Uh Harry potterIn post 13, Schism wrote:RQS:
1. Whats a good Story you have read/watched/played?
2. If you had a superpower, what would it be?
3. What is your favorite mafia PR and why?
It says in op it would be randomised among valid setups. All three could have been fine.In post 10, Hopkirk wrote:I got exactly one non-town option in my nine cards and I discarded it.
I would have been a commuter if we'd gone with setup A.
Being in setup B suggests a lot of people here have preferences for scum roles. I feel like revealing choices for that setup is a good idea, especially who picked scum in the first game.
Isn't cop lover objectively better?
VOTE: TheNewEarth
what difference does it make?In post 19, DiamondSentinel wrote:My bad. Scratch Espeonage. I was still in GI mode, not GestI.
why did you repeat what i already said?In post 26, Espeonage wrote: It says in op it would be randomised among valid setups. All three could have been fine.
Because cupid is a very strong scum role, but horrible town role. In GestI, you only get the role or the alignment, not both. GI you get both. As-is, it's NAI.In post 29, northsidegal wrote:what difference does it make?In post 19, DiamondSentinel wrote:My bad. Scratch Espeonage. I was still in GI mode, not GestI.
why did you repeat what i already said?In post 26, Espeonage wrote: It says in op it would be randomised among valid setups. All three could have been fine.
Seer?In post 28, Espeonage wrote:vote holy spirit turtle
And I want to know why you discarded one of the strongest town power roles.
No. I have very vocally said I pick whatever is the strongest chance for me to win.In post 33, Schism wrote:Espeonage, I can assume you perfer a town role, no?
But are you aIn post 16, thenewearth wrote:I am a bad lover
Why isIn post 18, DiamondSentinel wrote:Anyways, Espeonage, newearth, and wilky have scummy AF discards.
Fite meIn post 24, thenewearth wrote:No one vote schism ples
My setup A choice was a serial killer. Does that count?In post 25, Espeonage wrote:Actually important point sk is town this game I am psychiatrist. If you are sk you should claim.
I don't know your definition of "strongest," for the only thing that's strongest that I have is my avatar.In post 28, Espeonage wrote:And I want to know why you discarded one of the strongest town power roles.
Very, assuming town picked it.In post 37, Schism wrote:And Psychiatrist is optimal vs a Mafia Cupid?
funny, i was just reading back through that! but no, my vote is because of this:In post 40, HolySpiritTurtle wrote:You really must've hated that votefuckery game.
diamondsentinal quite clearly took back the comment about espeon's discard being scummy in hisHolySpiritTurtle wrote:Why isIn post 18, DiamondSentinel wrote:Anyways, Espeonage, newearth, and wilky have scummy AF discards.MAFIACupid discard a scummy discard?
Wholeheartedly agree. I was just about to say the same thing.In post 41, northsidegal wrote:funny, i was just reading back through that! but no, my vote is because of this:In post 40, HolySpiritTurtle wrote:You really must've hated that votefuckery game.
diamondsentinal quite clearly took back the comment about espeon's discard being scummy in hisHolySpiritTurtle wrote:Why isIn post 18, DiamondSentinel wrote:Anyways, Espeonage, newearth, and wilky have scummy AF discards.MAFIACupid discard a scummy discard?very nextpost. given that you obviously took the time to check what espeon's discard was and also responded to posts later on in the thread, i can only assume that you noticed this and yet still chose to keep it in your post. i don't see why you would do that except to try to look town / to look busy.
Thats not the question. The question is why is Psyche a better pick for a pr instead of Mafia Cupid if Espe doesnt have an alignment preference.In post 45, HolySpiritTurtle wrote:Uh
VT is still TOWN, ya know.
Increasing number of town member is huge.
to be a scum cupid his third card choice (assuming he's telling the truth about being psychiatrist) would also have to have been scum. if he got two town cards and mafia cupid as the third, it makes sense as a discard.In post 48, Schism wrote:Thats not the question. The question is why is Psyche a better pick for a pr instead of Mafia Cupid if Espe doesnt have an alignment preference.
no, not usually. i voted wisdom because i thought vanilla townie was the scummiest discard – not sure why i didn't just say that.@NSG: do you normally naked vote in RVS? Curious on if you had a reason to vote wisdom.