Mini #556 - The Most Excellent People Ever - Called.

[Guardian]

hm. interesting of you to point this out publicly.

I see no reason to not investigate now that it is partially in the open:

Korlash, do you have role based knowledge that jester is scumz?

[Korlash]

No, purely meta reasons combined with his poor excuse for his "pressure vote."

[Guardian]

So lloyd, how do you feel about your vote now that you're pulling this role based info out of your ass?

[Rosso Carne]

QUICK UPDATE

DizzyIzzyB13 replaces RangeroftheNorth

Also, looking for a replacement for tyhess.

[The Jester]

Hi Dizzy! How are you? Want some Tea?

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Izzy is not a fan of tea, being stuck licing in England where they love the stuff. But thanks for offering all the same.

Lloyd is L-2. I am severely tempted to knock him to L-1 to see what reaction it will garner, especially since the argument that he is scummy is vaguely persuasive, but given that the guy I replaced gathered a bunch of votes for putting someone to L-1, I'm leery of it.

[The Jester]

You're in England?

I love you already...

[DizzyIzzyB13]

I live there yes. I am not a native. And if we were still in the joke voting phase, that would have earned you a "vote: Jester" for proclaiming love so quickly.

Although... sucking up could be a scum tell anyway...

[WhoMe?]

I live there yes. I am not a native. And if we were still in the joke voting phase, that would have earned you a "vote: Jester" for proclaiming love so quickly.

Although... sucking up could be a scum tell anyway...

Hell, I'm tempted to vote you for being "stuck" here...

[Guardian]

Damn, WHoMe?. I forgot you were even playing....

[The Jester]

Consider it Out of character, as a greeting to the new replacement.

Native or otherwise, doesn't matter.

Still...don't be like that...

[Guardian]

Why were you so active Feb 20 and then became so inactive, WhoMe??

[WhoMe?]

Why were you so active Feb 20 and then became so inactive, WhoMe??

i check in on mafiascum damn near every day. Something must have caught my attention then, not so much recently

[Korlash]

yay new person...

Psst... you should vote jester anyway... >.>

[Lloyd]

So lloyd, how do you feel about your vote now that you're pulling this role based info out of your ass?

i feel dumb now, for seeing something that wasn't there. i'll re-read this game again

[lovo14]

im away til monday. my vote will stay on llyod.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

vote: Panzer

I've read through the thread a couple of times, and I'm not sure he has adequate reasons for his suspicion that Lloyd is scum, especially given how hard he's pushing for him to be lynched. I'd like Panzer to explain his suspicion in as much detail as possible.

[Cavebear with a toothache]

Sorry for not posting lately, I didn't want to post until I felt I could add something substantial to the discussion. In any case, I'll be out of town for a week starting tomorrow, and I'm not sure what my Internet access will be like. I'll check in when/if I can.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Also: Who Me? pretty much confessed to lurking. I don't know if this is a scum tell or just caution, but I'm not a fan of it.

[WhoMe?]

Also: Who Me? pretty much confessed to lurking. I don't know if this is a scum tell or just caution, but I'm not a fan of it.

I have a vote in play. If i don't see anything comment worthy when i read up, i don't post fluff just to say i'm here.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

It doesn't help the town if you're not letting people get a read on you., which is what lurking does. It's a hinderance, that makes you seem scummy.

[PJ.]

Dizzy, Did you read my reasons for voting Llyod? How clear must I be? Since then he has lurked hardcore and grasped at straws for his big "aha" reason. Which would have outted a cop btw. Must I be more clear?

[Lloyd]

notes i jotted down from re-reading:

urza - i've never seen anyone so bent on lynching someone else, to the point of posting an out of game thread about it
viewtopic.php?t=7493

guardian - since i consider mafiascum games as 25% finding scum, and 75% convincing others that i've found scum...i like playing with guardian more than urza, as guardian is less stubborn about who to lynch.

pan - he seems determine to lynch me, but it pales in comparison to urza's determination to lynch korlash.

lovo - he seems overly conscious about his vote, which seems typical for him. typical lovo for not participating much on day 1s, and preferring day 2s and beyond instead.

whome - reminds me of lovo's playstyle of not doing much on day 1s, but less extreme about it

ranger - even though he's been replaced, i still agree with him about having shorter day 1s.

ua - his recent absence is indicative that this game has stalled. i don't understand what the reference to team asshat was about

thanantos - i was wrong about his claim trying to get discussion going. i don't get the reason to get jester to pick up on it. otherwise, hard to read.

carebear - his positive tone seems reminds me of thanatos'. hard to read as well.

jester - interestingly, i didn't see he confirm nor deny korlash' claim that they know each other a long time in person

korlash - seems jovial about getting jester lynched. if it's for meta-gaming reasons, i can only take it at face value since i never played with either before

dizzy - playstyle seems genuine so far, need more posts to get a better read

tyhess - will probably be replaced, posts so far don't seem to say much

[Guardian]

lloyd... from this re-read... who is scum? did you neglect the 25% of the game that you allocate to finding scum, and just do the convincing part?

[Lloyd]

haven't gotten to the 25% yet

was just posting notes first

need to analyze next