Team Mafia 2018: Mafiosi Revolution (Over)

[Ether]

Day 1, Votecount 20

---

4 Transcend (Chara, Ginngie, Toranaga, Mulch)
3 Cabd (Firebringer, Spiffeh, Transcend)
2 UnaBombaH (Cheetory6, implosion)
1 Firebringer (Kmd4390)
1 Kmd4390 (Patrick)
1 Mulch (Kagami)

3 Unvote (Aristophanes, Cabd, UnaBombaH)

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.
The deadline is in (expired on 2018-02-05 00:00:00), on Sunday, February 4 at 11:59 pm EST.

---

[Transcend]

Whatever, everyone else in the game trs me so idc :p

[Transcend]

1 Firebringer (Kmd4390)

Hmmm Not good

[Cheetory6]

T have you ever done the whole "this person is going to be a mislynch" thing when you were scum?
Also, how often have you been wrong about this sort of thing as town?

Keely, is 217 a townpost or bullshit?

First little bit is kinda townish I guess?
I feel like there's a lot of stuff that bothers me about Una that I'm finding it hard to get past. :/

[Transcend]

Yes

And maybe 20% of the time.

[Transcend]

Back to work

[Cabd]

Kagami let's talk about mulch.

And why he's a townarse this game. You clearly think otherwise; care to unpack that?

[Cabd]

Kagami let's talk about mulch.

And why he's a townarse this game. You clearly think otherwise; care to unpack that?

My sane-keeper cheet can chime in too I guess but only because he's cool.

[implosion]

Implosion you do realize Transcend's forte as scum is having good tone

This quote from me in the game I played with Transcend-scum kind of resonates here:

As for Transcend: I still think he's scummy. Frankly it feels like he's trying way too hard relative to how it felt like he played in my other game with him. In that game he seemed overall irreverent, making snyde comments and commenting on a sort of arbitrary subset of the things that were being said (of course it was a large normal so there's a difference there but etc). Something feels off about his entry into the game and I think it's that it feels like he's going "hey guys I have reads look at me."

I feel like he isn't trying hard here, and he has the right mix of irreverence and pointedness from what I think his town game is supposed to look like.

[Toranaga]

when I decide to ISO kmd, I'll think he is scum won't I?

[implosion]

@Transcend: did you ever respond to post 554? If not, can you, and if so, can you point me to it?

[Mulch]

Implosion you do realize Transcend's forte as scum is having good tone

This quote from me in the game I played with Transcend-scum kind of resonates here:

As for Transcend: I still think he's scummy. Frankly it feels like he's trying way too hard relative to how it felt like he played in my other game with him. In that game he seemed overall irreverent, making snyde comments and commenting on a sort of arbitrary subset of the things that were being said (of course it was a large normal so there's a difference there but etc). Something feels off about his entry into the game and I think it's that it feels like he's going "hey guys I have reads look at me."

I feel like he isn't trying hard here, and he has the right mix of irreverence and pointedness from what I think his town game is supposed to look like.

I don't know, he seems really scummy to me. Like when he did that reaction test. That's super scummy

Or the fact Eddie Cane can't explain why he scumreads me.

Or the fact they are tunneling me despite the fact they both profess not to be able to read me

[Mulch]

Implosion you do realize Transcend's forte as scum is having good tone

This quote from me in the game I played with Transcend-scum kind of resonates here:

As for Transcend: I still think he's scummy. Frankly it feels like he's trying way too hard relative to how it felt like he played in my other game with him. In that game he seemed overall irreverent, making snyde comments and commenting on a sort of arbitrary subset of the things that were being said (of course it was a large normal so there's a difference there but etc). Something feels off about his entry into the game and I think it's that it feels like he's going "hey guys I have reads look at me."

I feel like he isn't trying hard here, and he has the right mix of irreverence and pointedness from what I think his town game is supposed to look like.

I don't know, he seems really scummy to me. Like when he did that reaction test. That's super scummy

Or the fact Eddie Cane can't explain why he scumreads me.

Or the fact they are tunneling me despite the fact they both profess not to be able to read me

Last game I was scum against Eddie, he townread me and then I dominated his ass. It dosen't make sesne that he would scumread me and think his read is legit here. And trans still hasn't given me a simple "why" which also makes no sense

[Toranaga]

when I decide to ISO kmd, I'll think he is scum won't I?

I didn't

[Cheetory6]

My sane-keeper cheet can chime in too I guess but only because he's cool.

