Mini Normal 1985 No Spoilers (END)

[Gamma Emerald]

I like the direction of some of the thoughts you've had

[Chara]

Mulch soft-defended Creature early on. keep in mind i'm not saying this makes Creature scum, Creature is scum all by himself but it does say something about Mulch's treatment of his scumbuddies this game.

Mulch also choosing to vote me for a short period of time before going back to James is not something i think Mulch would do were James his partner. initially i thought it meant James could be his partner, because Mulch used my James read to vote me, but now i'm not so sure. thoughts?

[Chara]

btw regardless of the guilty James Brafin is probably scum because he's shading the guy with the guilty so hard
VOTE: James Brafin
Because might as well

i actually don't get this at all, Gamma. why does scum shade the guilty that we'll surely lynch once revealed? it seems a rather simplistic conclusion, and James gains little, especially after the guilty flips. to me it was more indicative of someone who didn't think the guilty was real, while scum, knowing anti was town, would then know the guilty is likely real. unless James was pretending to be uninformed, if that's what you were implying.

i know i said no massclaim, but will you claim who you neighbourized last night and why?

[Chara]

i think i remember Mulch buddying Two somewhere, but i can't find it in his ISO. i'll do it when i'm on my laptop, unless someone knows what i mean.

[Gamma Emerald]

I neighborized 2iam last night because I figured if FL/2iam was TvT it would be smart to work that out not in the main thread
As for the point you're making, yeah that's honestly probably true. I'm kinda skeeved out by his disappearance d3 when it comes to the possibility of James!scum, like wtf happened, and shouldn't his buddy have taken notice if he were scum?

[Chara]

i feel like every time Gamma has talked about his read on me it's been for a different reason. 881 my efforting is towny, right now it's that he likes the direction of my thoughts. somewhere in between that he agreed i was moonlogicky as scum. could you be more specific?
(and remind me where you've seen my scumgame? i'm curious)

pedit: oh, thank you.
what were you skeeved out by, sorry? you agree James is more likely town because he disappeared?

[Gamma Emerald]

I don't see how "efforting" and "direction of posts" really conflict. The reason direction of posts is my current explanation is because while I wasn't to big a fan of you suspecting me in a specific post there was some decent points you made, might quote that one. As for the scumgame where I felt you were moonlogicky, that was Death Note mafia where you were the Almost Chara hydra, where I started suspecting you off of a post where I felt the logic was off
I was skeeved out of thinking James was probably scum by him flaking d3. And yeah that's right.

[Chara]

they don't conflict, i just wanted more detail. which you have provided, thank you.
we have three lynches left til game over, and two scum. i think Creature > Flavor > Gamma gets us the win at that time, but i've barely begun. i probably die tonight so i want to do something before i'm out.

[TwoInAMillion]

I still think FL is scum because he's been more active elsewhere on the site.

[Chara]

^^^ i've used this in the past and it has constantly failed me. though i agree with your conclusion, if not your methodology.
reads on the rest of the game?

[Gamma Emerald]

I still think FL is scum because he's been more active elsewhere on the site.

no.

[TwoInAMillion]

Hawk is the third scum most likely.

but it could be sheep.

[Chara]

Hawk is the third scum most likely.

but it could be sheep.

Hawk isn't the third scum. he's very towny.
why aren't you considering Creature scum?

[TwoInAMillion]

It could be creature. I still don't like Hawk's claim.

[Chara]

So I'm really bad at this game and feel like I probably ruined d1 for town.

I'm Miller.

My bad that I waited till 200 posts to claim. I've never played with this role but doing research I think this is what I probably should have done yesterday.

Hawk needs to be lynched. You don't claim miller after you're being wagoned.

Yeah I realized that this morning. Better to just get it out of the way. I mean if I got to a close lynch and then claimed it wouldn't have helped.

Sorry guys shoulda just claimed from the start.

scum doesn't claim like this.
arbitrary rules like "not claiming miller after being wagoned" don't apply when not claiming immediately was a mistake to begin with. not to mention, if Hawk wanted the wagon to dissipate, or even to draw a town PR claim, he would have picked basically anything else.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think Hawk's reaction to fro99er's Vanilla Cop thing was more townclearing

[Chara]

perhaps i didn't find it as such because i already thought he was town. either way.

[TwoInAMillion]

Okay, well I can go with that for now. I've been wrong before.

What about sheep/james?

[Gamma Emerald]

Okay, well I can go with that for now. I've been wrong before.

What about sheep/james?

See above

[Chara]

Mulch interactions (not just the simple fact if James was scum Mulch was bussing, because scum Mulch absolutely busses) point me towards town James as i explained. i also just considered him towny in general and while i began to doubt that, going back to what i townread him for initially, i still think it holds. Mulch was the one who attacked me my reasoning there, too.

[TwoInAMillion]

i think i remember Mulch buddying Two somewhere, but i can't find it in his ISO. i'll do it when i'm on my laptop, unless someone knows what i mean.

He didn't buddy me, I buddied him. I thought he was town day 1.

[Flavor Leaf]

1:Creature- Easy read
2:Mulch- Easy read
3:Fro99er- Hard read
4:Transcend- Hard read
5:Flavor Leaf- Hard read
6:TheYankeeReaper- Null read
7:James Brafin- Null read
8:Locke113- Null read
9:Hawk- Null read
10:Gamma Emerald- Null read
11:Smocaine- Null read
12:TwoInAMillion- Null read
13:Chara- Easy read

It’s Creature and Chara. Nuff said.

Although, neat trick you did with pushing Creature first.

[Flavor Leaf]

Creature’s at L-2, right?

Intent to hammer.

[Flavor Leaf]

Froggy and I aren’t hard reads for Mulch. It was him signaling to his teammates.

[Chara]

so then why didn't Mulch put you two down as null reads?