In post 684, Jabarkas Mayonnaise wrote:
Why N15? Didn't he claim a protective role? Do you think that claim honestly comes from scum trying to get someone else lynched via counterclaim? Because, if so, then if acid flips the role they claimed, nothing would stop people from lynching N15 for driving the lynch there.
drealmer what if I say I'm deciding between lynching Yetichain and lynching northsidegal today and your thoughts on why you want to lynch northsidegal might tip the scales, would you then think that it is meaningful to share your thoughts?
hi meet my mafiascum gravestone, the flowers were probably left by camn or schadd or Prism, blow them kisses for me would you?
In post 729, nancy wrote:drealmer what if I say I'm deciding between lynching Yetichain and lynching northsidegal today and your thoughts on why you want to lynch northsidegal might tip the scales, would you then think that it is meaningful to share your thoughts?
In post 457, Not Known 15 wrote:
They claimed a neighbourizing and a protective role. That looks strange to me because of what
my
role is. A bit too close, perhaps. Depends on what they really are.
That’s not claiming a protective role NOR is any of that a “counterclaim” in a closed setup. Easy to wiggle out of the reprocussions if it got acid lynched.
Furthermore, town would, I hope, not cc there anyway, all that’s done is out yourself as a relevant pr.
So no that doesn’t give me any pause.
Hell, are you saying we lynch acid if n15 flips town because of the same reasons?
In post 737, nancy wrote:Since you mention it though, do you want to lynch Yeti or do you just not not want to lynch Yeti?
that's a good question all I've got for you is I could go either way ? which is more indifference which is more the "not not" option but I could totally see myself getting some enthusiasm there without much to make it happen which would turn it into "want"
T_T
Porkens, if you read my exchange with NK15, you'd know those answers already;
1. There's no such thing as a counterclaim in a closed setup, especially role madness.
2. It only makes sense as either play from a town PR legitimately thinking they are validly counterclaiming or from scum attempting a counterclaim that holds no weight because it's a closed setup and D1 anyway so if NK15 is scum doing a CC gambit, they're just going to be lynched the next day
3. I believe they can both be town and be neighborizing protectives.
What makes the NK15 soft-claim there really notable is that I don't think acid claimed anything close to protective--just neighborizer while softing there might be more.
-V
The best way to achieve your goals is through conquest.
I don't think there's any way that I come away from reading NK15's soft-claim and my exchange with him after that as indicating NK15 is scum.
It legitimately looks as though NK15 is counterclaiming acid because they believe it's a valid counterclaim.
Once they realize it isn't, they back away from pushing acid.
It baffles me how none of the people pushing NK15 address that.
-V
The best way to achieve your goals is through conquest.
In post 741, Jabarkas Mayonnaise wrote:T_T
Porkens, if you read my exchange with NK15, you'd know those answers already;
1. There's no such thing as a counterclaim in a closed setup, especially role madness.
2. It only makes sense as either play from a town PR legitimately thinking they are validly counterclaiming or from scum attempting a counterclaim that holds no weight because it's a closed setup and D1 anyway so if NK15 is scum doing a CC gambit, they're just going to be lynched the next day
3. I believe they can both be town and be neighborizing protectives.
What makes the NK15 soft-claim there really notable is that I don't think acid claimed anything close to protective--just neighborizer while softing there might be more.
-V
2. How does nk get lynched the next day? Especially considering your 3.
3. Acid softed John Reese “come with me if you if you want to live”, that’s how I read it.
Could you rephrase/clarify "which is more indifference which is more the "not not" option" please? Are you saying indifference is more the "not not" option?
hi meet my mafiascum gravestone, the flowers were probably left by camn or schadd or Prism, blow them kisses for me would you?
