Team Mafia 2018: Mafiosi Revolution (Over)

[UnaBombaH]

OK, end of the spamline:

Solid-ish Townreads:

Patrick, Cheetory6, Chara

Townleans:

Spiffeh, implosion, Firebringer

Waffle-line:

Ginngie, Toranaga, Kmd4390

Scumleans:

Aristophanes, Kagami, Cabd

Scumreads:

Mulch-slot, Eddie Cane

DISCLAIMER:

I absolutely hate saying anyone is "NULL" at this point of the game anymore, therefore I have that waffle-line for slots I'm having most trouble with. Almost all of those slots are either A) posting too little ACTUAL CONTENT for me to be confident in my ability to read them or B) providing good content I townread, but then posting things I scumread, and effectively muddying it up.

On Eddie/mulch - I do not care how much Eddie (or anyone else) bashes me for putting him down there, but I'm trying to be honest and open with my read on the slot at the moment. One reason that slot is still in there, is because of how Trans approached the game. While Eddie has been salvaging the slot immensely, I still think Trans was scum, and therefore Eddie is playing VERY WELL, but on a scum-slot. (I feel dirty for writing scum-slot, I might have a dirty mind )

Toranaga WOULD BE a townlean for me, but his waffling on mulch confused me immensely.
One of the main reasons why I want a flip from mulch/Eddie is for me to maybe be able to sort Tor too.

Kmd I initially scumread, but their content has been generally good. They will most likely rise above or fall below by the time they make their next bigger post.

Ginngie is not as adorable as I thought she might be. She is one of the three slots in this game that would benefit IMMENSELY from just spamming game-related content. She would likely either towntell, or be scummy in my eyes very quickly.

The other two slots that I just need to see more from (in terms of quantity) are Cabd and Ari. If they are town, all they need to do is spam content, and I'm almost certain I'm able to sort them too. (I understand IRL can be hard, it has been for me too, but that is the only way I can confidently sort them)

K, thx bai.

[Ginngie]

Ginngie is not as adorable as I thought she might be.

[UnaBombaH]

I think DBZ-abridged is amazing, and Vegeta is the best there and in the original, so I'll give you some DBZ-based towncred that have absolutely no effect on this game.

[Ginngie]

remember this is LyLo

[UnaBombaH]

remember this is LyLo

.........

(No idea what kind of "stuff" she is using, but I almost feel like I want some.)

[Ginngie]

remember this is LyLo

.........

(No idea what kind of "stuff" she is using, but I almost feel like I want some.)

yes

[UnaBombaH]

Who is scum Ginngie? Don't need to tell "why" for now, just tell me who.

[Ginngie]

viewtopic.php?p=9912583#p9912583

keep read

[UnaBombaH]

Ah, but you don't list the "who's left" explicitly as scumreads..
You also explain your townreads better than you do any scumreads.

[Ginngie]

I got the strat from Nacho, if I have a really tough time finding scum, but the ability to find town is something I can do really well.

So I go for finding the town and then by PoE i have to have the scum and that's how I play.

[Toranaga]

so what's up

someone had both mulch and transcend as top scum leans and you know what, I get it

[Kmd4390]

Kmd: So if I understood this correctly: Kagami and Imp have gained scumleans from you because of HOW they have presented their townreads on you? I like this line of thinking.

That was part of it, yeah. I feel a little better about implosion on that issue now though.

[Eddie Cane]

OK, end of the spamline:

Solid-ish Townreads:

Patrick, Cheetory6, Chara

Townleans:

Spiffeh, implosion, Firebringer

Waffle-line:

Ginngie, Toranaga, Kmd4390

Scumleans:

Aristophanes, Kagami, Cabd

Scumreads:

Mulch-slot, Eddie Cane

DISCLAIMER:

I absolutely hate saying anyone is "NULL" at this point of the game anymore, therefore I have that waffle-line for slots I'm having most trouble with. Almost all of those slots are either A) posting too little ACTUAL CONTENT for me to be confident in my ability to read them or B) providing good content I townread, but then posting things I scumread, and effectively muddying it up.

On Eddie/mulch - I do not care how much Eddie (or anyone else) bashes me for putting him down there, but I'm trying to be honest and open with my read on the slot at the moment. One reason that slot is still in there, is because of how Trans approached the game. While Eddie has been salvaging the slot immensely, I still think Trans was scum, and therefore Eddie is playing VERY WELL, but on a scum-slot. (I feel dirty for writing scum-slot, I might have a dirty mind )

Toranaga WOULD BE a townlean for me, but his waffling on mulch confused me immensely.
One of the main reasons why I want a flip from mulch/Eddie is for me to maybe be able to sort Tor too.

