In post 209, eth0s wrote:Defending not_maf at all in this game seems like a viable jester strat lmao
I'll grant this. I like to whiteknight as scum and I really did think he was town so as jester I would have been much more passively defending him, probably by just calling people dumb and repeating that he was town rather than addressing their actual arguments. (Conversely, I would NEVER defend him after that wagon as his partner because I saw such a low chance of people actually listening to me.)
However. I think the rest of the day should prove that I'm not jester. I can easily point to a half dozen things I would have done differently.
I say this because I should probably not live to LYLO, and if I'm not going to I should be lynched today or tomorrow. And before you go OMG jester play!!!1! remember that I'd have to have somehow CORRECTLY and confidently read Not_Mafia, despite your implications that he's difficult or impossible to read.
Hmmmmmmmmm... defending yourself against a jester accusation? I think we should lynch Something Smart on Day 4.
I honestly have no idea what the fuck to do. Like, it's nightless, so we can just lynch all my suspects in a row, but I also have no reason to and no clue how to argue why we should lynch one first over another.
Like, we all agree we should be lynching non-jesters first and we're likely to hit scum. Now what?
Where are the votes at?
"I just want to play mafia, not Economics Wonderland." - cytheflyguy
In post 209, eth0s wrote:Defending not_maf at all in this game seems like a viable jester strat lmao
I'll grant this. I like to whiteknight as scum and I really did think he was town so as jester I would have been much more passively defending him, probably by just calling people dumb and repeating that he was town rather than addressing their actual arguments. (Conversely, I would NEVER defend him after that wagon as his partner because I saw such a low chance of people actually listening to me.)
However. I think the rest of the day should prove that I'm not jester. I can easily point to a half dozen things I would have done differently.
I say this because I should probably not live to LYLO, and if I'm not going to I should be lynched today or tomorrow. And before you go OMG jester play!!!1! remember that I'd have to have somehow CORRECTLY and confidently read Not_Mafia, despite your implications that he's difficult or impossible to read.
Hmmmmmmmmm... defending yourself against a jester accusation? I think we should lynch Something Smart on Day 4.
In post 209, eth0s wrote:Defending not_maf at all in this game seems like a viable jester strat lmao
I'll grant this. I like to whiteknight as scum and I really did think he was town so as jester I would have been much more passively defending him, probably by just calling people dumb and repeating that he was town rather than addressing their actual arguments. (Conversely, I would NEVER defend him after that wagon as his partner because I saw such a low chance of people actually listening to me.)
However. I think the rest of the day should prove that I'm not jester. I can easily point to a half dozen things I would have done differently.
I say this because I should probably not live to LYLO, and if I'm not going to I should be lynched today or tomorrow. And before you go OMG jester play!!!1! remember that I'd have to have somehow CORRECTLY and confidently read Not_Mafia, despite your implications that he's difficult or impossible to read.
Hmmmmmmmmm... defending yourself against a jester accusation? I think we should lynch Something Smart on Day 4.
what the hell town can defend himself
If someone would accuse me of being jester, then I would just shrug. A read as jester or scum; well that would cause me to defend myself against the scum read. You scumread me but don't think that I am Jester so I told you why I was playing like that.
NK, the argument put forth in that post was based on the premise that I shouldn't live to endgame because of my defense of Not_Mafia. In that case, I'd rather be lynched before day 4 than after, and that makes defending against jester accusations necessary.
Also, since we're talking so much about jester and not-jester reads, I should probably share my jester pool: {Ari, eth0s, Heartless} in decreasing order of likelihood.
I'm not going to argue you wanting me alive as the Survivor that I am, but why do you expect both me and Dino to make it to day four in this weird AF game, though?
I'm good with SS's plan in terms of lynching NK15. Hopefully NK15 is right about SS being jester. Responding to a case on you with "yo the guy wanting you to lynch me is a fuckin jester" is really weird.
Plus this conversation is clearly one of those that's gonna be a distraction forever.
VOTE: NK15
"I just want to play mafia, not Economics Wonderland." - cytheflyguy
You are scum. You are either Jester scum or Mafia scum. I don't know which one. That is why I said that you should die Day 4. By then, you either suicided as Jester or are the last remaining mafia.
In post 266, Mathdino wrote:I'm good with SS's plan in terms of lynching NK15. Hopefully NK15 is right about SS being jester. Responding to a case on you with "yo the guy wanting you to lynch me is a fuckin jester" is really weird.
Plus this conversation is clearly one of those that's gonna be a distraction forever.
You are scum. You are either Jester scum or Mafia scum. I don't know which one. That is why I said that you should die Day 4. By then, you either suicided as Jester or are the last remaining mafia.
How can my actions have jester motivation or mafia motivation but not town motivation?
You are scum. You are either Jester scum or Mafia scum. I don't know which one. That is why I said that you should die Day 4. By then, you either suicided as Jester or are the last remaining mafia.
How can my actions have jester motivation or mafia motivation but not town motivation?
At the moment, I am not sure if you try to get towncred by telling others you want to get lynched as townie to prevent the Jester from winning...
or if you are really the Jester trying to get lynched on Day 3.
And that defense on Day 1, of Not Mafia, I don't know if you are their partner trying to avert a (for mafia) horrible Day 1 Mafia lynch or if you are the Jester who scumread them(especially easy if you know that they are NOT Jester because there is only one, you...) and tried to look suspicious