Newbie 1839: Game over

[JunkoChan]

SHHHHHHHHHHH you are not supposed to speak after hammer, GuiltyLion should have said so, please teach the new players, since acid is dead.

[GuiltyLion]

Eh, people have different views about twilight (after hammer but before threadlock) posting. I think for D1 it's mostly harmless - if you are town, mostly just consider whether the info you're giving on your reads will help scum make a more informed NK or not.

It can sometimes be useful in that scum have a harder time posting believably during twilight when they know what the person is going to flip - I've seen players towntell in twilight before because their posts were obviously ignorant of the upcoming flip and/or still working to gamesolve.

[nancy]

Votecount 1.09

acidphoenix

(5)

~ GuiltyLion, RedFlavor, 3 Masons in a Trenchcoat, Impede, JunkoChan

talon152 (2)

~ HeWhoSwims, acidphoenix

JunkoChan (1)

~ talon152

Not voting (1)

~ wavemode

With 9 alive, 5 votes were needed to lynch.
Day 1 has ended with a lynch.

[nancy]

acidphoenix,

Vanilla Townie

, Lynched Day 1.

It is now Night 1. Night 1 deadline is in (expired on 2017-12-20 17:28:15).

[nancy]

GuiltyLion,

Vanilla Townie

, Died Night 1.

It is now Day 2.

Votecount 2.00

Not voting (7)

~ 3 Masons in a Trenchcoat, JunkoChan, HeWhoSwims, Impede, talon152, RedFlavor, wavemode

With 7 alive, 4 votes are needed to lynch.
Day 2 ends in (expired on 2018-01-04 18:44:45).

[JunkoChan]

I think I'm about here, assuming no one counterclaims Mason:
{3Mason}
{Impede, JunkoChan, RedFlavor}
{HeWhoSwims, wavemode}
{acidphoenix, talon}

This was the last read list GL left before dying, we can at least work from there since now there's no way to know why he read HeWhoswims as more likely mafia, tbh it would make sense for HWS to be mafia since GL died, killing the only one who had him as a scumread seems like the right thing to do.

If we go with this train of thought then HWS pushing so hard a lynch on talon probably makes him town, unless he went for a bus kill since talon is barely playing at all.

on the other hand what the f why is the doctor not dead? unless someone is gamethrowing 3 masons is still 100% town.

I think we should all Hypo cop/track claim today and only if the real cop/track has a guilty/investigation on someone they hardclaim cuz we still have the doc to get another read.

In worst case scenario if real cop outs with the guilty and we lynch the vanilla mafia instead of the roleblocker we at least have 1 more conftown for next day.

My hypo claims are Wavemode guilty and GuiltyLion visited no one.

[JunkoChan]

I just realized worst case scenario is even worse than I thought fk. But it still leaves us with a conftown at least

[Impede]

Agree with the hypo claim I think. Not really sure how it’s executed though. I’m super intrigued that 3M is alive still. Very odd.

[Impede]

Unless scum are trying to frame me since I made a big deal about him being for sure dead. Or maybe they don’t realize Doc can’t protect himself.

[JunkoChan]

Agree with the hypo claim I think..

You give a report as if you were cop and tracker so in case you die we can still work with that next day

[JunkoChan]

I think it's obvious but I meant in case real cop dies

[Impede]

Do I claim one or the other specifically?

[JunkoChan]

Claim both

[JunkoChan]

My hypo claims are Wavemode guilty and GuiltyLion visited no one.

Like this

[JunkoChan]

fucked up the quote format but you get the idea

[Impede]

Cop: RedFlavor - Town
Tracker: GuiltyLion - No target

[RedFlavor]

Junko ns

Impede no one

[3 Masons in a Trenchcoat]

I think I'm about here, assuming no one counterclaims Mason:
{3Mason}
{Impede, JunkoChan, RedFlavor}
{HeWhoSwims, wavemode}
{acidphoenix, talon}

This was the last read list GL left before dying, we can at least work from there since now there's no way to know why he read HeWhoswims as more likely mafia, tbh it would make sense for HWS to be mafia since GL died, killing the only one who had him as a scumread seems like the right thing to do.

If we go with this train of thought then HWS pushing so hard a lynch on talon probably makes him town, unless he went for a bus kill since talon is barely playing at all.

on the other hand what the f why is the doctor not dead? unless someone is gamethrowing 3 masons is still 100% town.

I think we should all Hypo cop/track claim today and only if the real cop/track has a guilty/investigation on someone they hardclaim cuz we still have the doc to get another read.

