Newbie 1827: Baseball Game Over

[Apple Jack]

I have to reread some things with the mindset tsq is town. Once I do that I should have different reads.

I will say if tsq is town, I don’t like quick anymore but I still haven’t seen tsq give any actual reasons for him and he (tsq) still never answered my questions.

[wilky]

I have to reread some things with the mindset tsq is town. Once I do that I should have different reads.

I will say if tsq is town, I don’t like quick anymore but I still haven’t seen tsq give any actual reasons for him and he (tsq) still never answered my questions.

Yeah, I wasn't sure on quick until I done the ISO's and noticed the sort of back and thro from UC by mentioning he didn't like it yet still getting on the wagon then voting TSQ because of the wagon. Something just doesn't sit right there for me.

[taiho]

Cs and taiho I want your reads and a vote preferably in the next two posts.
Time to get this shit going.

Im already voting cs, i think hes scum, that hammer post is really scummy.

-..- im rlly exhausted atm ill do it tomorrow, true storyl!!

[Apple Jack]

Do you honestly think scum would hammer like that though? If scum want to blend in, how would he do that by hammering like that?

[Quick]

Quick why the backwards and forwards on that?

I thought what UCV did was Scummy, just not a slip. I make distinctions that a lot of people don't get a lot of the time and it makes me look Scummy a lot.

[mhsmith0]

Votecount 2.05

Quick (2)

Thestatusquo , wilky ,

wilky (1)

gameplay506 ,

CsBlastoise (1)

taiho ,

gameplay506 (1)

Quick ,

Not Voting (2)

CsBlastoise , Derpy Hooves ,

Day two deadline is Saturday November 4, 7 PM PST. (expired on 2017-11-04 19:00:00)

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch!

[/size]

[mhsmith0]

Thestatusquo has failed to pick up his prod and is being replaced.

Thor665 replaces Thestatusquo effective immediately.

[Apple Jack]

Ugh

[Thor665]

Greetings everybody.
Who's scum?

[Thor665]

No takers?

Vote: Wilky

Okay, I think Wilky is scum.
People should sheep me or explain why their read is better.

[Apple Jack]

Or maybe explain why wilky is scum cause nobody should blindly sheep anyone.

[Thor665]

I think he's scum due to wagon analysis and the night kill.

Why are you voting 'not voting'.
I'm a Daycop and checked him - he won't flip scum, I promise.

[Apple Jack]

I un-voted cause I need re-read. My scum team was dependent on your slot being scum and since nobody has cc'd your predecessor I was forced to unvote. I still don't fully trust your slot.

[Apple Jack]

I will do my re-read probably Wednesday

[Thor665]

I un-voted cause I need re-read. My scum team was dependent on your slot being scum and since nobody has cc'd your predecessor I was forced to unvote. I still don't fully trust your slot.

What do you think of my case on Wilky?

[Apple Jack]

lmk when you actually make one and I'll tell you.

[Thor665]

I did make one.

How about if you don't consider it a case/don't understand it you ask a question or explain why and I can expand on the case?

[Thor665]

Just to wear an IC hat for a moment;

"Player X is scum because he has an ugly avatar"

Is a case. It presents a position and is clear.
Now, it does lack support - and maybe you'd like to see more, or maybe you'd suggest the reasoning is faulty (I know I would ).
But it's still a case.
So, if you think wht I did isn't a case, I'll suggest you and I strongly disagree about what constitutes a case - maybe explain your definition and that can serve as a start of actual conversation about the game?

Unless you goal was just to be rude or insult me - then you did fine

[Apple Jack]

I mean you didn't really show your work or anything. I already mentioned the part about NK makes wilky look bad. It's why I am suspicious of your slot actually. My mind has scum as you/wilky but nobody cc'd your cop claim so here we are...

the VCA also points to your slot being scum, so if you are town then I don't really know how it points to wilky being scum.

I am a believer in posts they made. If you want to show me some posts wilky made that makes you so sure he is scum, i'd love to read them.

[Thor665]

I mean you didn't really show your work or anything.

I agree, I wasn't asked to though, nor did I refuse to do so.
So at worst what we have is you wanting information, not asking for it, and then complaining about what I'm doing.
Doesn't make a lot of sense, does it?
Your reaction makes perfect sense if I had refused to offer clarification though.

I already mentioned the part about NK makes wilky look bad. It's why I am suspicious of your slot actually. My mind has scum as you/wilky but nobody cc'd your cop claim so here we are...

That's derpy on a few levels.

the VCA also points to your slot being scum, so if you are town then I don't really know how it points to wilky being scum.

I would suggest that if you presume I'm town, that it easily suggest Wilky due to the final wagon of the day - how do you see that as non-telling?
I think we can both agree that there are high odds of at least one scum voting for that wagon, so if we both choose to agree that I'm town, and Wilky is one of four other voters, ought to at least show him as a 25% chance, yeah?

How do you think the VCA doesn't point to him?

I am a believer in posts they made. If you want to show me some posts wilky made that makes you so sure he is scum, i'd love to read them.

I've basically read no posts by them, it's why I cited VCA and NK analysis as my case.
If he's scum the posts he's making are lies anyway, so it's an adventure to wade through them anyway.

[wilky]

So what exactly is meant by my wagon analysis? I did join the UC wagon but I weren't the only one and quick joined it whilst saying it was a bad wagon. Also scum reading me but not reading my posts???

Derpy what does VCA mean?

[Apple Jack]

I agree, I wasn't asked to though, nor did I refuse to do so.
So at worst what we have is you wanting information, not asking for it, and then complaining about what I'm doing.

Um. You asked me to respond to a case you didn’t make.

My response back to you was my way of asking for information since I can’t respond to something that hasn’t been made.

You tried to blabber your way through a response and I followed it up with asking for specifics.

Don’t try to treat me like an idiot cause you are playing poorly.

[Apple Jack]

I would suggest that if you presume I'm town,

I don’t presume you are town. So the rest of this part is irrelevant

[Apple Jack]

I've basically read no posts by them, it's why I cited VCA and NK analysis as my case.

So basically you are promising somebody will flip scum without actually doing any work.

Yeah I don’t care if there is no cc.

VOTE: Thor

Impossible 2 separate players play this bad. It’s scum.

[Apple Jack]

Derpy what does VCA mean?

Ask the IC