Newbie 1838: Pirates vs Ninjas: GAME OVER!

[wilky]

yea because apparently nothing would have

You gave up like straight away at my intent, you haven't brought much forward in terms of advancing the game and you were clearly actively lurking until I called you out on it.

[acidphoenix]

1. ?
2. yeah because of lack of motivation to play and lack of... anything, not doing things
3. a. pretty sure active lurking refers to filler not reading and not playing but b. see answer 2

[acidphoenix]

unless it's revealed that somehow that wasn't actually hammer this is my last post

[fferyllt]

Vote Count 1-8

acidphoenix

(5): smilefires, Jodaxq, Alonzo, Nauci, wilky

Alonzo

(2): mozamis, acidphoenix

Nauci

(1): TheGoldenParadox

Not Voting

(1): Bellaphant

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline: December 16, Midnight US Eastern Time.

Countdown: (expired on 2017-12-15 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

-

A Lynch Has Been Achieved!

[fferyllt]

acidphoenix was a

Mafia Goon

.

Night 1 begins now and will end Wednesday, December 13, Midnight US Eastern Time

Countdown: (expired on 2017-12-12 21:00:00)

[fferyllt]

Mozamis died last night. He was a

Vanilla Townie

.

[fferyllt]

Vote Count 1-1

Day 2 Begins!

]

Not Voting

(7): smilefires, wilky, Jodaxq, Alonzo, Nauci, TheGoldenParadox, Bellaphant

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline: December 29, Midnight US Eastern Time.

Countdown: (expired on 2017-12-28 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

-

[Nauci]

HIGH FIVES ALL AROUND GUYS

Okay I think my current tiers are:

smilefires, wilky (both have a lot of good, substantive posts with what read to me as town motivation)
Jodaxq (null, leaning town)
Bella (null)
TGP, Alonzo (FOS! I had Mozamis here but I guess he's defintely not scum!)

I'll write up something more in depth when I have time later.

Awesome reads, people!

[Jodaxq]

I have a few questions for VOTE: TheGoldenParadox

Why did you kill Mozamis? He was most certainly your best shot at a mislynch today. Why not Smiles or Wilky who most of us read as town? I feel like your only real path to victory was to kill wilky/smiles/me, have us mislynch Mozamis, kill wilky/smiles/me, and then have Bellaphant be convinced enough of Alonzo by the end of the game. It's a long shot, but I hope your kill of Mozamis wasn't a give up type of thing.

How did you feel when Acidphoenix voted you? Did you all plan the whole Acid votes TGP, TGP makes towny post, acid town reads TGP interaction? Did you consider bussing him once we were all on to him?

I'm interested in this Mafia Mystery app that you talked about briefly. How different is it to play scum on there versus here? Did you find it easier or harder? What about it?

[Bellaphant]

I haaaate night kill spec, but wow that was a strange one. As Jo says, moz was 100% my preferred lynch for today.

Wagon make up suggests Alonzo is also town. I'm hard town reading wiky , so my scum pile is tiny.

Jo, nauci, please talk to me about smiles

[Alonzo]

Ok that is not the Nk I was expecting.

Nauci... What is that sad list you have written?

[Jodaxq]

Jo, nauci, please talk to me about smiles

Smiles is town.

[Jodaxq]

Ok that is not the Nk I was expecting.

Nauci... What is that sad list you have written?

It has VOTE: TheGoldenParadox in the right spot so it can't be that sad.

[wilky]

As has been said Nk speculation probably isn't the best of place but a NK on a very lynchable player is weird.

On my lunch break right now but off the top of the head without going back through anything i'm thinking:

Town

Jordaxq - Bella
Smiles

Null

Nauci

Scum-Lean

Alonzo

Scum

TGP

I'm not commiting to any votes until tonight at the earliest as I won't be around the next few hours. I'll try ISO Moz quickly to see what I can see before I have to go back to work and then tonight i'll ISO Acid tonight.

[wilky]

So scum in Alonzo, Golden,Blooper, Acid, Belle???

Probably the most noteworthy thing I can find in Moz's ISO. I'd hedge my bets that the last scum is within that list. Acid is dead which narrows it down further.

My thoughts on the list:

Alonzo, Golden,

Blooper (Jordaxq)

,

Acid

,

Belle

I have strong town reads on the Blooper and Belle spots mentioned in Moz's post. So i'd narrow it down to two from their.

Moz went after Alonzo for most of the day yesterday but that actually makes me doubt that Alonzo is the scum that killed him as it would be too easy and I guess scum would want us to think it was Alonzo. That of course is all WIFOM though.

[TheGoldenParadox]

I have a few questions for VOTE: TheGoldenParadox

Why did you kill Mozamis? He was most certainly your best shot at a mislynch today. Why not Smiles or Wilky who most of us read as town? I feel like your only real path to victory was to kill wilky/smiles/me, have us mislynch Mozamis, kill wilky/smiles/me, and then have Bellaphant be convinced enough of Alonzo by the end of the game. It's a long shot, but I hope your kill of Mozamis wasn't a give up type of thing.

How did you feel when Acidphoenix voted you? Did you all plan the whole Acid votes TGP, TGP makes towny post, acid town reads TGP interaction? Did you consider bussing him once we were all on to him?

I'm interested in this Mafia Mystery app that you talked about briefly. How different is it to play scum on there versus here? Did you find it easier or harder? What about it?

