Newbie 1828: Utopia! - Game Over!

[darrenwoodward10]

Wait, I didn't complain about the game pace ; I observed it's different than what I'm used to. That's a big difference. Are you trying to throw me under the bus?

Oh hi Noodle!
I'm not sure what you mean by "trying to throw you under a bus"
Also pls get a profile pic

[darrenwoodward10]

Apologies in advance if I mess up your pronouns, if I do don't take it personally. Just let me know if it's wrong.

[Porkens]

1) what kind of response to being voted would make you think someone was probably town?
2) if you were scum, would you try to signal your partner like that during day 1?

[Porkens]

Apologies in advance if I mess up your pronouns, if I do don't take it personally. Just let me know if it's wrong.

That's very polite of you.

[darrenwoodward10]

1) what kind of response to being voted would make you think someone was probably town?
2) if you were scum, would you try to signal your partner like that during day 1?

1) Like I said, immediately defending themselves or voting against them.
2) I don't know, maybe if it's essential

[Porkens]

vote: darrenwoodward10

[Nauci]

also obligatory

gorny was a wagon?

(but seriously i didn't actually realize at time of voting)

Hmmmmm

I am satisfied for now.

[Nauci]

Gorny:

I'm on mobile so I'm not going to try to quote that giant post. If I forget to address anything let me know

1: I enjoy being generally trolly and announcing all sorts of claims. VT, arson, jailer, etc. Am actually town aligned witch!
2: I said "am not scum" because someone had just asked me if I'm scum. I am not scum.
3: Lurking is definitely a scummy thing to do, not NAI. Defending lurking is also scummy.
4: You've post multiple times saying Noodles weird behavior is actually normal, giving him excuses to hide scumminess behind. Smells like scum teaming!
5: I don't really know how to explain why I think your posts are overly defensive without writing out a psychology essay so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

For now my reads are on the quiet people, so Noodle and... Hmm. I'll have to take another look in the morning.

Also lol @ the bus joke. Where I'm from, bussing means one scum throwing another under the bus!

VOTE: Noodle

[Nauci]

Also what are you on about with the scum message reads? If scum wanted the other scum to vote someone, they'd say it in scum chat.

[Nauci]

Oh and I asked why Porkens had someone as a town read. Asking why someone reads another person as town is VERY different from saying they're scum. I didn't back off anything because I didn't imply anything in the first place. I always want to know why someone gets a green read as much as why someone gets a red one.

[Nauci]

I'm very suspicious of the people trying to fish for PR.

[darrenwoodward10]

vote: darrenwoodward10

I feel like this is just another test to see if everything I said was true. So I'm not going to take it seriously for now.

[acidphoenix]

I didn't respond because I slept

ffs

[acidphoenix]

gorny / Darren

gorny turn

[Gorny]

Here's a fun game, popcorn your guess for scumteam. Popcorn means I'll start and then pick someone to go next. It stops whenever someone chickens out

unvote

I'm guessing it's gorny and northsidegal

Acid you go next.

gorny / Darren

gorny turn

Aristo/Noodle

Northside turn

[Noodle]

1. Ok, but this isn't live mafia, you can wait a while to post. Everyone has a life. It's not weird to only post a couple times a day. So, you have time to purge those emotions, and post calmly and without "panic". So assume scum know this. And they will not be overly defensive. That's just my advice

2. This is a good analysis. Does that seam scummy to you? Just curious I haven't formed an opinion yet.

It's not necessarily scummy what Noodle is doing, my dislike towards his playstyle is more based off how long he goes without posting. He could just be a town collecting reads which is appreciated, but I wish he would have told us rather than wait until provoked about it. What really makes me thing Noodle is scummy, is how he intentionally misquoted Acid, especially the part of the quote that seemed scummy to me.

It's not that complicated, guys. I only quoted the statement to which I was replying.

[acidphoenix]

Also pls get a profile pic

[darrenwoodward10]

It's not that complicated, guys. I only quoted the statement to which I was replying.

It's not about that, it's the fact that you intentionally left a bit out.

[Porkens]

1) what kind of response to being voted would make you think someone was probably town?
2) if you were scum, would you try to signal your partner like that during day 1?

