[1977] Exile Island: Chapter 2 (Day)

[Kaede x Kokichi]

Ari, N_M. Can you explain what you think of Drealz post that I pointed out?

[Dunnstral]

Dunn can you clarify your reads? Is Chickadee the only suspect you have here?

nero, bins, and chikadee are all using meta that doesn't exist to say I'm scum when I have about 6 posts

[Kaede x Kokichi]

Can you tell the class why the meta doesn't exist. Can you link games they've played with you that proves it wrong?

[Kaede x Kokichi]

So you think all 3 of them are scum? Or do you think 1 is scum just coasting on it? If so, what are your other reads? Outside of the fake meta/real meta thing. Who do you townread? Who do you scumread that it outside of that?

[Aristophanes]

Ari, N_M. Can you explain what you think of Drealz post that I pointed out?

This post?

if it's a townslot, I don't think it would have sat around as a viable wagon

What does this even mean? So you're saying town can't be mislynched?

I think he is a little misguided, but I don't see any scum intent in the post. Do you?

[Kaede x Kokichi]

ehhh, I don't like that claim at all...

especially with how much flavor the game has (and my role PM's flavor), for someone to come and claim and have it be simple "novice cop", combined with their seeming non-care attitude (plus the rest of the constant scumness they've been oooozing), I'm inclined to think that's just scum throwing something out there and hoping it saves them or to out a counterclaim, which also kind of fits the 4scumteam idea - that they'd care less, and possibly already be being bused

eh, not like I'm going to push us to lynch the claimed cop on D1, but, I know I'm not all "oh okay then guess we'll look elsewhere" either, but I am still strongly scumreading there regardless of claim

if it's a townslot, I don't think it would have sat around as a viable wagon+lynch for as long as it did, even getting to L-1 for a good period, I think scum would have pushed it more, rather than there being a ton of lurking (which makes me think some scum were just biding time hoping it'd go away)

Makes me think Drealz is scum even more now. His whole post is contradictory. Says he thinks we are scum but tried to tiptoe by posting the 2nd paragraph about not pushing the cop claim, then subtly tries to push in his next paragraph.

[Kaede x Kokichi]

Those 2 posts, what do you think about what I pointed out. What makes him misguided over scum?

[Not_Mafia]

hmmmmm

[Kaede x Kokichi]

An analysis of it would be great.

[Not_Mafia]

I'm reflecting on it

[DiamondSentinel]

They're lurking, which they do incredibly commonly, regardless of alignment.

agreed. But he just feels different than normal. Call it gut, I can't really put it into words.

As a bonus Q. You are voting Ari, who lurks regardless of alignment, why is his lurking scummy and Dunn's isn't?

Same reason that you just said. He feels off. Dunnstral less so.

I've modded for Dunnstral as scum in the past, and this doens't feel at all like that game.

[Chickadee]

sorry sorry sorry sorry

Just checking in right before heading to bed. Super tired from work, have to work again tomorrow, and I have plans after. I've been pretty clear about where I stand though.

[Bins]

tbh i have scumreads on all the ppl rn

[Bins]

i mention dreal and then 3 people hop on it? spooks

[MariaR]

tldr on dreal scum?

[Not_Mafia]

I'd lynch most people at this point

[Aeronaut]

VoteCount 1.21

(expired on 2018-01-23 04:13:00) remain.

• [L-7] Nero Cain -
  
  
  [L-7] Not_Mafia -
  
  
  [L-5]

  drealmerz7 -
  Dunkerdoodles, Kaede x Kokichi
  
  [L-7] SnarkySnowman -
  
  
  [L-7] Sheepsaysmeep -
  
  
  [L-6]

  Chickadee -
  Dunnstral
  
  [L-6]

  Aristophanes

  -
  DiamondSentinel
  
  [L-7] MariaR -
  
  
  [L-7] DiamondSentinel -
  
  
  [L-5]

  Dunnstral -
  Chickadee, Nero Cain
  
  [L-7]

  Bins

  -
  
  
  [L-7] dunkerdoodles -
  
  
  [L-4]

  Kaede x Kokichi -
  Aristophanes
  , drealmerz7, not mafia

Not Voting

- SnarkySnowman, Bins, MariaR, Sheepsaysmeep

[Aeronaut]

I'll be kind of VLA and phone posting until around Monday morning, but I'll still be mostly active.

[Kaede x Kokichi]

i mention dreal and then 3 people hop on it? spooks

tldr on dreal scum?

Read post #555

[Bins]

i know this is sort of weird but maria does ur role relate to your flavour

[DiamondSentinel]

Screw it. We need a lynch and I'll go for a Dunnstral lynch. I'd still prefer to get an Aristophanes lynch, but we've all got to compromise a bit especially this close to DL.

VOTE: Dunnstral

[Aristophanes]

Screw it. We need a lynch and I'll go for a Dunnstral lynch. I'd still prefer to get an Aristophanes lynch, but we've all got to compromise a bit especially this close to DL.

VOTE: Dunnstral

Why not Kaede?

This dunn push and the push on me feel manufactured and if you really were deadline compromising voting Kaede would make more sense

[sheepsaysmeep]

VOTE: dia
cfd gogogogo

[sheepsaysmeep]

memes > the game

[sheepsaysmeep]

im fine with the drealz post