Large Normal 208 - Fireworks Festival [End]

[pienyan]

votecount 1.14

TwoInAMillion (4) - Cabd, beeboy, Dunkerdoodles, Whiskers

I Am Innocent (2) - TwoInAMillion, Nauci
UC Voyager (2) - Rhah, gerryoat
Nauci (2) - Alisae, Nero Cain
Whiskers (1) - Flubbernugget
Dunkerdoodles (1) - HolySpiritTurtle

Not voting (6) - Shiro, I Am Innocent, Joey_, Quick, UC Voyager, AxleGreaser

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch. Deadline is October 23, 15:00 GMT-7 or in (expired on 2017-10-23 15:00:00).

Shiro is V/LA until October 17.

[Nero Cain]

hi gerryboat, i hope you dont scumread me for defending and being associated with two towns this game

it would be great if you could vote the scum known as UC

here we go again lol

yeah, he's horrible. He's like an extra scum member. He's prob town as are you and UC.

[Nero Cain]

If I did say that please tell me where I did.

true, you didn't but I felt like your 542 implies that you were legit scumreading me at some point or another. We are 20+ pages in. Do you have any reads at this point?

[gerryoat]

hi gerryboat, i hope you dont scumread me for defending and being associated with two towns this game

it would be great if you could vote the scum known as UC

here we go again lol

yeah, he's horrible. He's like an extra scum member. He's prob town as are you and UC.

you're the horrible one lol, stop being salty

[gerryoat]

actually it's possible Nero is scum pretending to be extra salty. no way he gives a townread that easily

[Nero Cain]

yeah, he's horrible. He's like an extra scum member

[gerryoat]

VOTE: nero

[AxleGreaser]

FOS: AxelGreaser

back at you,
except i have a question


Can you explain why you thought these were good <pro town> questions to ask?

He hasn't given us the details:

*What is the name of the role?
*Is it only one shot?
*Can it be used any day?
*Are there restrictions on when it can be used?
*Do you have any other powers in addition to this one?

[Nauci]

Gerry seems quite yolo,

what do you mean by this? how is this even a read?

I'm not sure what you mean by "read" here.

It's the impression I have, thus far, of your posting style. Quickly lobbed tid bits of reactionary or impulsive posting which is thus far NAI.

[Nauci]

FOS: AxelGreaser

back at you,
except i have a question


Can you explain why you thought these were good <pro town> questions to ask?

He hasn't given us the details:

*What is the name of the role?
*Is it only one shot?
*Can it be used any day?
*Are there restrictions on when it can be used?
*Do you have any other powers in addition to this one?

How experienced is TIAM?

Accidental scumfishing is a trademark of new players.

But otherwise, it was quite the bit of scumfishing.

All we need to know for now is that Cabd has something up his sleeve that's demonstrable in the future, and giving more details to scum is probably anti town at this point. Obviously there are things we'd love to know about how it functions as town, but not necessarily at the expense of telling scum.

Awaiting more Cabd contributions to the thread for now!

[AxleGreaser]

If I did say that please tell me where I did.

true, you didn't but I felt like your 542 implies that you were legit scumreading me at some point or another. We are 20+ pages in. Do you have any reads at this point?

542 also said this.

Lets see where you go from here

which as per my last post means, while I have the concerns my last post defined very explicitly.
I was intending to disengage and see where you went.

As also indicated I appear not to work/think quite like you.

Do you have any reads at this point?

I have lots of "reads", my first post contained reads detailing what I knew about some people capabilities.
I find that important in then later deciding whether they headed off in a scummy or towny direction.

Is there anyone I am wanting to vote and say Vote Player1 : intention to lynch. <<< and if I say that I pretty serious.
Not Yet.

Speaking of which (here as counter example is me inertacting with CABD about his role)
@CABD I am expecting no reply to this. pls ta tia.

Spoiler: CABD

You have indicated

is going to be proven day one~

a role that can give town two lynches day one.

So as it is your role and you(CABD) are the informed minority about it, you get to decide when you should do what.
If there are to be "two Lynches" you will also get to manage what notification we have about when they will happen.
And when i need to know you will tell me.
AND
rather obviously (as in "

No shit sherlock

") as you will be making all those choices, town will judge you by their town utility.

and as previously observed by relative noob mafia player

so I am assuming Cabd is a sane actor

and that combined with my stated in the thread, estimation of CABD skill level

leaves me in the I dont need to know bucket.

hence asking not to be replied to.
-----

This example is brought to you by the letter A and the number 3.

Your interactions had a very different focus to mine.
but you are also not me.

Do you have any reads at this point?

I have a number of rocks i wish to look under. If i run out of those by then i will find more.
I am aware my vote is not in play.

[Nero Cain]

Awaiting more Cabd contributions to the thread for now!

Why does he need to post?

[AxleGreaser]

Some advice, when playing in school ground dont stamp in the puddles other people are playing in.
patients is a virtue.
I am not sure what would have happened next, but now I am not sure i will be able too interpret the response reliably as you poked too.

Spoiler: Naucis post and context.

[...]
Can you explain why you thought these were good <pro town> questions to ask?

[..the questions..]

How experienced is TIAM?

Accidental scumfishing is a trademark of new players.

But otherwise, it was quite the bit of scumfishing.

All we need to know for now is that Cabd has something up his sleeve that's demonstrable in the future, and giving more details to scum is probably anti town at this point. Obviously there are things we'd love to know about how it functions as town, but not necessarily at the expense of telling scum.

