Anything uPick? (Endgame)

[ObsessedFanGrill]

@mastina

- Read up to this point and talk to me about Gamma please <3

[ObsessedFanGrill]

Chesskid Conf assuming the blue colored name is related to role and not pick.
Smocaine
Maybe you.
Fire eh could be town.
Maki TR's Yume I think that's a self-resolving slot.

[Nosferatu]

Oh, so first you insult me and when I call you out on it, you ignore me. Real mature, Fire, real mature.

Convince Firebringer to stop jabbing at me and you've got yourself a deal.

Idk the beef between you two but how does one ignore you and make jabs at the same time lol

HEY WHATS UP
COULDN'T PLAY TILL VOTED

Bullshit

i doubt that ginngie's post restriction was faked but it seems slightly convenient that it got lifted so early.

what does that even mean

[Mathdino]

Just to be clear, NSG is trying to prove to me she's playing her scumgame, right?

@NSG:

I wasn't comparing this to your other Newbie towngame, I'm comparing it to what I remember of Marked For Death. Original/interesting thoughts are thus far what I expect from town-you. Your first two posts aren't the centerpiece of this read.

If you REALLY want me to reevaluate the read in depth I can go ahead and ISO you and actually go and directly compare. Initial progression of thought was:
- oh shit is NSG avoiding lengthy early posts to hide her obvscumgame
- NSG's questions are okay I guess but nothing special
- oh shit 138 is #goodposting.

Town NSG tries to nullify scumtells. Scum NSG tries to nullify towntells. That's my understanding so far but if you feel like that's inaccurate I'll go and remetadive you.

[northsidegal]

i doubt that ginngie's post restriction was faked but it seems slightly convenient that it got lifted so early.

what does that even mean

it doesn't seem like the post restriction itself was faked but something seems off about how it got lifted so early. like i already said, mastina's reasons for voting there seem slightly contrived within the context of voting ginngie being the way to get her in the game.

Just to be clear, NSG is trying to prove to me she's playing her scumgame, right?

no, i'm just suspicious of your townread on me.
i figured it was me.

[Firebringer]

VOTE: northsidegal

[Nosferatu]

it doesn't seem like the post restriction itself was faked but something seems off about how it got lifted so early. like i already said, mastina's reasons for voting there seem slightly contrived within the context of voting ginngie being the way to get her in the game.

you implying that she knew he needed to be voted and made up a reason to?

[Gamma Emerald]

I mean mastina and Ginngie are close so it makes sense she'd think something was up with Ginngie not posting

[ObsessedFanGrill]

i figured it was me.

Why?

pedit: fire can be town I guess.

[Firebringer]

i figured it was me.

Why?

pedit: fire can be town I guess.

No, I am scum. Fight me

[Mathdino]

Dino try hardness is funny when you combine it with bad read on gamma

Convince me the read is wrong. From my perspective I have scum motivation, meta, his shit votes/reads, and gut/tonereads on my side.

Where is scum motivation because you didn’t mention that once in your vote on gamma.
Give me meta game you have because this is basically town gamma
His shit votes and reads are again Town gamma

Marked For Death 8p Micro.

WhemePlay would've been a viable wagon and an easy one to jump onto because Wheme was admittedly being pretty whack.

54 has him tunnel after the player in question, rather than defend his tunnel to everyone else. Dramatic, waste of time.

Paranoia generation in 142 is good. Most townblocs (or blocs in general) are brought down by outside paranoia moreso than scum infiltration.

172 calls rolefishing anti-town, doesn't explain why it's scum. Helps with discrediting/pushing suspicion without being the one accountable.

The Gamma that I know is a lone voice pushing/casing his reads on others in a way that makes him directly responsible for all of them. The above is just lazy. Ironic given that he has more time.

[northsidegal]

it doesn't seem like the post restriction itself was faked but something seems off about how it got lifted so early. like i already said, mastina's reasons for voting there seem slightly contrived within the context of voting ginngie being the way to get her in the game.

you implying that she knew he needed to be voted and made up a reason to?

yes, that's exactly what i'm implying.

i figured it was me.

Why?

pedit: fire can be town I guess.

well, like i said – i would've scumread me based off of my first few posts. it was really down to only a pool of three people: myself, nosferatu and chickadee, and it just seemed like it was me out of those three. you scumread me at the start of that one game we played together, too, assuming that i'm correct in who you are.

