In post 2159, Aneninen wrote: In post 2118, chesskid3 wrote: In post 2117, Aneninen wrote:2) I don't think this story is confirmable in any way which is not against the rules
its existence and effectiveness have been confirmed in completed games and there are many players in team mafia who can attest to this.
I guess there are other players being able to confirm this.
Many
In post 2118, chesskid3 wrote:
Therefore it carries the same weight as a cop guilty and needs to be treated as such by every player in this game.
No, it's
very far
from Cop guilty. Firstly, noone can know it for sure whether you used that program on Mastina. Secondly, even if you did so, there's
no
100% guarantee that it analysed Mastina correctly.
The first part is only true if I am scum. As I stated before, my ego is not so out of control that I would fake this as town. The second is incorrect. As I also stated before, this has never been wrong, has an established history and coincidences don't exist (it's not going to magically be wrong for the first time ever on a tell it found in team mafia. Also tells are output with a confidence range etc etc and the one in this case is as close to a certainty as it gets.
See the below quote.
In post 5056, Ellibereth wrote:I AM absolutely abusing the meta where I've NEVER BEEN WRONG when i've declared a 100% scumread on someone.
That's, unfortunately, not true. It's also possible that the program you used makes you over-confident about your reads, and both you and Mastina are town. And we can't rule it out that both Mastina and you are scum and this whole story about that analysis is pigeon poop. (Although I don't think this latter one is too likely.)
The above rules out the Town/Town scenario. You are correct that the Scum/Scum scenario is an option, albeit a silly one. However if this is your concern this is absolutely MORE reason to vote between us
In post 2122, chesskid3 wrote:
Ive said this before but I'll say it again, RCs actions in this game make just as much if not more sense as a mastina buddy going hard in the paint to save mastina than a pants on head town.
Once mastina flips scum and Im dead he's going to continue being loud and controlling, despite claims that he only did so to save mastina. As sane/obvtown voices like Hindu, Reck die I don't trust he will actually be lynched, and it 100% needs to happen.
This is worth pigeon poop if Mastina flips town. If Mastina gets lynched and she flips scum, we'll take a close look on RadiantCowbells. (But in this case we should take a close look on plenty of other players too. Eg. me.)
What you're saying about RadiantCowbells is not impossible. I saw that gameplay from him before and I definitely don't want to see it here. But right now I don't have an idea whether we see the aggressive town-RC or the aggressive scum-RC.
By the way, if that program
really
works so perfectly,
why
haven't you examined other players too? Eg. RadiantCowbells? Reckoner?
It is possible that I have tells on other players in team Mafia. I am not going to confirm or deny this. However as I stated before,
I have the tells Elli gave me and from when we messed with the program together prior to him taking over team mafia. I also am depressed that I had to use this to win this fight with Mastina+RC.
As far as point 6, it's simply to lay out a clear conditional.