Wow. Just wow.
The second you come back on to the game, you accuse me of scum like I am scum, you make it the only possibility. Why?
I will now answer your questions, but not in the implied meaning that I am scum, because I am not.
I did not kill Mozamis. (obviously, vanilla townies cannot kill anyone.)
When Acidphoenix voted me, I did not really care, since there are better reads and I wasn't scum anyway, so there was no reason to suspect me for things that I hadn't done.
I obviously cannot plan anything with him.
Mafia Mystery, I think it is much easier to play scum than on forum games or real-life games, whereas it's harder to play town. (I have either real-life played or forum played both scum and town, and same with Mafia Mystery.)

[TheGoldenParadox]

As has been said Nk speculation probably isn't the best of place but a NK on a very lynchable player is weird.

On my lunch break right now but off the top of the head without going back through anything i'm thinking:

Town

Jordaxq - Bella
Smiles

Null

Nauci

Scum-Lean

Alonzo

Scum

TGP

I'm not commiting to any votes until tonight at the earliest as I won't be around the next few hours. I'll try ISO Moz quickly to see what I can see before I have to go back to work and then tonight i'll ISO Acid tonight.

See my previous post. Why have I suddenly turned to scum?

[Jodaxq]

I have a few questions for VOTE: TheGoldenParadox

Why did you kill Mozamis? He was most certainly your best shot at a mislynch today. Why not Smiles or Wilky who most of us read as town? I feel like your only real path to victory was to kill wilky/smiles/me, have us mislynch Mozamis, kill wilky/smiles/me, and then have Bellaphant be convinced enough of Alonzo by the end of the game. It's a long shot, but I hope your kill of Mozamis wasn't a give up type of thing.

How did you feel when Acidphoenix voted you? Did you all plan the whole Acid votes TGP, TGP makes towny post, acid town reads TGP interaction? Did you consider bussing him once we were all on to him?

I'm interested in this Mafia Mystery app that you talked about briefly. How different is it to play scum on there versus here? Did you find it easier or harder? What about it?

Wow. Just wow.
The second you come back on to the game, you accuse me of scum like I am scum, you make it the only possibility. Why?
I will now answer your questions, but not in the implied meaning that I am scum, because I am not.
I did not kill Mozamis. (obviously, vanilla townies cannot kill anyone.)
When Acidphoenix voted me, I did not really care, since there are better reads and I wasn't scum anyway, so there was no reason to suspect me for things that I hadn't done.
I obviously cannot plan anything with him.
Mafia Mystery, I think it is much easier to play scum than on forum games or real-life games, whereas it's harder to play town. (I have either real-life played or forum played both scum and town, and same with Mafia Mystery.)

TheGoldenParadox

[Jodaxq]

My tier list:

100% Town

Bellaphant, Wilky, Smilefires, Alonzo, Nauci

100% Scum

TheGoldenParadox

[Jodaxq]

VOTE: TheGoldenParadox

Come on everyone, let's lynch this and move on to our next games.

[Jodaxq]

I have a few questions for VOTE: TheGoldenParadox

Why did you kill Mozamis? He was most certainly your best shot at a mislynch today. Why not Smiles or Wilky who most of us read as town? I feel like your only real path to victory was to kill wilky/smiles/me, have us mislynch Mozamis, kill wilky/smiles/me, and then have Bellaphant be convinced enough of Alonzo by the end of the game. It's a long shot, but I hope your kill of Mozamis wasn't a give up type of thing.

How did you feel when Acidphoenix voted you? Did you all plan the whole Acid votes TGP, TGP makes towny post, acid town reads TGP interaction? Did you consider bussing him once we were all on to him?

I'm interested in this Mafia Mystery app that you talked about briefly. How different is it to play scum on there versus here? Did you find it easier or harder? What about it?

Wow. Just wow.
The second you come back on to the game, you accuse me of scum like I am scum, you make it the only possibility. Why?
I will now answer your questions, but not in the implied meaning that I am scum, because I am not.
I did not kill Mozamis. (obviously, vanilla townies cannot kill anyone.)
When Acidphoenix voted me, I did not really care, since there are better reads and I wasn't scum anyway, so there was no reason to suspect me for things that I hadn't done.
I obviously cannot plan anything with him.
Mafia Mystery, I think it is much easier to play scum than on forum games or real-life games, whereas it's harder to play town. (I have either real-life played or forum played both scum and town, and same with Mafia Mystery.)

I appreciate your last answer so thank you for that. Now can you please come back and answer the other questions truthfully? I'm genuinely interested why you killed Mozamis.

[Alonzo]

Wolves

Alonzo Bellaphant mozamis Nauci
Null

Acid Wilky

Sheep

Smilefires

Undecided on Blooper

Nothing from Paradox

Comparing my list of wolves vs Naucis list of reads, we may have a problem here....

[Alonzo]

I appreciate your last answer so thank you for that. Now can you please come back and answer the other questions truthfully? I'm genuinely interested why you killed Mozamis.

Will you be voting for Golden the next 14 days do you suppose?

[wilky]

Wolves

Alonzo Bellaphant mozamis Nauci
Null

Acid Wilky

Sheep

Smilefires

Undecided on Blooper

Nothing from Paradox

Comparing my list of wolves vs Naucis list of reads, we may have a problem here....

Why?

[Alonzo]

Im not sure this town is big enough for the both of us...

Unless you agree That Me and my scum partner bussed each other all day yesterday, followed by me killing moza, the obv mislynch, Which is what nauci seems to..