Micro 759: Tarot uPick III - Game Over!

[nancy]

I've been adventurous the whole game with next to no company I'm bored of it -_-

It's pretty much just that you don't seem interesting in pushing/solving the game? Like your read on Dunker is pretty hedgy + your reasoning there was weakened by his most recent posting but he's still your top scumread with the reasoning now being that you think you stopped the kill + he has a wagon and you're still not voting him, think all that is a little weird considered together. There's some smaller things like the way you distanced yourself from acid's behavior unprompted and asked a question in 1310 that serves you no purpose if you're town but looks like you trying to lay cover for having the vote if you're mafia, which would more or less line up with you being self-conscious about it / not voting if you're trying to avoid attention in that regard.

Also, uh, haven't had the chance to see you interact or react to stuff so your slot is full of question marks.

[nancy]

I mean there's also acid's entrance today but that's not really something you can respond to.

[Yetichain]

I have a couple of things.

If garaputo is scum, there is

no explanation

for the no kill apart from acid not submitting a kill, which is very unlikely. It wouldn't have been my doing. Which nancy already knows.
So unless someone has another possible reason for the no kill, I'm strongly against his lynch today.


Secondly

dunk, could you say what you were talking about in 494?

not without claiming

also i'm vt

jabarkus and nk15 both said this game was role madness which means they obviously had pr roles and i thought them thinking it was role madness made them them more likely to be mafia

1300 is just a lie? He claimed VT and his reason for thinking that was not role related at all, I don't know why he'd cover like that.

Vote: Dunkerdoodles

Jail Yetichain tonight the slot is wolfy as fuck.

I'm 100% on board with jailing me if we don't lynch scum today, it's not worth it to scum to no kill again to guilty me instead of taking a better shot, so there'll probably be a kill and I will be as clear as I can get.

nancy please

anybody that sheeps this is basically scumclaiming

This response to the vote is pretty rubbish though :/ why's it a scumclaim?

Here's a novel idea.

Everyone in the game posts a readslist.

And if they're feeling adventurous... a line of reasoning!

Town:
nancy, garaputo, Not Known 15

Confused feelings:
Porkens, drealmerz7

Scum:
Dunkerdoodles, northsidegal


-Key

Also Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays!

[Dunkerdoodles]

VOTE: yetichain
i like this actually

[Dunkerdoodles]

oh read list
um

me nancy porkens
everyone else

[nancy]

If garaputo is scum, there is no explanation for the no kill apart from acid not submitting a kill, which is very unlikely. It wouldn't have been my doing. Which nancy already knows.
So unless someone has another possible reason for the no kill, I'm strongly against his lynch today.

???

????????

????????????

????

??????

??

[nancy]

the Dunkers JK is not the only possible reason for the no kill.

[nancy]

Dunkerdoodles is too cute. I can't lynch him.

[nancy]

Like, if there's no other explanation for the lack of a kill then Dunker is confirmed scum. You keep saying there is another explanation. And if there is another explanation then why do you have NK15 and garaputo as townreads? But now you're saying there's not another explanation??????

[northsidegal]

i thought that you already knew that her other explanation was the hider thing, right?

[nancy]

I have no idea what she's saying anymore, she's contradicted herself here and in hood so it's difficult to make sense of what she thinks.

[Yetichain]

Like, if there's no other explanation for the lack of a kill then Dunker is confirmed scum. You keep saying there is another explanation. And if there is another explanation then why do you have NK15 and garaputo as townreads? But now you're saying there's not another explanation??????

what.



Calm your farm and think it through.

I told you that if

acid

was scum that I didn't know what caused the no kill because it wouldn't have been me. Don't generalise beyond that point.

I thought I'd given you the information you needed (JK was not necessarily the cause of the no kill because it might have been me, if acid/garaputo is scum I didn't cause the no kill so it must have been something else) but clearly it's just causing more harm than good. I'm happy to claim if it will clear things up.

I have garaputo as a townread because if I caused the no kill, he is not scum, and if he caused the no kill, he is not scum. If we are the only two who could have caused the no kill which seems apparent so far, then my conclusion is that he is not scum.

I have NK15 as a townread because I townread them and their roleclaim.

VOTE: yetichain
i like this actually

Yes okay... so why did you say in 1300 you couldn't explain 494 without claiming when you clearly could?


-Key

[Dunkerdoodles]

VOTE: yetichain
i like this actually

Yes okay... so why did you say in 1300 you couldn't explain 494 without claiming when you clearly could?


-Key

um ???
if i say that the game isn't role madness that obviously makes me vt no?

[nancy]

Okay wonderful you make sense now.

Vote: Dunkerpoodles

[Dunkerdoodles]

wait yeti
are you claiming u caused the no kill or not?

[fferyllt]

Vote Count 2-6

Dunkerdoodles

(4): northsidegal, Not Known 15, nancy, Woman of Crystals

garaputo

(2): drealmerz7, Porkens

Yetichain

(1): Dunkerdoodles

northsidegal

(1): Yetichain

Not Voting

(1): garaputo

With 8 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: January 3, Midnight US Eastern Time.

Countdown: (expired on 2018-01-02 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

-

[nancy]

WHAT

[nancy]

Vote: northsidegal

[Dunkerdoodles]

help

i think woman of crystals is just gara's secret doublevote

[garaputo]

I've been adventurous the whole game with next to no company I'm bored of it -_-

It's pretty much just that you don't seem interesting in pushing/solving the game? Like your read on Dunker is pretty hedgy + your reasoning there was weakened by his most recent posting but he's still your top scumread with the reasoning now being that you think you stopped the kill + he has a wagon and you're still not voting him, think all that is a little weird considered together. There's some smaller things like the way you distanced yourself from acid's behavior unprompted and asked a question in 1310 that serves you no purpose if you're town but looks like you trying to lay cover for having the vote if you're mafia, which would more or less line up with you being self-conscious about it / not voting if you're trying to avoid attention in that regard.

Also, uh, haven't had the chance to see you interact or react to stuff so your slot is full of question marks.

Yes, I'm not sure on my read on dunker, but I am still more certain on dunker than anyone else. I agree dunker having a reason why, as vt, his position changed between 439 and 494 impacted my read from 1302 and 1308, but we actually discussed this. As I said in 1326 I'm prepared to accept the explanation given, but that shift was not the sole basis for my read. I think my 1306 and subsequent posts show that a major thought process (other than the WIFOM arguments I see from dunker, which in themselves are enough to worry) is trying to explain the lack of a kill. I think more likely than not it's because Dunkers is scum, rather than the target last night.

[garaputo]

help

i think woman of crystals is just gara's secret doublevote

This thought is based on bad assumptions.

It is true that I have 2 votes available but I can place them only on the same person simultaneously, in public posts.

[Dunkerdoodles]

so then who is woman of crystals?

[nancy]

This reminds me of that time I played in a game with Jesus and he randomly voted people and I got modkilled because I forgot to swear at the mod.

[garaputo]

so then who is woman of crystals?

I haven't the foggiest idea.

[garaputo]

This reminds me of that time I played in a game with Jesus and he randomly voted people and I got modkilled because I forgot to swear at the mod.

I remember this one game I had a post restriction that I couldn't use the letter "e" in my posts.

Modkilled