In worst case scenario if real cop outs with the guilty and we lynch the vanilla mafia instead of the roleblocker we at least have 1 more conftown for next day.

My hypo claims are Wavemode guilty and GuiltyLion visited no one.

Agree with the hypo claim I think. Not really sure how it’s executed though. I’m super intrigued that 3M is alive still. Very odd.

I can think of one situation that keeps me alive. The mafia has a roleblocker. If they do, then it makes more sense to roleblock me until random selection lets them kill the cop. Then they can kill me no problem and kill the rest of the town.

Funny thing is, I tried to save GuiltyLion. I thought that they might attack him because he was one of the people who was slamming me before I claimed. I thought they would try to make it seem like I fake-claimed. It was stupid logic, but my intuition picked the right person. Yet he still died.

So I'm a vanilla townie until we lynch the Roleblocker. But now we know something important: There is a cop, and that cop should NOT hard claim. We also know that there's a roleblocker.

Intuition told me that there's a roleblocker in this game, but I didn't have any evidence. That's why I was so skitzy about the BP claim. I knew there was no BP, and that it was being asked for by a mafia roleblocker who was trying to see what the setup was.

Just as a reminder, that was RedFlavor, who requested it in post 29 and had a grudge in the beginning against Guilty starting at 39. And guilty ended up dead.

My evidence is circumstantial, but I'm gonna iso Red and try to get a read. I'll get back to everyone tomorrow. For now...

VOTE: RedFlavor

[JunkoChan]

I think I'm about here, assuming no one counterclaims Mason:
{3Mason}
{Impede, JunkoChan, RedFlavor}
{HeWhoSwims, wavemode}
{acidphoenix, talon}

This was the last read list GL left before dying, we can at least work from there since now there's no way to know why he read HeWhoswims as more likely mafia, tbh it would make sense for HWS to be mafia since GL died, killing the only one who had him as a scumread seems like the right thing to do.

If we go with this train of thought then HWS pushing so hard a lynch on talon probably makes him town, unless he went for a bus kill since talon is barely playing at all.

on the other hand what the f why is the doctor not dead? unless someone is gamethrowing 3 masons is still 100% town.

I think we should all Hypo cop/track claim today and only if the real cop/track has a guilty/investigation on someone they hardclaim cuz we still have the doc to get another read.

In worst case scenario if real cop outs with the guilty and we lynch the vanilla mafia instead of the roleblocker we at least have 1 more conftown for next day.

My hypo claims are Wavemode guilty and GuiltyLion visited no one.

Agree with the hypo claim I think. Not really sure how it’s executed though. I’m super intrigued that 3M is alive still. Very odd.

I can think of one situation that keeps me alive. The mafia has a roleblocker. If they do, then it makes more sense to roleblock me until random selection lets them kill the cop. Then they can kill me no problem and kill the rest of the town.

Funny thing is, I tried to save GuiltyLion. I thought that they might attack him because he was one of the people who was slamming me before I claimed. I thought they would try to make it seem like I fake-claimed. It was stupid logic, but my intuition picked the right person. Yet he still died.

So I'm a vanilla townie until we lynch the Roleblocker. But now we know something important: There is a cop, and that cop should NOT hard claim. We also know that there's a roleblocker.

Intuition told me that there's a roleblocker in this game, but I didn't have any evidence. That's why I was so skitzy about the BP claim. I knew there was no BP, and that it was being asked for by a mafia roleblocker who was trying to see what the setup was.

Just as a reminder, that was RedFlavor, who requested it in post 29 and had a grudge in the beginning against Guilty starting at 39. And guilty ended up dead.

My evidence is circumstantial, but I'm gonna iso Red and try to get a read. I'll get back to everyone tomorrow. For now...

VOTE: RedFlavor

This is super important, it also means that cop has at least 1 report, so yeah, everyone hypo cop please.

[JunkoChan]

Junko ns

Impede no one

What do you mean by ns?

[Impede]

Wow. That’s gamechanging. So now we know what our setup is which puts us on an even playing field with scum.

I agree you should look at Red more closely. Although I don’t think the BP claim is AI at all. I still have a slight townlean on Red tbh.

[JunkoChan]

3 masons, Impede

town

Talon152

null town

HeWhoSwims

wildcard

RedFlavor Wavemode

Scum lean

I thinnk I'm sitting on this reads for a bit

[talon152]

Cop: Impede town

[RedFlavor]

Ns means inno

3 masons, Impede

town

Talon152

null town

HeWhoSwims

wildcard

RedFlavor Wavemode

Scum lean

I thinnk I'm sitting on this reads for a bit

Why impede is town

[nancy]

♥