Newbie 1846 - Game Over

[Not_Mafia]

I saw my role was possible with Neopolitan, got it my head that that was the set-up, so when UC claimed I forgot to recheck the other Doc set-ups and claimed by reflex

[MagikHorse]

Still put more faith in UCV than Golden, so the vote swings that way. At least if I'm wrong it's an easy and guaranteed lynch on UCV tomorrow.

VOTE: TheGoldenParadox

That's the Hammer folks!

[Myloninja13]

I would prefer a TGP lynch.
updated reads lists

town
me
magik

town lean
NM, leeoon

null
mason slot
slight scum lean
lucky
cabd
scum
tgp

Geez, apparentally I'm not even playing

But woah, that escalated quickly. I was always more suspicous of Golden, and I would understand him claiming a role to try and avoid his lynch, but I don't know.

As of now, I still don't like voting UCV, most of the evdience behind him seems a stretch at best, but we do need a lynch and I'm not sure where to go.

[MagikHorse]

It'a hammered anyways Mylon. TGP is a dead man talking.

[Myloninja13]

Oh, didn't see that. I'm fine with that, I was likely going to do that anyway if someone else hadn't.

[MagikHorse]

Yeah. Usually I'd state my intent to hammer first, but why bother when he's already claimed and done everything he could to defend himself?

Still, if he flips Town Neapolitan, UCV should die tomorrow as a confirmed fakeclaiming scum.

[Huntress]

Vote Count 1.13

TheGoldenParadox (5) - 3 Masons in a Trenchcoat, UC Voyager, Not_Mafia, Leeoon, MagikHorse [LYNCH]

UC Voyager (2) - Cabd, TheGoldenParadox
Cabd (1) - Lucky2u
3 Masons in a Trenchcoat (1) - Myloninja13

Not voting (0) -


With nine players alive, it takes five votes to lynch.

[Huntress]

TheGoldenParadox (Vanilla Townie) was lynched Day One.

It is now Night One.

Deadline for Night One is Saturday, 27th January, 11.40 pm GMT, (in (expired on 2018-01-27 23:40:00)) assuming I have found a replacement before then.

[Huntress]

yankeefan116 replaces 3 Masons in a Trenchcoat.

[Huntress]

Not_Mafia (Town Doctor) was killed night one.

It is now DAY TWO

With seven players alive, it takes four votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Two is Saturday 10th February, 11.40 pm GMT, (in (expired on 2018-02-10 23:40:00)).

[Lucky2u]

ok... so now we lynch Cabd?

[MagikHorse]

TGP basically gave up our power roles trying to save his butt, and I am

peeved

to all heck and back about this. There was no reason to claim anything but VT, as another claim just puts our Town PRs at risk. Now the scum knows who is what with 100% certainty and our Doctor is dead over it. Just... ugh...

Alright Magik, chill a little. It'll all be alright. We're not dead yet. We can sort all this out. UCV is still alive as an essentially proven Townie. With a little luck in hitting the Mafia Roleblocker today, we can

maybe

save him from inevitable death and take an easy Town win with it. It's just a 20% chance of hitting the Roleblocker and then another 20% chance to jail the scum, but it's still possible. We still have everything from yesterday, we have a finished wagon to look at, and a new player stepping in for a fresh perspective.

Alright, let's get to business with a question.

Cabd

, with UCV as a proven Town via claiming and Not_Mafia dead, I want to know where you stand on who is scum since your arguments on those two don't hold together anymore. Do you still think Lucky is scum, and why?

Lucky

, why are you leaning on Cabd so much as scum? On that note, could we have your reads at all? You never once gave us a readlist on Day 1, and it would be very informative.

Yankee

, welcome to 3 Mason's slot! Have a good read if you haven't already.

Just generally, what does everyone think of Masons/Yankee with Golden flipping Town? I'm inclined to think it a mistake along the lines of my own mistake, but I'd like more opinions here on what Masons might've been going at before being replaced.

[UC Voyager]

pro-tip 2: don't fake claim as town.

[Cabd]

Yeah that was pretty anti-town and game-throwish?

Sigh. Resetting...

[Leeoon]

To Ben honest, I don't think TGP flipping town makes Masons/Yankee any more or less scummy. That said, I'm really not sure where my opinion on him lands right now. I guess I'm going to have to see what Yankee brings to the table.

[yankeefan116]

Hi everyone! Glad to be here!

I don't understand for the life of me why town people insist on fake claiming as town?
Same thing happened to me in my first game and I got lynched day 1 as a Bulletproof because a town person counterclaimed my real claim.
Mafia ended up getting a clean sweep.
I also don't think it was wise of NotMafia to imply he had a power role so early in the game.
All that did was gave an easy target to the Mafia.

