Large Normal 209: BooneyToonz VI - Journey to Boon Island!

[Srceenplay]

It’s not bad. It’s been discussed.

[Egg]

Kokichi's issue was the "I don't care" and "why is it bad" together? I actually see your side of that argument that they were about different things. But I don't like the way you asked why it was a bad post. It felt like "shit, did I say something scummy?"

[Srceenplay]

Saying something is bad but not explaining is throwing shade without reason just to act busy. So if someone does that there is nothing wrong for someone to ask for a follow up.

[Egg]

I went back and looked just now with that in mind and it still feels more defensive than it feels like you questioning someone's intentions. Especially with this tacked on:

Him trying to goad me into voting him and me doing it?

[Srceenplay]

Rhetorical

[TywinL]

Srceen, you have been pretty vocal about lynching a SK claim over a PR claim. Why the vote on Assemble?

[TywinL]

Or atleast I'm pretty sure it was you.

[Egg]

Rhetorical

Probably why it came off defensive.

[TywinL]

Also, I think Fykus would agree with me, but I have a gut scumread on tchill simply because he's been active lurking all game.

[Fykus]

Also, I think Fykus would agree with me, but I have a gut scumread on tchill simply because he's been active lurking all game.

Agreed. Hes definitely "off" from what ive seen. What was he like on day 1? I think i recall mulch giving him instructions before he died so he must of been doing something right

[Srceenplay]

Srceen, you have been pretty vocal about lynching a SK claim over a PR claim. Why the vote on Assemble?

Hood thoughts.

I can talk about it later.

[TywinL]

He was on the Mulch wagon. Other than that, his posts don't really stand out which I think is tchill's intention. His ISO takes only takes a minute to skim.

[Transcend]

K but assembler

[TywinL]

When did we decide to not lynch Kaede?

[TywinL]

For the record, I believe Fykus over Assemble, but I'm just curious as to why we going this route.

[Egg]

Now that there is nothing to distract me...

Kokichi and Tywin did a lot of talking about tchill's meta without really getting specific. I'd love to know what they have noticed in his meta because I haven't figured him out yet. I read him incorrectly in our one finished game.

Whymafia's question about town reads on him and some other consensus stances is one that I see coming from town. I had actually just noticed myself that a lot of people's reads were matching my own. Then I looked back over my reads and yeah they all seem to be consensus reads. I feel like a lot of people are just on the same page. But that doesn't mean everyone is right. If a lot of those consensus reads turn out to be wrong, we need to look at the people who made those reads consensus. I'd suspect that 1-2 players who are consensus town reads and seem to be leading the charge probably turn out to be scum in that case. Problem is I don't know who that would be. Maybe Transcend? *shrug* (And of course after I type this I see three other people strengthen their whymafia town reads because of this post...)

I like Kaede recognizing a flaw in her own logic regarding tchill/screen being the same alignment.

I'm through page 20. Only a few things stood out in that stretch. Taking a break.

Town on top, scum on bottom:
Whymafia
Kaede
tywin
Transcend
Dunk
Kokichi
tchill
Kaito/fykus/skirt
Unabomb
Something Smart
Screenplay
Assemble

[Egg]

Can someone summarize the claims we've seen so far for me?

[WhyMafia]

Then I looked back over my reads and yeah they all seem to be consensus reads.

Yeah this is something common throughout the game, which is something that's been bugging me as well

[WhyMafia]

@Egg
We have Kaede - Who went from vig to SK to vig
Assemble, the even? night loyal JK who has confirmed Kaede is not the same alignment as him
and Fykus, the JOAT who used an invest N1 to find Piss had a gun, healed? Transcend N2, and now has a 1 Shot JK

[WhyMafia]

Also, I think Fykus would agree with me, but I have a gut scumread on tchill simply because he's been active lurking all game.

yes
We're putting him on the hot seat tomorrow/day 5

[WhyMafia]

Kokichi and Tywin did a lot of talking about tchill's meta without really getting specific. I'd love to know what they have noticed in his meta because I haven't figured him out yet. I read him incorrectly in our one finished game.

I'm using a bit of meta, but just look at his ISO lol
He's been active elsewhere as well ..

[WhyMafia]

No matter what, we're lynching between Kaede & Assemble. I'll vote either. I gave some more thought. Neither Assemble, nor Fykus's night actions make sense to me. Kaede's day play has been better than Assemble's, therefore I suppose I'll VOTE: assemble

[Srceenplay]

Srceen, you have been pretty vocal about lynching a SK claim over a PR claim. Why the vote on Assemble?

Hood thoughts.

I can talk about it later.

I want to believe Kaede.

There is now three of us in the hood. I’m making an assumption that 1 is scum. Piss crumb his role and actions and now he is dead. So I’m sure one of Assemblerotws or scarscat is scum.

I’m thinking it’s a toss up.

Last game Boon seemed to have mirrored type roles.
Some were Town and town
And iirc one was town and scum.

If Assemblerotws and Fykus are mirrored I think it could be Town and scum

[Egg]

@Egg
We have Kaede - Who went from vig to SK to vig
Assemble, the even? night loyal JK who has confirmed Kaede is not the same alignment as him
and Fykus, the JOAT who used an invest N1 to find Piss had a gun, healed? Transcend N2, and now has a 1 Shot JK

Oh wow.

So Assemble who is scummy anyway can't be town with Kaede...which explains the 1v1.

Why did Fykus claim?

I'm using a bit of meta, but just look at his ISO lol
He's been active elsewhere as well ..

Well my question is more about his meta. What is different between his scum play and town play?

[Something_Smart]

What is different between his scum play and town play?

scum: potshots and stating reads

town: actual prodding and asking questions

this is of course a massive oversimplification. but I get the feeling that he's trying to solve rather than direct.