1) Like I said, immediately defending themselves or voting against them.
2) I don't know, maybe if it's essential

vote: darrenwoodward10

I feel like this is just another test to see if everything I said was true. So I'm not going to take it seriously for now.

[Inferno390]

Ma, a whole lot has been going on! I'm going to have to skim for a bit to see what I pick up, but I just want t make one thing clear before I do:

Spoiler: inferno

I having a hard time putting a read on Inferno. He's seeming null with the casual stance, even saying he's not defensive but casual.
He did move for the BP claim, which even though it can produce a confirmed innocent...it also gives scum setup info.
One thing that does stand out is he asks the mod as to whether or not we should use the BP Strat. As far as I remember, there's no reason to ask the mod. Its a consensus among the players.
Though he is asking questions and poking for answers with his posts after 196, it doesn't seem overly scum worthy to me.

Inferno is true Nulll at this point.

I did not ask the mod if we could do the BP Strat. I just asked

if we could begin a vote tally

to see who wanted to do the BP Strat. I, for one, would be interested in seeing how it plays out.

[Inferno390]

Okay, here's what I have:

I don't understand the last 2 pages.

What Porkens is doing is precisely scum hunting.

I have acid, Gorny, darren, and Noodle on my scummy list and Porkens on scum hunting list.

Yeah, it's scum hunting, but it seems all over the place. Like, either Porken's is trying really hard to find a read, or the questions are related I a way that I'm not seeing, or Porken's "fishing" for a reason to get a scumread on someone, Idk. THat's just what that post feels like to me.

3.1: But there's more than one kind of defensive.
3.2: You asked if Darren thought he was reading the posts. I think he is. That would be lurking. There's only a few reasons he would be lurking: To avoid suspicion, to try and get reads on everybody, or to try and find a reason to jump on somebody for a mislynch.

3.1: accepted.
3.2: Is lurking scummy, Towny, or Not Alignment Indicative?

Um, I'm the one who said this, not Nauci.
I think that lurking has a slight lean toward scummy.

pls don't lynch me

curious at what the hell inferno's readslist is

porkens is probably town

cat avis are still probably town

gorny is the worst looking out of others imo

What do you mean, what my readlist is? I posted it a few pages back.

[northsidegal]

Also what are you on about with the scum message reads? If scum wanted the other scum to vote someone, they'd say it in scum chat.

this is probably a townslip.

Okay, here's what I have:

I don't understand the last 2 pages.

What Porkens is doing is precisely scum hunting.

I have acid, Gorny, darren, and Noodle on my scummy list and Porkens on scum hunting list.

Yeah, it's scum hunting, but it seems all over the place. Like, either Porken's is trying really hard to find a read, or the questions are related I a way that I'm not seeing, or Porken's "fishing" for a reason to get a scumread on someone, Idk. THat's just what that post feels like to me.

this is precisely how i'm looking at porkens right now. any scumhunting looks really all over the place.

i pass on the popcorn thing. inferno can be next.

[Noodle]

It's not that complicated, guys. I only quoted the statement to which I was replying.

It's not about that, it's the fact that you intentionally left a bit out.

Yeah, because I wasn't replying to that part. It's not like it magically suppressed the rest of his post, I just didn't quote the parts irrelevant to my reply. It's for readability's sake. I find it really a stretch to suggest some nefarious intent.

[Inferno390]

Also what are you on about with the scum message reads? If scum wanted the other scum to vote someone, they'd say it in scum chat.

this is probably a townslip.

Okay, here's what I have:

I don't understand the last 2 pages.

What Porkens is doing is precisely scum hunting.

I have acid, Gorny, darren, and Noodle on my scummy list and Porkens on scum hunting list.

Yeah, it's scum hunting, but it seems all over the place. Like, either Porken's is trying really hard to find a read, or the questions are related I a way that I'm not seeing, or Porken's "fishing" for a reason to get a scumread on someone, Idk. THat's just what that post feels like to me.

this is precisely how i'm looking at porkens right now. any scumhunting looks really all over the place.

i pass on the popcorn thing. inferno can be next.

I think Porkens and acid. Next: Noodle.

[fferyllt]

...and