Mini Normal 1982: anagrams (endgame) (egad, men!)

[Dunkerdoodles]

why dont you think dunk was killed?

His romantic demeanor

wtf

[Tchill13]

Not_Mafia (née randomidget)- Good lynhc
Tchill13- Bad lynch
Mulch (née Sergtacos)- Bad lynch
Lycanfire- Good lynch
Dunkerdoodles- Bad lynch
Havo- Bad lynch
eth0s- Good lynch
profii- Good lynch
Chumba- Good lynch--- great lynch

VOTE: CHUMBA

VOTE: not mafia

[Mulch]

Not_Mafia (née randomidget)- Good lynhc
Tchill13- Bad lynch
Mulch (née Sergtacos)- Bad lynch
Lycanfire- Good lynch
Dunkerdoodles- Bad lynch
Havo- Bad lynch
eth0s- Good lynch
profii- Good lynch
Chumba- Good lynch--- great lynch

VOTE: CHUMBA

VOTE: not mafia

Sheeping

VOTE: NOTMAFIA

[Dunkerdoodles]

VOTE: notmafia
choo choo

[Tchill13]

seems like a good compromise to me.

[eth0s]

why are we voting him exactly?

[Tchill13]

Why not?

[eth0s]

Why not?

Idk I just thought we would be a bit more methodical. If you all want to wagon him then go ahead but I would like to be a little more sure before I vote. Another mislynch+NK means our scum lynch yesterday won't mean nearly as much.

If anyone wants to actually make a case against him then I'm all ears.

mulch/dunker/profii have most of my attention currently.

[profii]

I thought it was a player fairly universally town read to confuse us

And what about that would “confuse” us?

Prediction : today’s lynch will end up on one of

Me / Havo / Tchill

Why would you post this?

I’m pushing my theory that the Mulch/Taco slot was framed by the Nero kill to see if it stands up.

Assumption: it’s on the money.

Conclusion: mafia would have to avoid trying something like that, so by picking a low post count/ mostly town read player it doesn’t give anything away really. It’s just a plain old logical kill for scum to whittle the town down - it’s not too clever to try and send us at a mislynch today because their attempt on Taco/Mulch got rumbled

So following on from that, I considered process of elimination over the 2 lynches and looked at players who voted for both Morality and Fykus

Logically - a scum might be on Morality because it was a town rush and logically someone might have bussed fykus for cred - the result was the 3 players I mentioned so I thought I’d post in an effort to stifle the logical path to a mafia quick wagon as I believe we are all town..

The other way of thinking about it, is there are 3 scum given we’ve not had 2 kills ina night yet, so the same scummer on the 2 lynches might be ambitious - maybe they rotated meaning a scummer is someone who was on Morality but not Fykus (or vice versus)

This would be Lycan or Dunker... (and I voted for.... )


I know that’s ambitious thinking but I believe in my Taco frame theory so I wanted to reconsider it based on D2 flip and I think the above series of events fits

I wondered if Lycan might go today as he was another highly town read player...

[Tchill13]

I think all 3 of them have a better likelihood of being town than them being scum at this point. Why don't you?

[Chumba]

Why not?

Idk I just thought we would be a bit more methodical. If you all want to wagon him then go ahead but I would like to be a little more sure before I vote. Another mislynch+NK means our scum lynch yesterday won't mean nearly as much.

If anyone wants to actually make a case against him then I'm all ears.

mulch/dunker/profii have most of my attention currently.

He’s not posting or playing. The last person we flipped who did that flipped scum. Doesn’t hurt to pressure him to post.

I’m fine with lynching those 3 also but we need lots of posts from him.

[Chumba]

I think all 3 of them have a better likelihood of being town than them being scum at this point. Why don't you?

You think mulch/profli/dunkers could all be town?

[Chumba]

I’m pushing my theory that the Mulch/Taco slot was framed by the Nero kill to see if it stands up.

[profii]

I’m pushing my theory that the Mulch/Taco slot was framed by the Nero kill to see if it stands up.

it's ambitious but not impossible so face palm all you like... I'll give you a town card as you didn't kill me last night anyway

[Chumba]

remember the discussion about Occam’s razor? I just don’t see how you are town pushing a scenario that is least likely.

VOTE: profli

[profii]

Good to see you are coming round, we've moved from disproven to least likely.

[Chumba]

Well technically it is disproven

[profii]

I would say no one was going to push a taco wagon when I was strongly suggesting that would be a big scum tell in a well presented and thoroughly thought out scenario, so I think your post about saying you were the only one on taco means my theory is disproven does not hold water.

I agree with your occams razor point though - I did say this is all ambitious, however it lead me to Dunkers and I was happy to push that one.

[Chumba]

but mulch/tacos has done nothing that looks town. how can you still be defending them? maybe you figure you had to double down now you lost fykus ?

[profii]

actually, thinking about it, you make a good point. I have to admit Mulchs style annoys the poop out of me so I tend to ignore him throwing votes around like they are going out of fashion but...

I did make a list of everyone's names and work backwards through each ISO and listed what each persons last read was on each other player... In the instance of Mulch, he had made a scum suggestion for every player except UnaBomah (admittedly some of this was down to my interpretation, I was looking at anything that might have even been scum lean on player x etc)

Now it's a stretch to say that Mulch pre-planned to lynch the only player he town read that day, but the mind does do subconscious things.

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: proffii

[profii]

Not_Mafia, your sum contribution is 13 words and 2 votes. Interesting.

[Mulch]

I’m 99% sure chimba is scum

chumba

[Mulch]

Straying too far from his town meta

[Chumba]

Meta is garbage. First on my other accounts I play scum and town identically

This was an account I was trying to keep hidden and as such I am experimenting on a new playstyle.

So your meta argument is garbage but you are scum so this is a non issue.