Mini Normal 1976 - The Firsts - Night 2[End Jan 8]

[profii]

I’ve had an idea. If we are going to lose a PR when DH kills Mulch, I’ll make a different policy vote

VOTE: no lynch

Ner!

[Apple Jack]

if disagreeing with a vote isn’t a reason to scumrrad someone what the fuck IS

Lots of things but Disagreeing with somebody is never a good reason to scum read somebody. If I wasn’t so lazy I’d bet I can find multiple examples where you disagreed with somebody who was town.

[Apple Jack]

Profi doesn’t want to find scum. He’s basically scum claimed.

[profii]

Profi doesn’t want to find scum. He’s basically scum claimed.

Yes, exactly, by not wanting to lynch the PR claims, I am scum claiming

Logical fallacies, certainly not scummy at all there buddy

[Apple Jack]

So clearly the alternative to lynching Pr claims is not lynching anyone...

Lynching your scum reads isn’t an option for you for some reason.

[profii]

What if I think one of you and Mulch are likely scum but I’m fairly confident we won’t get a majority vote on either

[TwoInAMillion]

profi's assumption of Mulch as town, and Mulch's quick vote of Jodax after profi was voted makes me think they could be a scumteam.

Called it already.

[profii]

VOTE: twoinamillion

Go review the last few pages and come back and tell me what’s changed since that quote and I’ll move my vote

[Apple Jack]

What if I think one of you and Mulch are likely scum but I’m fairly confident we won’t get a majority vote on either

There is probably 2 other scum.

[profii]

Derpy - if we lynch Mulch today, who do you shoot?
Presumably if you don’t shoot and don’t get killed, do you think you’d get lynched tomorrow? I’d be really tempted as it currently stands

[TwoInAMillion]

With only 11 players I highly doubt there are 4 scum. 3 is pushing it.

[profii]

I think he is saying one of him and mulch are scum + 2 = 3 total


Someone help me out because I’m new on this site. Will the vig and mafia kills be announced as “player X was shot” ie we won’t actually know which kill was the scum or vig

I can see a scenario where DH is scum and they already plan to kill Mulch... DH doesn’t die and palms it off as maybe a Dr or scum wanted mulch dead too (whatever)
We then go mad at DH for killing a PR so his scum mates bus him for town points

Feasible or no?

[TwoInAMillion]

Someone help me out because I’m new on this site. Will the vig and mafia kills be announced as “player X was shot” ie we won’t actually know which kill was the scum or vig

didn't he claim day vig? I could be mistaken. A day vig would obviously be posted seperately while a night vig you wouldn't be made aware of which was which, although some mods may make hints with the day flip flavor.

[Sky_Paladin]

Well hmm i am out of town for the morning but I expect to make a catch up post in around 12 hours.
Main thoughts from skimming:
Mulch claim instead of diverting DH by actively scum hunting is interesting. Not convinced claim is legit.
I am more inclined to believe DH claim simply by virtue of it not being repealed when monkey was replaced. I sincerely thought Ash was fakeclaiming to force a “win” in the argument they were having with monkey. Note there are any number of things people can do to screw with eh regardless of alignment so this claim itself is not AI or a guaranteed town claim as scum can also have 1 shot gig.
I am concerned that DH is taking up a lot of the towns focus and diverting away from scum hunting except for their chosen few.

I feel like I should do something about this.

[Sky_Paladin]

Sigh no
Ash = DH
This is why I don’t post on my iPhone while away x_x

[Apple Jack]

Derpy - if we lynch Mulch today, who do you shoot?
Presumably if you don’t shoot and don’t get killed, do you think you’d get lynched tomorrow? I’d be really tempted as it currently stands

You or psycho probably

No I don’t think I’ll get lynched if I survive the night but I guess it’s possible.

[Apple Jack]

Someone help me out because I’m new on this site. Will the vig and mafia kills be announced as “player X was shot” ie we won’t actually know which kill was the scum or vig

didn't he claim day vig? I could be mistaken. A day vig would obviously be posted seperately while a night vig you wouldn't be made aware of which was which, although some mods may make hints with the day flip flavor.

No didn’t claim day vig

[Sky_Paladin]

@Derpy or any interested party
Hypothetically let’s say your claim is legit!town and you shoot mulch without interference and mulch flips town.
Who are your scum picks in that world? Why?
@Mulch you have linked some posts and said that you have scum hunted. Imo town should be able to gurp our theirnreads immediately and I strongly dislike anytime people say “I already did this” instead of “sure, my reads are xyz”.
For instance I have derp/mulch in my scum list because this interaction between the two of you looks entirely fabricated, aside from the force replace of monkey, which to me would not have happened if you were scum buddies together. So I’m wrong I’m at least one count.
Outside of that I feel monkeys initial comments re 2mil are on the mark and I’m considering switching to 2mil.

So who are your scum picks and why? And don’t give me “who do you want me to explain?” I want YOU to tell me who YOU ATHIJK IS SCUM AND WHY.

[Sky_Paladin]

Sigh seriously I’m about to give up in this phone
That all caps was supposed to be “WHO DO YOU THINK IS SCUM AND WHY” except also not in all caps.

[BuJaber]

We are not lynching mulch unless we get a counterclaim. Anynody voting mulch from now on is scum in my book.

2inam and psyko definitely one of them is scum and since psyko scumreads me my past games tell me he's more likely town. (I'm scumread by town a lot in the early game)

I don't know what to think about profii.. his wallpost from before made me move away from him but suggesting no lynch and then asking questions about the vig kill doesn't make me feel confident about townreading him.

Monkey was force replaced so sadly we cannot learn anything from that. Don't jump to conclusions.

DH and mulch I told you to stop talking to each other this is pulling focus away from everyone else and scum are taking advantage.

There is absolutely no way this many townies can be okay with a claumed cop getting lynched/shot. We have scum here and they're outing themselves.

Jodax still lurking?

[BuJaber]

I meant to UNVOTE: VOTE: twoinamillion

[TwoInAMillion]

I never said I want to lynch mulch. I said I don't believe his claim. And asking for counterclaims is just as bad as rolefishing. Where in the mafia handbook does it say any power role claim gets a free ride?

[Mulch]

I do agree with the fact that probably one of the people encouraging Derpy to shooot me is scum

[TwoInAMillion]

I want him to follow his gut rather than be told what to do and not be accountable.

[Mulch]

I want him to follow his gut rather than be told what to do and not be accountable.

Is this a scumclaim? His "gut" is to kill

the cop


and your telling him to follow

his gut