In post 105, davesaz wrote: In post 100, HeWhoSwims wrote: In post 57, Jodaxq wrote:
Not sure what to think about this. It seems so scummy that I can't see scum doing it.
I agree with this. I feel like it would be too obvious an action for scum and especially for experienced scum.
Scum might do it for exactly that reason. There is usually far more pressure on the hammer vote, especially if quick. And if it's a bus they get to use it as an argument against being a partner for the rest of the game.
I can see what you (and others) are saying. I'd personally think scum doing something like that would take a risk as it could lead to more discussion which might hurt scum... then again I don't have too much experience around here and nothing else about Tchill seems suspicious to me.
Tchill13 wrote:how in the world are beef and odd getting thrown around as town reads?
For now I'm asking myself too, not because they look scummy to me but because I just haven't seen them do anything really pro-town... unsure what exactly to make of odd, on one hand his "screenplay's reaction is out of place" is a bit weird to me but after that he seems to dive into the wagon on screen. Calling beef and jodaxq "very town" again this early is eh.
Beef, I'm not sure what to make of him so far. It's way too early to throw out definitive leads. Something that does spring out to me is that he initially votes for oddmusic, then Tchill, then seems to believe in Tchill's "1 of these is scum" idea and votes back on oddmusic. As I said I'm not sure what exactly to make of it but it just sprung out to me. You could probably argue it's pro-town because he's keeping an open view and is not tunneling, you could also say it's being confusing, or that it's contributing to discussion... for now I tend to lean towards this being pro-town as it might lead to more discussion and content, which means more reads which means better chances for Town.