I mean mastina and Ginngie are close so it makes sense she'd think something was up with Ginngie not posting

sure, i could definitely believe that – it's not like i'm calling the scumteam right now. it's just something that gives me pause.

[Firebringer]

i doubt that ginngie's post restriction was faked but

it seems slightly convenient that it got lifted so early.

ur actually a wolf this time feelsbadman

do you disagree? at that point in the game a good portion of the playerlist was still yet to have much of an impact on the thread, if at all. mastina specifically making the note of scum being in the inactives and then choosing ginngie along with ginngie's pr being lifted upon being voted seems oddly specific to me.

OFG have you ever played with NSG before?

@NSG

: mastina and Ginngie are pretty good friends, I think. Seems natural. The massive number of townreads is concerning but also happened the last time I played with her IIRC (admittedly years ago. Do you think scum lovederizer rolecop would ever be a thing?

there's nothing to suggest mastina is telling the truth about anything, yet.

This post is really scummy for trying to suggest mastina is telling a lot of lies.

[ObsessedFanGrill]

well, like i said – i would've scumread me based off of my first few posts. it was really down to only a pool of three people: myself, nosferatu and chickadee, and it just seemed like it was me out of those three. you scumread me at the start of that one game we played together, too, assuming that i'm correct in who you are.

Who we are is right in our signature lmfao.

[northsidegal]

well, like i said – i would've scumread me based off of my first few posts. it was really down to only a pool of three people: myself, nosferatu and chickadee, and it just seemed like it was me out of those three. you scumread me at the start of that one game we played together, too, assuming that i'm correct in who you are. i would've scumread me based off of my first few posts. it was really down to only a pool of three people: myself, nosferatu and chickadee, and it just seemed like it was me out of those three. you scumread me at the start of that one game we played together, too, assuming that i'm correct in who you are.

oh, i thought this was that other person whose name i can't remember talking to me, not ofg. the last part is directed at them.

[Nosferatu]

yes, that's exactly what i'm implying.

why wouldn't she just rvs vote him?

ginngie doesn't need a post restriction to be townread

[northsidegal]

yes well if you would all type a little slower i could've posted that beforehand!

[northsidegal]

This post is really scummy for trying to suggest mastina is telling a lot of lies.

i'm not saying mastina is telling a lot of lies – i'm suggesting that there's nothing to suggest that she's telling the truth, yet. i hate role madness games, so in terms of scumhunting i'm trying to treat this like a normal game.

yes, that's exactly what i'm implying.

why wouldn't she just rvs vote him?

ginngie doesn't need a post restriction to be townread

that's true, and something i hadn't considered. in that case the convenience wouldn't even need an explanation because the post restriction would likely never be brought up in the first place.

assuming that ginngie is telling the truth about the post restriction, does that tell us that it's likely that she's town, given that she wasn't voted in rvs?

[Firebringer]

i'm not saying mastina is telling a lot of lies – i'm suggesting that there's nothing to suggest that she's telling the truth, yet. i hate role madness games, so in terms of scumhunting i'm trying to treat this like a normal game.

How is that different?
You telling us to be skeptical is to put in our minds that there’s chance none of it’s true which would be a lie.

And I see no reason to tell people to be skeptical about claims like that unless you either A) pretty sure it’s horseshit or B) scum trying to keep options open

[Nosferatu]

yes, that's exactly what i'm implying.

why wouldn't she just rvs vote him?

ginngie doesn't need a post restriction to be townread

that's true, and something i hadn't considered. in that case the convenience wouldn't even need an explanation because the post restriction would likely never be brought up in the first place.

assuming that ginngie is telling the truth about the post restriction, does that tell us that it's likely that she's town, given that she wasn't voted in rvs?

Playing devil's advocate with myself, it's possible that if mastina voted ginngie straight out of the gate and later on he got vigged, and we see a post restriction that we had never seen, we'd deduce that the first person to vote them was also scum.

At the same time I would think that they would milk it harder...

[WhemePlay]

i figured it was me.

VOTE: Northsidegal

[Mathdino]

Someone please write up actual reasons NSG is scum. I'm not seeing it.

[Firebringer]

Scum NSG tries to nullify towntells.

[Ginngie]

Scum NSG tries to nullify towntells.

i see what you did there

[Ginngie]

To sheep or not to sheep cuz I dont wanna read