shrug*

He’s never fooled me, though.

[Mulch]

so I’m going to try to read Mulch off of reading other players.

Which dosen't work.

It does if I POE and figure out if i think Jordan is a mislynch or not, and if you’re the one pushing the scum agenda or town tunneling, but if something pings me on the side, like if I see scum trying to take advantage of your push on Jordan, then I would probably be more comfortable town reading you. However, Una is in that spot that I just stated, but I do see TownUna there because of it. Yes, this does imply I am lean towning on Jordan.

So why are you townreading him based on scum pushing a mislynch if you think Una is town?

[Mulch]

And why are you leaning town on him?

[Mulch]

Mulch (replaces Vedith)

massive

XnadrojX

pisskop

Kaminaseigaku

acidphoenix

Assemblerotws

MeowMix

texcat

Boonskiies

Carcalilly

Fykus

UnaBombaH

Dunkerdoodles
mozamis

Not Known 15

wavemode

Raskolnikov

[Mulch]

And why are you leaning town on him?

More specifically, why are you so confident with him being town that you would be willing to townread me if you think there are people jumping opportunistically on it? Why don't you think it could have been ME that was being opportunistic scum? Or that Xandroj is scum and there are town jumping on it?

[Carcalilly]

I don't think we can just day1 una
If he's scum we could prob find out better later...

[Mulch]

I don't think we can just day1 una
If he's scum we could prob find out better later...

Maybe. What do you think about Fykus?

[UnaBombaH]

I can see this. Uh, but he also has fooled me in the past so *shrug*

When?
I haven't really rolled scum on this site yet..

Being Traitor doesn't count, and you know how good I am at that.

[UnaBombaH]

I don't think we can just day1 una
If he's scum we could prob find out better later...

I mean, you CAN.
It has been proven time and time again, I am easy to lynch as town..
But yea, you SHOULDN'T.