Mini Normal 1985 No Spoilers (END)

[Hawk]

Also flavor creature had to go. Can you imagine lynching outside of that today going into 5 left with creature being the person we have left to sort if we get it wrong today?

[Gamma Emerald]

*Hawk: definitely town.
*Two: possibly town. not much to see here, honestly.
Gamma: i have my doubts. i don't think the reasons for townreading him are good, including Frog's.
Flavor: i thought he was scummy but after our talk i don't know.
sheep: i'm just townreading him.
Creature: hopefully scum!

Why on sheep

[Chara]

Chara why is Gamma scum? What's wrong with the reasoning. Who Neighborizes and opens with wanna Mason Gambit as scum?

i've seen scum neighbourizers do this. it's not really that strange. what exactly is the risk as scum?

[TwoInAMillion]

I was townreading Chara but the readlist makes me doubt him.

[Chara]

Why on sheep

James was towny, sheep has so far been mildly towny, and there's what i noticed about Mulch. i'll go over it tomorrow if i'm alive.

pedit: <3

[Flavor Leaf]

Also flavor creature had to go. Can you imagine lynching outside of that today going into 5 left with creature being the person we have left to sort if we get it wrong today?

I was never against lynching Creature today. I stated my intent to hammer pages ago, haha. All my evidence I was shouting out all said ScumCreature.

[Flavor Leaf]

Chara why is Gamma scum? What's wrong with the reasoning. Who Neighborizes and opens with wanna Mason Gambit as scum?

i've seen scum neighbourizers do this. it's not really that strange. what exactly is the risk as scum?

This is why I pushed Gamma in the first place.

[Hawk]

Chara why is Gamma scum? What's wrong with the reasoning. Who Neighborizes and opens with wanna Mason Gambit as scum?

i've seen scum neighbourizers do this. it's not really that strange. what exactly is the risk as scum?

Doesn't make sense in the context of the game if you present it as a scum Neighborizer. There was a traitor. scum knew that the Neighborizer would have been a way to get the traitor into a day chat with town. Meaning As scum I would Neighborized people I thought were potential traitors first.

Unless flavor and gamma are the scum team I don't see this scenario playing out with gamma being scum.

[Flavor Leaf]

Chara why is Gamma scum? What's wrong with the reasoning. Who Neighborizes and opens with wanna Mason Gambit as scum?

i've seen scum neighbourizers do this. it's not really that strange. what exactly is the risk as scum?

Doesn't make sense in the context of the game if you present it as a scum Neighborizer. There was a traitor. scum knew that the Neighborizer would have been a way to get the traitor into a day chat with town. Meaning As scum I would Neighborized people I thought were potential traitors first.

Unless flavor and gamma are the scum team I don't see this scenario playing out with gamma being scum.

If Gamma and I were the scum team, we’d be confirmed not traitors, so we wouldn’t need to neighborize as there would be a PT already.

To be fair, I have had a scum neighborize partner neighborize me. Just letting that be out there.

[Gamma Emerald]

Why on sheep

James was towny, sheep has so far been mildly towny, and there's what i noticed about Mulch. i'll go over it tomorrow if i'm alive.

pedit: <3

please do it today

[Chara]

sorry, nope.

[Chara]

i mean, i could. it's just that it's basically what i already said? i just don't feel like towncasing him now considering it's Twilight and discussing why players are town when the lynch is already decided is incredibly pointless.

[Gamma Emerald]

Chara why is Gamma scum? What's wrong with the reasoning. Who Neighborizes and opens with wanna Mason Gambit as scum?

i've seen scum neighbourizers do this. it's not really that strange. what exactly is the risk as scum?

Doesn't make sense in the context of the game if you present it as a scum Neighborizer. There was a traitor. scum knew that the Neighborizer would have been a way to get the traitor into a day chat with town. Meaning As scum I would Neighborized people I thought were potential traitors first.

Unless flavor and gamma are the scum team I don't see this scenario playing out with gamma being scum.

If Gamma and I were the scum team, we’d be confirmed not traitors, so we wouldn’t need to neighborize as there would be a PT already.

To be fair, I have had a scum neighborize partner neighborize me. Just letting that be out there.

Yeah, the point of scum neighborizer is to get people to trust you, it would be very weird to neighborize a teammate, the only time I've seen it was a weird fringe case where there was a PT cop but I don't think the player was aware of that when they did it

[Chara]

the reason for a scum neighbourizer to hit their teammate is because it's a good distancing move. for exactly the reasoning you're using.

[Flavor Leaf]

I’ve literally had a game where I had my scum neighborizer neighborize me and we had so much theatre in there, then in 7p lylo we brought a townie in with us, and got in a hard 3v3 and had said townie vote with us.

We played a fake miller-cop gambit that game too. Was great. Rb was one of the people on the opposite 3v3 as well, and Eddie was a vig that game.

Gambits are awesome. Town and Scum ones.


Also, Scum Neighborizer does make sense in this setup to neighborize your traitor, so there’s the potential for PT talk, but there’s no way Gamma would have thought I was a traitor. He was buddying up to me so hard early game and I called him out for it.

Gives some merit to him wanting to do the mason gambit with me specifically. However, Gamma did bring up wanting to do it with Mulch but Mulch pushed him.

[Flavor Leaf]

I just can’t see Gamma trying to warlock me, though. (Buddies up enough where he makes me do all the work as town for him and protects him.)

[Hawk]

the reason for a scum neighbourizer to hit their teammate is because it's a good distancing move. for exactly the reasoning you're using.

It is but I don't buy it... It's very well setup in the thread and the interaction feels genuine.. I don't believe it would be from two scum buddies just trying to pocket me and any other player they add... what do you think 2iam?

Also if and when creature flips scum that throws this entire thing out the window.

[sheepsaysmeep]

what's the argument for town!boon

[Chara]

oh, i don't think that's what's happened. Creature's scum.

[sheepsaysmeep]

boon feels ehhh

[Hawk]

what's the argument for town!boon

If gamma!town he Neighborized Boon with the intent of doing a Mason claim gambit because he believed boon to be town. Boon the very first chance he gets outs the neighborhood and uses me as confirmation throwing away a gambit with a towny as scum.

Basically scum Flavor leaf never throws away all of the town cred Gamma was giving him by outting the neighborhood right away.

[sheepsaysmeep]

you dont sound like youve seen scum!boon

[TwoInAMillion]

scum!boon manipulates. town!boon townbuilds and tries to solve. This seems a lot more like scum!boon.

[sheepsaysmeep]

so i found it with command f
eh it's not hard for me to see scum!boon do this

looking for what his read on gamma was before that

[sheepsaysmeep]

ugh i really need context