In any case, we really got to get this next one right, otherwise we are going to be significantly behind with 4 town people down.

If UC Voyager is telling the truth and he's the jailkeeper, with the doctor dead, that means we have to be playing Row 2 Column A.
If anybody else out there has a power role, then that person knows that UC Voyager is lying and that means we're playing Row 3.
The problem is, that person can't really counterclaim because with no doctor, we have no way of protecting them.
So that kind of puts us in a difficult position.

So my first question is for UC Voyager. Who did you lock in jail last night?

[UC Voyager]

Hi everyone! Glad to be here!

I don't understand for the life of me why town people insist on fake claiming as town?
Same thing happened to me in my first game and I got lynched day 1 as a Bulletproof because a town person counterclaimed my real claim.
Mafia ended up getting a clean sweep.
I also don't think it was wise of NotMafia to imply he had a power role so early in the game.
All that did was gave an easy target to the Mafia.

In any case, we really got to get this next one right, otherwise we are going to be significantly behind with 4 town people down.

If UC Voyager is telling the truth and he's the jailkeeper, with the doctor dead, that means we have to be playing Row 2 Column A.
If anybody else out there has a power role, then that person knows that UC Voyager is lying and that means we're playing Row 3.
The problem is, that person can't really counterclaim because with no doctor, we have no way of protecting them.
So that kind of puts us in a difficult position.

So my first question is for UC Voyager. Who did you lock in jail last night?

I jailed cabd. i was going to try to jailkeep NM, s they could live, but i remembered that they had a roleblocker who would just RB me, so i was hoping that they would have RB commit kill and roleblock me. that or them RB NOTMAFIA and NM could still doc me.

[UC Voyager]

Hi everyone! Glad to be here!

I don't understand for the life of me why town people insist on fake claiming as town?
Same thing happened to me in my first game and I got lynched day 1 as a Bulletproof because a town person counterclaimed my real claim.
Mafia ended up getting a clean sweep.
I also don't think it was wise of NotMafia to imply he had a power role so early in the game.
All that did was gave an easy target to the Mafia.

In any case, we really got to get this next one right, otherwise we are going to be significantly behind with 4 town people down.

If UC Voyager is telling the truth and he's the jailkeeper, with the doctor dead, that means we have to be playing Row 2 Column A.
If anybody else out there has a power role, then that person knows that UC Voyager is lying and that means we're playing Row 3.
The problem is, that person can't really counterclaim because with no doctor, we have no way of protecting them.
So that kind of puts us in a difficult position.

So my first question is for UC Voyager. Who did you lock in jail last night?

i read some of that game. it was really really really sad, and a prime example of a horrible town. you did nothing wrong

[Lucky2u]

Lucky, why are you leaning on Cabd so much as scum? On that note, could we have your reads at all? You never once gave us a readlist on Day 1, and it would be very informative.

He should be talking more. I realize that seems hypocritical, but I mean town Cabd should be talking more. I'm not saying he posts often, I don't think he does really, but his posts usually have more substance then this.

Here is my read lists. Ucv is confirmed town. I am confirmed town to myself. There are 4 non Cabd players other then that, they range is scum from greatest to least as follows.

Yankee.
Leon
Mylon
Magick

[Lucky2u]

VOTE: cabd

[Leeoon]

Here's my reads list

Town: UCV, Magick

Null:Lucky, Yankee

Scum: Cabd, Mylon

Here are my questions for everybody.

Yankee: Can you give a detailed reads list, and thoughts on the major events of day 1? I want to see your stance on things.

Cabd and Mylon: More content, please. Neither of you have contributed that much. You can start by doing the same thing I asked Yankee to do.

Lucky: Any over thoughts?

VOTE: Mylon

[Myloninja13]

I don't really have strong reads again, but here's my readlist (From most town to least)

UCV (I'm pretty sure he's confirmed without a counterclaim)

MagikHorse (Just overall helpful play)

Lucky & Leeoon(Not really much to say, but I'm giving them town leans)

Yankee (This is obviously based off Masons Day1, Yankee so far seems fine. Neutral.

Cabd (I don't necessarily think they are scum, but they're the only player I'd actually vote for now.)

There wasnt really much to say about Day1 aside from the whole L-1 debate, which I already talked about.

[Myloninja13]

Oops, I forgot to

Vote: Cabd

[UC Voyager]

Guys. No quocklynching. Today is my last day alive, so lets make the most of it please. Thanks

[Myloninja13]

It's L-2. I wouldn't have made it L-1, and my only other real voting option was Yankee, who just started out.