In post 1964, Apple Jack wrote:He town read scum. Scum read town. Didn’t want to lynch scum. Refused to explain his reads. Backed down when asked to explain his scum reads.
I just can’t see how that is town play.
I have had 2 other games with dunker and he plays a shit town game where his reads are almost always dead wrong. While I'm not saying he benefits town and I have no idea what his scum play looks like, this isn't the strongest reason to potentially mislynch him.
In post 1974, Tchill13 wrote:Hmm... Speed skimmed nauci. He hard defends anime and throws what seems to be fake shade at chickadee. Meaning he votes chickadee and quickly finds another reason to vote someone else but claims to be suspicious of chickadee in multiple reads lists while constantly taking his vote off her.
Nauci/dave/flavor/gurgi/dunker/tchill/derpy/xl
We Lynch in this order we win. Anyone else disagree?
Can we please stop confusing my gender why is it so much to ask to be referred to by the proper pronoun? I corrected XL on it in the first day and it's lame to have at least 3 people still fuck it up.
I defended anime because I thought the way he questioned why I town read him as town. He didn't keep up this style of scum hunting, and fell into a shit ton of defensive posts. I gave him a respite from voting him after his explanation, but upon rereading him I thought his reasons were bullshit because he wasn't attacking anyone's shitty logic, he was ONLY being defensive. I FOSed him, but was voting lurkers because I wasn't ready for the day to be over yet. I was caught by surprise when I checked back in the thread and Chickadee had already been lynched, and was highly suspicious of Porkens for the lolhammer.
With Chickadee, I was very suspicious of her constant excuses to not post well, but didn't still feel she was posting nearly as scummy as Wossi. I also, again, wasn't ready for the day to be over yet, and wasn't fully on board with the lynch. I didn't have time to pop in until just after Porkens lolhammered.
In post 1976, Tchill13 wrote:VOTE: nauci
Alright screw it. I'm giving up on the flavor suspicion at the moment.
As of rn I'm operating according to the lists that I have supplied unless I'm shown a reason not to.
I'm not sure why there's cause to FOS Flavor in the first place. I am giving him town credit for calling town correctly on Wossi, and driving the wagons for both Chickadee and Animetrix. I feel like it would be ridiculous to bus BOTH partners so early when there are potentially a lot of town PR left.
In post 1991, Tchill13 wrote:Let's Lynch nauci here after Dave provides some input on the situation.
In post 1994, Tchill13 wrote:I'm just wondering why xl was your preferred case when there were associatves to be made with Dave and nauci also. That's all that has me suspicious.
In post 2004, Flavor Leaf wrote: In post 2001, Tchill13 wrote:It's not confirmed 3 scum either. I could see a scenario where dunk and flavor are the last 2 scum due to flavors defense of dunk. Wouldn't it be more likely there's 4 scum anyway because of the "backup" modifier?
No. 1 kill night 1, 2 Night 2.
In post 2005, Apple Jack wrote: In post 1989, Flavor Leaf wrote: In post 1987, Tchill13 wrote:News flash having a "good game" or not doesn't matter. Winning or losing is what matters.
Yep, and I’m on my way to bringing this town to victory. Was hardcore right on 2 scum and multiple town already.
Having “accurate reads” doesn’t mean you helped town.
Chick got lynched more for my contributions than yours. Basically her 180 and denying she sheeped me when she clearly did was her downfall.
You get no credit for the anime kill.
Take your ego and go on with yourself. You really have nothing to help town.
Derpy you have so many shitposts. These stupid "I get the credit" battles are dumb, and accurate reads that he actively pushes are the very definition of helping town.
You have every potential to make good posts but instead just throw out this kind of hypocritical crap.
In post 2010, Apple Jack wrote: In post 2009, Tchill13 wrote:So what are the chances xl is a werewolf that claimed vig? Or am I being stupid?
Per the wiki flavor is right. Mafia gunsmith would not find a gun on a SK.
So we either have a vig or mod trickery. For now I’ll err on the side of vig. Occam’s razor and all that jazz.
I'm not following. Why would it matter if mafia find or don't find a gun on an SK? How would you know? They killed Porkens, so presumably they found a gun on him.
Someone explain to me how this is a read of existing facts and not some sort of scum slip on gunsmith results.
Yeah I'm not sure what you think you've caught me at because I've just been town posting. My reads were very shaken by the flips thus far and I needed to take time to reread and re-evaluate. So far I FOS Dave, think Gurgi needs to post a lot more, and want to re ISO Tchill and Flavor.
In post 2017, davesaz wrote:Yes, I saw the earlier posts regarding Nauci interactions with Animetrix. At the time I thought the person who pointed that out could be scum throwing shade, but in light of flips it fits great.
VOTE: Nauci
How come you always lurk for a long time then pop in to conveniently join whatever wagon is active?
In post 2038, Apple Jack wrote:UNVOTE:
this game is basically solved, no reaosn not to claim tbh. scum has like a 11% chance of winning.
Don't be so overconfident. One PR is already outed so if we guess wrong we're definitely losing it. I don't really trust approaching a lylo situation with you and dunker around, and Dave and Gurgi lurking.
Current reads:
Flavor - towny
XL - probably vig
Derpy - bad town
Tchill - can't get a good read; need to ISO
Dave - scumlurking
Gurgi - hard to read because of lurking; FOSing but need to ISO