Awaiting more Cabd contributions to the thread for now![/quote]

Your points re TIAM are valid.
Your other options was to keep that powder dry, see what TIAM responded like and see what i did with it.

Was my question in some sense unfair?

TLDR: Answering questions asked of other players is often not clever.

How experienced are you?

This is something I regard as a mistake I find reasonable, for you to make. NAI.

Next time pls wait, see what I am doing, before being "helpful"

[AxleGreaser]

Y-you too

Yes i see where your vote is. and Skip is still curled up.

Spoiler: more obscure hard to read stuff

skip

.
.
.
.Grass
.
.
.

I assume you can multitask when you are next online.

[AxleGreaser]

@Two in amillion
just to be clear id still like you to answer my question to you in 582

[AxleGreaser]

Also

@nauci

, now i have a question for you

How experienced is TIAM?

Accidental scumfishing is a trademark of new players.

When you made this post, could you please clarify the intention/purpose of your post. (or what you were generally thinking about)

"suspicion of my motives?"

Was my question in some sense unfair?

or
"being helpful" as i described it.
or something I haven't thought of or didn't say.

[Nauci]

@Axle

My bad! I totally see the cock up now. I had meant to simply ask how experienced he was but sometimes I just vomit a lot of words.

[Nauci]

Gah I'm on mobile in bed and accidentally hit post.

I had originally intended to quote it and follow up ask him or you for an assessment of his experience level, but the comment somehow got away from me and I vomitted out my reasonings for wanting to know.

Didn't mean to smokescreen. T_T

[Nauci]

FOS is finger of suspicion.

What do you think about the wagon on you?

I forgot to directly answer this.

I don't have any particular reads as a result of the suspicion on me.

I understand why my joke about dunking lurkers sounds scummy if not taken as a joke. As I said before, the bits analyzing my read on Cabd get rather WIFOM when I was just offering up my perspective on something important to us.

I'd like to think that people will be more understanding of my low intel, few reads situation.

I don't think it's particularly telling if anyone was on me because they thought I was being scummy or if any actual scum were trying to drive an easy mislynch-the-new-person wagon. At least, not as telling as people's reactions to a claimed can-prove-today town PR.

[AxleGreaser]

Ok so now I reframe my question.

Also

@nauci

, now i have a question for you

@Axle

My bad! I totally see the cock up now. I had meant to simply

ask how experienced he was

but sometimes I just vomit a lot of words.

When you tried to make made that post, (asking only

that

but went too far)

could you please clarify the >>>

intention/purpose

<<< of your post. (or what you were generally thinking about)

"suspicion of my motives?"

Was my question in some sense unfair?

or
"being helpful" as i described it.
or something I haven't thought of or didn't say.

Perhaps answer this question too.

what were you trying to find out about who?
why were you trying to find that out?

[AxleGreaser]

and as my vote is not doing anything more important, for now.

Sup?

For someone who is quick, you are playing the game pretty slow.
Come on in the water is fine.

VOTE: Quick

[AxleGreaser]

Spoiler: previous gerry goat posts

hi gerryboat, i hope you dont scumread me for defending and being associated with two towns this game

it would be great if you could vote the scum known as UC

actually it's possible Nero is scum pretending to be extra salty. no way he gives a townread that easily

VOTE: nero

Gerry a little while ago you seemed to indicate you were fairly convinced, UC is Scum.

I now get two different strengths of your nero read.

actually it's possible Nero is scum

no way he gives a townread that easily

Do you have doubt. town!nero would give away that read?

[Nero Cain]

I understand why my joke about dunking lurkers sounds scummy if not taken as a joke. As I said before, the bits analyzing my read on Cabd get rather WIFOM when I was just offering up my perspective on something important to us.

re-reading your post I think I buy the joke thing but that's not really the reason that I was voting you in the first place.

I think that my biggest problem with Nauci is that her first post was mainly CABD related and that feels like a safe conversation to hang her hat on.

like, there wasn't much of an original thought and I was a bit concerned about that.

and these

that Nauci took a more "Cabd is town" approach from it which i kinda liked more

like I get the whole "CABD is a killing role he's town." (day sk? lol) but if Nauci is scum wouldn't "CABD is town!" stance be a good way to get town cred?

Maybe but she's also new. I think new scum could be subdued and passive. Town also OMGUS SUPER HARD. Pushing ppl is always a risk. I could see scum her not pushing anyone so she doesn't get OMGUS scum read.

Awaiting more Cabd contributions to the thread for now!

Why does he need to post?

And this feels buddyishy or to use the jargon of you offsiters...pocketing.

[Alisae]

People who townread 2iam; explain why plz kthnx.

Bringing up a pgo in a normal just comes off as loltown to me.

--

votecount 1.3

Shiro is V/LA until October 17.

Once again. You are not reading the goddamn thread. Know who doesn't bother reading the thread? People who already know all the fucking alignments.

A. Apparently I didn't "read the thread" when I 1. Missed a post saying you would do whatever you are doing as either alignment and 2. when you responded to my catchup post saying "why don't people read the thread?" Why are you treating me differently then tiam? If there's more to that read you're welcome to explain it because
B. This point is shit and you know this.

--

and as my vote is not doing anything more important, for now.

Sup?

For someone who is quick, you are playing the game pretty slow.
Come on in the water is fine.

VOTE: Quick

Dude its less then 24 hours since the day started -_-

[Alisae]

VOTE: Cabd