Large Normal 208 - Fireworks Festival [End]

[pienyan]

votecount 1.8

Alisae (1) - beeboy
Nero Cain (1) - AxleGreaser
UC Voyager (1) - Rhah
Cabd (1) - Nero Cain
beeboy (1) - Dunkerdoodles
Whiskers (1) - Flubbernugget
TwoInAMillion (1) - Cabd
Joey_ (1) - Whiskers
Dunkerdoodles (1) - HolySpiritTurtle

Not voting (9) - Alisae, Shiro, I Am Innocent, Joey_, gerryoat, Quick, Nauci, UC Voyager, TwoInAMillion

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch. Deadline is October 23, 15:00 GMT-7 or in (expired on 2017-10-23 15:00:00).

Shiro is V/LA until October 17.

[HolySpiritTurtle]

lack of trust

Welcome to mafia

[Whiskers]

I think it's possible Camd's claim is correct and he just made a poor judgement in claiming.

Or maybe he did make the best decision in claiming exactly how he did and you are the one who lacks the information to decides if he outed correctly or not

Well I am obviously lacking information because he is not full claiming, but I fail to see if he thinks "his role gives him a short life" why full claiming would not be the best thing to do.

I agree with this. If he claims and can prove his role, he dies N1.
However, if he doesn't claim, town has a random lynch on their hands at the end of D1 (or semi-random lynch, I have the feeling it'll be the two biggest wagons that are lynched at the end of the day).

[preedit]
Also, Alisae judging me based on lack of info on personality (when the info is in my post history),
Alisae letting Joey off easy based on his personality.
Alisae saying, "Cabd doesn't make poor judgement calls!" and letting him off without scrutinizing him,

based on his personality

This is scum.

[TwoInAMillion]

I think it's possible Camd's claim is correct and he just made a poor judgement in claiming.

Or maybe he did make the best decision in claiming exactly how he did and you are the one who lacks the information to decides if he outed correctly or not

Well I am obviously lacking information because he is not full claiming, but I fail to see if he thinks "his role gives him a short life" why full claiming would not be the best thing to do.

Exactly, you dont have his full claim.

If hes town, theres a very good reason that he doesnt full claim atm, why doubt him for that? The only reason youd want him to full claim is if you think hes mafia, if not just let him try to play his role the best way possible.

This is like my 6th straight town game and I've played 0 scum games. I've learned not to trust people.

[Whiskers]

unvote
vote: Alisae

[Joey_]

Dude, if you knew the extend of my personnality in mafia games you wouldnt say that i was let off easily lmao

[HolySpiritTurtle]

Alisae saying, "Cabd doesn't make poor judgement calls!" and letting him off without scrutinizing him, based on his personality

Wouldnt this be experience, not personality?

[TwoInAMillion]

lack of trust

Welcome to mafia

touche

[Whiskers]

Alisae saying, "Cabd doesn't make poor judgement calls!" and letting him off without scrutinizing him, based on his personality

Wouldnt this be experience, not personality?

Maybe? But it still is going "He's super smart, so he can't be scum."

He's scummy.

And you are a communist.

I like how you go for the easy OMGUS personal attack in response to being called scum.

[Alisae]

Alisae saying, "Cabd doesn't make poor judgement calls!" and letting him off without scrutinizing him, based on his personality

Wow okay you are scum.
How am I supposed to scrutinize someone who isn't even here?
VOTE: Whiskers

[TwoInAMillion]

Another possibility is that Camd is a PGO or asking for doctor protection.

[HolySpiritTurtle]

Wait, why is judging people with lack of info scummy?

[Alisae]

PGOs are not normal and I highly doubt Pie would put one in this game or if the reviewers would approve it.

[Joey_]

Another possibility is that Camd is a PGO or asking for doctor protection.

I suggest you forget about cabd claims for a day or two and then revisit it when he actually claims or do something

[HolySpiritTurtle]

I claim PGO

[TwoInAMillion]

PGO would not be approved but a double lyncher would be?

[Whiskers]

Correction, "I know from past games that he's super smart. Therefore he can't be scum."

Alisae saying, "Cabd doesn't make poor judgement calls!" and letting him off without scrutinizing him, based on his personality

Wow okay you are scum.
How am I supposed to scrutinize someone who isn't even here?
VOTE: Whiskers

what? lol
Cabd

is

here!
Not only did he make his most recent post

after

you came back from your movie, IT IS A FORUM GAME, YOU CAN LEAVE A MESSAGE INTERROGATING SOMEONE EVEN IF THEY AREN'T CURRENTLY READING THE THREAD. IT STAYS THERE.

[Alisae]

Yeah TIAM you are like
probably town
because tbh bringing up the possibility of a PGO in a normal just doesn't sound like something scum would do
so just forget about the claim and focus on his play.
It'll be a fun challenge~

[Alisae]

HEY CABD
WHERE ARE YOU
APPARENTLY I'M SUPPOSED TO SCRUTINIZIE YOU

[Dunkerdoodles]

guys what if cabd is PGO

[HolySpiritTurtle]

^ ISO this guy

[Alisae]

THERE IS NO PGO
STOP
ITS A FUCKING MEME

[Dunkerdoodles]

no i just want my towncred

[beeboy]

Everytime i read the thread the post quality just declines.

[beeboy]

And instead of doing anything to help that I am just going to continue to try and make a new profile picture.