Will probably be a little disappointing but here goes:

On the one hand I'm feeling townMulch in terms of his engagement/general gutfeels, but on the other hand his scumGame is apparently pretty good?

I could probably throw some hard effort at him to try to figure him out, but I feel like it's probably easier to just ignore him for now. [And I frankly probably ignored most of his posting in the first ten pages
>.>]

I told myself I would dig into Transcend vs Mulch harder tonight but that was probably never happening with my schedule right now.

Please compare mulch hater-boner to me in THIS game: viewtopic.php?f=53&t=73108

to his ISO here. It's different enough to earn that read from me.

Will try to get to this sometime in the next day or so if I can.

[Cheetory6]

Last game I was scum against Eddie, he townread me and then I dominated his ass. It dosen't make sesne that he would scumread me and think his read is legit here.

I would think this would make Eddie more wary of you, rather than just discouraging him completely from even trying to read you?

[Mulch]

Last game I was scum against Eddie, he townread me and then I dominated his ass. It dosen't make sesne that he would scumread me and think his read is legit here.

I would think this would make Eddie more wary of you, rather than just discouraging him completely from even trying to read you?

That's true I guess

Good point

It's possible he's just being super paranoid

but i still would like a reason I guess

[Transcend]

crazy... but i became hardtown when i wasn't voting you

hmmm i wonder if that's a genuine thought process from a player with a green role pm at all..

hmmmm

Transcend trying to pretend town isn't biased or inconsistent is telling.
it's textbook contradiction = scum logic employed by scum, i don't believe it's a real read coming from Transcend either.

I use this logic as both alignments

[Toranaga]

Last game I was scum against Eddie, he townread me and then I dominated his ass. It dosen't make sesne that he would scumread me and think his read is legit here.

I would think this would make Eddie more wary of you, rather than just discouraging him completely from even trying to read you?

That's true I guess

Good point

It's possible he's just being super paranoid

but i still would like a reason I guess

yo

ISO patrick

[Mulch]

but on the other hand his scumGame is apparently pretty good

Yeah it's so good that I get mislynched consistently as town

Like I was this game until someone who actually knows how to read me like Toranaga saved me

[Mulch]

Last game I was scum against Eddie, he townread me and then I dominated his ass. It dosen't make sesne that he would scumread me and think his read is legit here.

I would think this would make Eddie more wary of you, rather than just discouraging him completely from even trying to read you?

That's true I guess

Good point

It's possible he's just being super paranoid

but i still would like a reason I guess

yo

ISO patrick

Isos -_-

[Kmd4390]

Implosion feels pretty town rn

Really? Why?

748 and 792 are towny

Can you be more specific? Especially on the second one because that's likely something his team discussed pre-game. I'm willing to be at least half of the teams talked about who each team would give scum roles to.

[Mulch]

Last game I was scum against Eddie, he townread me and then I dominated his ass. It dosen't make sesne that he would scumread me and think his read is legit here.

I would think this would make Eddie more wary of you, rather than just discouraging him completely from even trying to read you?

That's true I guess

Good point

It's possible he's just being super paranoid

but i still would like a reason I guess

yo

ISO patrick

Isos -_-

I didn't really realize this but he does seem to be kind of pocketing me

Kind of in a panther-y way

otherwise I can follow his thoughts but there's nothing exceptionally towny

[Mulch]

Implosion feels pretty town rn

Really? Why?

748 and 792 are towny

Can you be more specific? Especially on the second one because that's likely something his team discussed pre-game. I'm willing to be at least half of the teams talked about who each team would give scum roles to.

i mean it more mitgated the scumread I had on him for pushing me on ~weird~ reasons, I can see him thinking that I would be handed a role PM red and same with ari, also I can see where he is coming from with Trans. the Trans stuff feels real to me

[Toranaga]

Last game I was scum against Eddie, he townread me and then I dominated his ass. It dosen't make sesne that he would scumread me and think his read is legit here.

I would think this would make Eddie more wary of you, rather than just discouraging him completely from even trying to read you?

That's true I guess

Good point

It's possible he's just being super paranoid

but i still would like a reason I guess

yo

ISO patrick

Isos -_-

I didn't really realize this but he does seem to be kind of pocketing me

Kind of in a panther-y way

otherwise I can follow his thoughts but there's nothing exceptionally towny

logic heavy crafty wolf posting IMO

but if it's not jumping out on you that's alright