Newbie 1845 - A New Dawn Game Over

[Sunset at dawn]

I guess I'll vote sheep. It seems kind of weird to want so many votes on red.

Vote: Sheep

[Sunset at dawn]

I dont think sheep was serious about vote

I said "I am red in this game" and red means scum so that was the scumclaim


Preedit: yes I also found that weird

VOTE: sunset at dawn

Oh. I thought that sheep meant RedFlavor not the scum

Unvote- sheep

I don't know who else seems off yet.

[Sunset at dawn]

All right. Since you seem so suspicious of me, all I can say is that I didn't want to seem overconfident and make a mistake.
I didn't post anything yesterday because I wasn't quite sure what to say.
Now that I have a little more information and I've looked over everything again, this is what I have.
Sheepsaysmeep is bouncing around a lot and seems very aggressive, especially towards Avi. Pretty suspicious, but seems almost too obvious to me.

Aviqvf pointed out that RedFlavor was at L-1, but didn't take his vote off of Red, but that could have just been to put extra pressure on him.

SaulJoker hasn't really said anything that makes me think one side or another

Creature hasn't said much either

Inferno390 jokingly voted himself and was pretty freaked out when RedFlavor was at L-1 so soon. He's done some analysis and seems pretty safe to me, unless- and I may be stretching here- he and Red are scum and that's why he freaked.

Lil Uzi Vert joined the game late but had a good excuse and doesn't seem suspicious.

Sunlit Diamond has been generally helpful and hasn't said anything weird. He seems town to me.

RedFlavor was almost lynched right at the beginning but didn't seem fazed. On the other hand, one of the votes was for his, so this could have been a way to gain our trust without much real risk.

[Sunset at dawn]

I didn't want to seem overconfident and make a mistake.

What do you mean by 'make a mistake'? Town generally should not need to worry about making mistakes.

What I mean is that I don't want to do something stupid like getting a power role lynched day one. That counts as a mistake.

[Sunset at dawn]

I know this was a while ago, but every time I think about RedFlavor's self-vote, it makes me more suspicious.
Like I said earlier, when he was at L-1, one of the votes was his own. If he had felt like he was in danger, he could have unvoted himself or changed his vote to keep himself safe. That means it would be much easier to stay calm and not make a mistake.
I may be reaching a bit, but if you're town, why vote for the one person you know is innocent?

[Sunset at dawn]

If he had felt like he was in danger, he could have unvoted himself or changed his vote to keep himself safe. That means it would be much easier to stay calm and not make a mistake.

do you think that this is what a player would think at l-1 having self voted regardless of their alignment?

I think that scum might be a bit more likely to think that way, but as I said, I'm probably reaching. This was just an idea that I didn't want to dismiss entirely.

[Sunset at dawn]

luv is at prod btw

pedit like do you have actual reads

I read you and creature as town

Sheep and Creature as town? That's new. Care to explain?

[Sunset at dawn]

I have to agree here. Most of what sheep says seems unnecessary, but on the other hand I don't really think he's scum anymore.
VOTE: Vote: RedFlavor
I still don't quite trust Red though.

[Sunset at dawn]

Sorry about that. I didn't notice.

[Sunset at dawn]

Aviqvf and Lil Uzi Vert still don't make me suspicious.
Sheep is posting as much as always and saying as little as always but I still don't really think he's scum.
Creature still seems to be avoiding saying anything
Sunlit Diamond is still relatively helpful
Red's posts seem kind of- fluffy, I guess? I just feel like there's something off.
SaulJoker hasn't said anything in a long time, he's been especially quiet since everyone started voting for him a while ago
All in all, not much has changed.

[Sunset at dawn]

I know that. I'm stating what I know and hoping something comes of it. I'm not certain of anything and this is what I have right now.

[Sunset at dawn]

How much mafia experience do you have, Sunset?

None. This is my first game.

[Sunset at dawn]

Aviqvf and Lil Uzi Vert still don't make me suspicious.
Sheep is posting as much as always and saying as little as always but I still don't really think he's scum.
Creature still seems to be avoiding saying anything
Sunlit Diamond is still relatively helpful
Red's posts seem kind of- fluffy, I guess? I just feel like there's something off.
SaulJoker hasn't said anything in a long time, he's been especially quiet since everyone started voting for him a while ago
All in all, not much has changed.

Also you said "Red's posts seem kind of - fluffy, I guess? I just feel like there's something off." but you did not point any post or something, but you were still voting me.

He also had no comment on Saul not posting after he got some votes.
Sunset, what do you think about saul's silence?

Saul has been suspiciously quiet and I'm starting to understand why most people are finding him suspicious. Even when he did post, it wasn't anything useful. I'll see what he has to say but I am considering changing my vote.