Kmd I initially scumread, but their content has been generally good. They will most likely rise above or fall below by the time they make their next bigger post.

Ginngie is not as adorable as I thought she might be. She is one of the three slots in this game that would benefit IMMENSELY from just spamming game-related content. She would likely either towntell, or be scummy in my eyes very quickly.

The other two slots that I just need to see more from (in terms of quantity) are Cabd and Ari. If they are town, all they need to do is spam content, and I'm almost certain I'm able to sort them too. (I understand IRL can be hard, it has been for me too, but that is the only way I can confidently sort them)

K, thx bai.

mulch is either town which makes tor town or scum which probably still makes tor town

[Kmd4390]

I was expecting that to be a post calling unabombs list a good list lol

[Eddie Cane]

it's not, my slot bring his strongest scumread is completely unjustifiable, and other than cheet my 3 biggest trs are his null line.

also una, in penguin mafia you did no reads lists like that and by the end (20-30 pages longer than the thread is now) you had a 2 page iso full of content. in WR mafia, however, you did those reads lists a lot and were always playing catchup iirc. thoughts?

[Aristophanes]

Reading a bit on my lunch break!

Vheet, I will answer the questions you had soon. As for sounding disingenuous about it being all spam, that is what I have read. If it becomes content full in my read I will be extremely pleased!

[Aristophanes]

If kagami flips scum then trans is town imo

Great, then we agree he's town.

Wait what

Oh lord

This is probably my favourite post of the game yet! XD

Watching that thought process was amazing!
And towny AF!

[Aristophanes]

So you/your team chose you for this mini normal over the other after you saw what your roles in both normals were?

Who cares?

I dont see why you are on this so much and I don't think it looks good on you.

I will be interested in reading your follow up to this.

[Kagami]

Hey spiff and/or cabd, are you around?

[UnaBombaH]

also una, in penguin mafia you did no reads lists like that and by the end (20-30 pages longer than the thread is now) you had a 2 page iso full of content. in WR mafia, however, you did those reads lists a lot and were always playing catchup iirc. thoughts?

Activity-meta would be a more accurate tool with me if IRL didn't pace my playing 100%.
Whenever I have time and energy - I'm online. Sometimes even when I don't. No matter the alignment.
I've been re-assigned at work, and that has taken a lot of my mental energy the past week or so, and it didn't help that this game was moving at an insane pace during my below-insane energy levels.

Now that I'm caught up, I only get left behind if you guys spam awfully lot during my sleepy-time (~6 hours from here on out actually).

AND just to make sure you don't get excited with those "points" of yours while I'm sleeping..

A) I might have not done such readslists in penguins game, because it was my first game outside of the newbie-queue. Something like my third game ever of forum-mafia.
B) I had more content in that game because, if memory serves correctly, I was able to stay up to speed the whole game then, and the distribution of posts were completely different. Firebringer, Trans and mulch make close to a total of 950 posts of this game so far..!
I'm also questioning me playing catch-up in WR-mafia, but don't feel the need to even check that now.

Back to fishing for you Eddie..

[UnaBombaH]

That was part of it, yeah. I feel a little better about implosion on that issue now though.

Good to hear.

[Kagami]

Patrick, katsuki says you've clearly senile and should just trust us on mulch-scum.

As a side note, I find it pretty incredible that there are so many goofy townreads on that slot while my entire team (minus smocaine who just hasn't commented on this game) agrees with me on this.

[Kagami]

you've clearly grown senile*

[implosion]

So you/your team chose you for this mini normal over the other after you saw what your roles in both normals were?

Who cares?

I dont see why you are on this so much and I don't think it looks good on you.

I will be interested in reading your follow up to this.

I mean.

If you literally look at Mulch's reply to this post on the same page, he says he was planning to take the scum PM if his team got one between the two normals, which is basically what I was trying to get out of this, i.e. a statement from him on what the baseline probability of him being scum is (which happens to be 36% if he is telling the truth about everything here).

It's not something I think is good to emphasize but it's good to know the baseline probability according to him. I also thought he was implying he'd decided entirely which game to pick between the two normals before seeing roles which seemed nonsensical.

I'm not really sure what your issue is with this, Ari.

[Patrick]

Patrick, katsuki says you've clearly senile and should just trust us on mulch-scum.

I appreciate Katsuki chiming in with this.

If forced to pick between you and Mulch (replacement), I'd probably vote for Mulch, but am not really comfortable with the idea that that one of you has to be scum, which seems to be gaining a fair bit of support. What's your current read on Spiffeh?