Newbie 1827: Baseball Game Over

[UC Voyager]

I declare this page top in the name of THE OAKLAND RAIDERS

[Apple Jack]

Not sure how that's over the top?

Because I wasn’t asking for a free pass. It’s an illogical conclusion imo.

[Luca Blight]

Not sure how that's over the top?

Because I wasn’t asking for a free pass. It’s an illogical conclusion imo.

Not really, considering you were saying you weren't going to push your scum reads until D2.

The illogical part to me is the belief you can't push your scumreads without ruining the game, seeing as that is in itself a fundamental part of the game, but whatever.

I also like to provoke people a bit in RVS - it's how I acquire my early reads.

[UC Voyager]

VOTE: Wilky

Here are my reads
Lucas

Spoiler:

I have a town read on them. They have made a decent case on Willy. Willy isl trying to make a case on them to.. And I have a scum read on Willy.

Shea

Spoiler:

I have a scum lean of him. i found his reaction to my entrance weird. He was talking about the whole RVS thing. About how it ends or whatever. Why does that matter? Shouldn't we be scum hunting?

Willy

Spoiler:

So I'm getting. A scum read on Willy. they tried to make a case on Derpy early on, but when one person found it scummy, he immediately found that person scummy. With not much to go off of, that's what I think.

[Luca Blight]

I'm gonna find it hard not to scumread Wilky until I can understand his thought-process behind this:

Whilst I don't think any of the posts indicate any players role,

if Hooves actively and effectively scum hunts it might be nice to revisit Luca.

[wilky]

VOTE: Wilky

Here are my reads
Lucas

Spoiler:

I have a town read on them. They have made a decent case on Willy. Willy isl trying to make a case on them to.. And I have a scum read on Willy.

Shea

Spoiler:

I have a scum lean of him. i found his reaction to my entrance weird. He was talking about the whole RVS thing. About how it ends or whatever. Why does that matter? Shouldn't we be scum hunting?

Willy

Spoiler:

So I'm getting. A scum read on Willy. they tried to make a case on Derpy early on, but when one person found it scummy, he immediately found that person scummy. With not much to go off of, that's what I think.

I'm failing to see where I tried to make a case on Derpy tbh? Also, I made one comment on Luca earlier in the game after that point I have just been answering his questions he has put to me. I'm definitely not building a case on him although my view from him has gone from null to null-scum over the last page or so because he keeps putting the same questions I have already answered back to me.

[mhsmith0]

Votecount 1.04

wilky (2)

Luca Blight , UC Voyager ,

UC Voyager (1)

gameplay506 ,

gameplay506 (1)

Thestatusquo ,

Luca Blight (1)

taiho ,

Not Voting (4)

Lxcifer , CsBlastoise , Derpy Hooves , wilky ,

Day one deadline is Sunday October 22, 6 PM PST. (expired on 2017-10-22 18:00:00)

Prodding CsBlastoise

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch!

[/size]

[Apple Jack]

Too soon mod. Too soon

[gameplay506]

I'm gonna find it hard not to scumread Wilky until I can understand his thought-process behind this:

Whilst I don't think any of the posts indicate any players role,

if Hooves actively and effectively scum hunts it might be nice to revisit Luca.

So what is the big problem with this post ?
Short and simple, I just skimmed your wallfight with wilky and I don't have the patience to search for an answer there

[gameplay506]

VOTE: Wilky

Here are my reads
Lucas

Spoiler:

I have a town read on them. They have made a decent case on Willy. Willy isl trying to make a case on them to.. And I have a scum read on Willy.

Shea

Spoiler:

I have a scum lean of him. i found his reaction to my entrance weird. He was talking about the whole RVS thing. About how it ends or whatever. Why does that matter? Shouldn't we be scum hunting?

Willy

Spoiler:

So I'm getting. A scum read on Willy. they tried to make a case on Derpy early on, but when one person found it scummy, he immediately found that person scummy. With not much to go off of, that's what I think.

Who is shea

[UC Voyager]

VOTE: Wilky

Here are my reads
Lucas

Spoiler:

I have a town read on them. They have made a decent case on Willy. Willy isl trying to make a case on them to.. And I have a scum read on Willy.

Shea

Spoiler:

I have a scum lean of him. i found his reaction to my entrance weird. He was talking about the whole RVS thing. About how it ends or whatever. Why does that matter? Shouldn't we be scum hunting?

Willy

Spoiler:

So I'm getting. A scum read on Willy. they tried to make a case on Derpy early on, but when one person found it scummy, he immediately found that person scummy. With not much to go off of, that's what I think.

Who is shea

Someone's title....there is a hint

[Luca Blight]

I'm gonna find it hard not to scumread Wilky until I can understand his thought-process behind this:

Whilst I don't think any of the posts indicate any players role,

if Hooves actively and effectively scum hunts it might be nice to revisit Luca.

So what is the big problem with this post ?
Short and simple, I just skimmed your wallfight with wilky and I don't have the patience to search for an answer there

Because what does Derpy's scumhunting or lack of it have to do with me?

I voted him on page 1 because he said he wouldn't push scumreads until day two. Wilky then says if Derpy decides to scumhunt it would 'be nice to revisit Luca' - which implies his scumhunting would make me look scummy. How could I be held accountable for something that happened

after

the post in question?

Wilky hasn't been able to answer this and has been backtracking that he meant it incriminated me, when clearly that's what was implied.

[wilky]

VOTE: Wilky

Here are my reads
Lucas

Spoiler:

I have a town read on them. They have made a decent case on Willy. Willy isl trying to make a case on them to.. And I have a scum read on Willy.

Shea

Spoiler:

I have a scum lean of him. i found his reaction to my entrance weird. He was talking about the whole RVS thing. About how it ends or whatever. Why does that matter? Shouldn't we be scum hunting?

