In post 447, SnarkySnowman wrote:So wait... 16 who are not immune = 8 immune => 6 immune non-cult leaders? Did I miss something or is there also no way to die? The plot ~thickens~
It has been established, several times, that there is no lynching.
Rather than trying to figure out what exactly happened, just accept the fact the two niw cannot be recruited. Period. Other than that, O'd be going by the navy rule: Don't ask. Don't tell.
So, since we KNOW each of the cults started with 1 member, and thus Town (neutrals) started with 22, it follows that we had 4 or 6 neutrals who could not be recruited (this depends on whether the 16 available dreal mentioned were his count before or after Dunker/Creature lost their virginity)
This also means any neutral with a role PM
other than Virgin
Should claim if put @L-2. We can trust their claims today bc Virgins wouldn't want to fake claim when they don't even know if they're going to get picked by either cult, and the Cult Leaders would not want to stop the immunization process targeting them (because it fails an thus a step to weaken the Town).
OK, Gamma has never been in a PT with me (at least I don't remember hi to be), but how could/would you miss the joke when you literally know I fake dumb to extract laughter???
ANYTIME a player submits an action, I respond with a "noted" - if you submit an action but do not receive a "noted" response, it's possible I missed recording your action, please bring my lack of "noted" response to my attention via PM - thanks!
So, what's the vote count (for reals)? We need to consolidate on wagons, and I suggest NOW is a good time to pick a new target hat hasn'r been brought up before (so it'd be much less likely they got targeted be the recruitment). I as going to say this in my previous post (the one where I commented on the mod's declaration on Creature/Dunker losing virginity), but I decided to wait just in case the cult leaders were waiting to see who was being wagoned.
Since dreal said it was close to the end of he day back then, I figure the cult leaders most likely did submit their action already (which cannot be modified, remember?)
Some how about we all go for: Lifthrasil/Vecna/Nancy Drew 39/northsidegal/JaydragonKing
I think that's a big enough a pool to pick from.
VOTE: Jay
Reason: I know him to be good at Scum and if recruited he could very well fool most if not all of us. Fortunately there's no killing ability for the Scum to get rid of those who won't fall for his trickery, but I'd rather be safe than sorry.
NSG I've never seen Scum!her but she's good at Town, so I'm akin the risk of maybe being able to see a definitive difference in her play if she gets recruited.
Vecna has been giving too much advice I think it will show if his alignment changes. I think his play alone should guarantee he won't be recruited (or at least I hope it does).
Lifthrasil I don't know, but -based on activity- I wouldn't be bothered recruiting him on D1 if I was a leader
Nancy Drew 39 I remember the name, but I'm not sure if we did play together, and she hasn't even posted yet, so probably not a recruitment target either.
In post 469, Almost50 wrote:So, what's the vote count (for reals)? We need to consolidate on wagons, and I suggest NOW is a good time to pick a new target hat hasn'r been brought up before (so it'd be much less likely they got targeted be the recruitment). I as going to say this in my previous post (the one where I commented on the mod's declaration on Creature/Dunker losing virginity), but I decided to wait just in case the cult leaders were waiting to see who was being wagoned.
Since dreal said it was close to the end of he day back then, I figure the cult leaders most likely did submit their action already (which cannot be modified, remember?)
Some how about we all go for: Lifthrasil/Vecna/Nancy Drew 39/northsidegal/JaydragonKing
I think that's a big enough a pool to pick from.
VOTE: Jay
Reason: I know him to be good at Scum and if recruited he could very well fool most if not all of us. Fortunately there's no killing ability for the Scum to get rid of those who won't fall for his trickery, but I'd rather be safe than sorry.
NSG I've never seen Scum!her but she's good at Town, so I'm akin the risk of maybe being able to see a definitive difference in her play if she gets recruited.
Vecna has been giving too much advice I think it will show if his alignment changes. I think his play alone should guarantee he won't be recruited (or at least I hope it does).
Lifthrasil I don't know, but -based on activity- I wouldn't be bothered recruiting him on D1 if I was a leader
Nancy Drew 39 I remember the name, but I'm not sure if we did play together, and she hasn't even posted yet, so probably not a recruitment target either.
A50, are you paying attention? Jay was the leader for like 24 hours, and thus fails your initial test of making a choice who hasn't been previously suggested.
It should be illegal to run a theme game and post flavor posts that correspond to actions but don't outright proclaim that an action actually happened or what the action is.
There's literally no way for us to say that drealmerz post means fuck all, but we're all acting on it as if it's mod-confirmation of two players becoming cult-immune when it's mod flavor that only sort of hints at that.
Doubly awkward is that the game didn't START with a 'Virgin' count and the entire 'virgin' mechanic wasn't a part of the public ruleset from the get-go.
This puts us in a really, really awkward position where we actually should be shooting to immunize people who even mentioned virgin stuff before the Virgin count was posted, because those are very likely the folks who were well aware of their virgin status, maybe?