If it were just the use of the role, I would be a little more on the fence. People get barnacles in their brains sometimes and do nonsensical things when everyone is all sleepin' in their bunks, which should still be punished, but is far from a silver bullet.
Let me once more be summarizin' the issues:
-From
290 and
357, we be learnin' that the snakey dragon can discover the title of sailors' deckhand duties, but she was thinkin' she would also learn where their loyalties lie. It already be a little strange that she be thinkin' this, but maybe the barnacles in her brain be larger than usual.
-Now way back when, she be postin'
198. Now I want ye all to be thinkin' about that. If ye were snakey-dragon and ye be thinkin' ye were a combined Cop + Rolecop, how would ye react to a miller claim? Would ye be defendin' it like she was? Even if ye have some barnacles in yer brains, ye have to be findin' a miller claim more than a little suspicious.
-Not role related, but in
201, we have her sayin' "hey, let's not be feedin' the sunny scummy diamond to the sharks. I be 'more confident' about the sailor who has only 2 posts." She had never mentioned the sunny diamond before this post.
-Then comes the night. From what we be knowin', here's what the snakey dragon be thinkin': ASP be her top suspect o' scurviness, and she was on the fence with the gun-slingin' matey (
410). Despite this, she be visitin' the bee fer a pretty silly reason (
360) with what she believed to be a cop investigation that also gets deckhand duties.
-She had the bee feller's role title and thought a massclaim was happening, but wasn't interested in hearing the bee feller's claim before revealin' that she had visited him.
-Her 'splanation for not targetin' ASP is "why waste the shot in a slot I want dead" (
371). Yet she had not made a single post pushing ASP since 198.
--
Now, as I said, I could believe some of these could come from a non-scurvy sailor who got bonked on the noggin one too many times, but surely not all of it while retainin' the ability to scrawl complete sentences. It be far, far more likely that she simply be scummier than a seagull after an oil spill.