Willy

Spoiler:

So I'm getting. A scum read on Willy. they tried to make a case on Derpy early on, but when one person found it scummy, he immediately found that person scummy. With not much to go off of, that's what I think.

Where do you think I was trying to build a case on Derpy? Not once have I said anything that would indicate I was building a case on him.

I'm gonna find it hard not to scumread Wilky until I can understand his thought-process behind this:

Whilst I don't think any of the posts indicate any players role,

if Hooves actively and effectively scum hunts it might be nice to revisit Luca.

So what is the big problem with this post ?
Short and simple, I just skimmed your wallfight with wilky and I don't have the patience to search for an answer there

Because what does Derpy's scumhunting or lack of it have to do with me?

I voted him on page 1 because he said he wouldn't push scumreads until day two. Wilky then says if Derpy decides to scumhunt it would 'be nice to revisit Luca' - which implies his scumhunting would make me look scummy. How could I be held accountable for something that happened

after

the post in question?

Wilky hasn't been able to answer this and has been backtracking that he meant it incriminated me, when clearly that's what was implied.

Really? Backtracking? I have been consistent with my answers on what has been the same questions over and over put to me from you. I have definitely not tried to incriminate you and I have definitely not backtracked.

[Luca Blight]

Do you not realise that for all your answers you never addressed my actual question?

[wilky]

Do you not realise that for all your answers you never addressed my actual question?

-At the time of posting my original comment there wasn't much activity in the thread. I was going off the small things we had.
-I believe that it would be nice to relook over the altercation once we have more to go on as it could help with further points (once again not automatically incriminating you though).


The comment was made to get conversation going. Whilst I meant what I said you seem to have taken that one comment and tunnelled on it without accepting any answers. You then focused solely on me incriminating you which definitely wasn't the case.

You have gotten over defensive right from the start on this debate and definitely seem like you have some thing to hide now. I had you down as a null read up until last night but now I have you down as null-scum but definitely leaning more towards the scum side.

[wilky]

Not sure how that's over the top?

Because I wasn’t asking for a free pass. It’s an illogical conclusion imo.

Missed thus post last night. Whilst I agree that Luca has been suspicious there was definitely an element to sarcasm in his initial post to you when talking about free passes.

[Apple Jack]

I didn’t detect any sarcasm

[Luca Blight]

Not overly defensive at all, Wilky - most of my points against you did not concern me; it just so happened that the most glaring of them was regarding your comment on me.

Ok, even if we forget the 'incriminating' part for a moment and just ask how derpy's future scumhunting would influence my post on page 1? My first post was made based on his first post, and is irrelevant to anything that might happen in the future.

And you seem to be using your read on me as some sort of threat. The fact is I'm Town and therefore don't care whether you scum read me or not; it doesn't influence the way I will treat you in this game.


Incidentally I'll be V/LA in two hours time for about a week. I'll try and stay active when possible.

[wilky]

There was an altercation between you and derpy that I said MIGHT be nice to go back to later in the game. A long with other information further down the line it MIGHT be usual. Note the emphasis on might here, I really don't get the big deal over my original comment tbh.

My read on you was not a threat if it was I would have placed my vote on you with it.

[Luca Blight]

I still don't understand why it would be nice to revisit it later in the game?

I made that post based on the information available at the time. How would anything that happens in the future have any bearing on what I said in that post?

If Hooves suddenly starts scumhunting would you be like 'hey, Luca said Hooves wanted a free pass on D1 which turned out not to be the case' as if I should have been able to look into the future and see that coming, when the information available at the time of my post contradicted that?

[taiho]

I'm here let me read what i missed while being away : )

[CsBlastoise]

Okay. I am definitely

not

used to forum mafia. Just yesterday I was thinking, "You know, I should put some activity in the Mafia Game thread; I haven't even looked at it since I made my first post," but I wasn't online at the moment, so I forgot until I got home and found a prod notification in my inbox. I looked at the thread again, and I was surprised at how it had exploded, growing by more than five whole pages, filled mostly by the wilky vs. Luca Blight situation. On that note, judging by how hard they're fighting, I'm leaning towards the conclusion that exactly one of them is scum, but I'm not sure which. Just a lean, just a feeling, don't take it too seriously yet.

I'm working on drafting a post with slightly more detailed responses to a lot of past activity in the thread, including how I wasn't trying to sound offended in post #28, but I don't have time to post it now because I have a shift at work soon. See you all in a few hours.

[mhsmith0]

Quick replaces Lxcifer effective immediately.

[UC Voyager]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Quick
you seem Quick to join they game.

Spoiler:

Dont worry. I will change it back after a few posts. I just always vote the new guy

[gameplay506]

I'm gonna find it hard not to scumread Wilky until I can understand his thought-process behind this:

Whilst I don't think any of the posts indicate any players role,

if Hooves actively and effectively scum hunts it might be nice to revisit Luca.

So what is the big problem with this post ?
Short and simple, I just skimmed your wallfight with wilky and I don't have the patience to search for an answer there

Because what does Derpy's scumhunting or lack of it have to do with me?

I voted him on page 1 because he said he wouldn't push scumreads until day two. Wilky then says if Derpy decides to scumhunt it would 'be nice to revisit Luca' - which implies his scumhunting would make me look scummy. How could I be held accountable for something that happened

after

the post in question?

Wilky hasn't been able to answer this and has been backtracking that he meant it incriminated me, when clearly that's what was implied.

What
What
?
Sry but this makes no sense
The whole you vs wilky is a headache of nonsensical posts and unless you have something more than this i suggest you back out cus wilky seems more like frustrated town than scum

I was thinking of switching my rvs vote but voyagers recent posts make not want to