Mini Normal 1989: A Perfectly Normal Day -- Game Over

[Tchill13]

That's 2 players that have openly said "Havo's scum Idc that there other scum members out there. We haven't sorted 5 players but we're done for the day."

[sheepsaysmeep]

replace me

it's honestly only fair for town
i cant keep up at all

[Jodaxq]

Now nk15 had a great question. What does chumba gain by intervening instead of letting havo and eth0s go at each other?

Would there be more to gain from chumba sitting back or did chumba have enough ammo to make it a quick argument?

I don't know. You've already seen what I think scum would do day one. Sit back.

All Ik is profii definitely expected havo to be lynched by the next time he seen the thread and if chumba/profii are scum together THEN it makes sense for chumba to intervene I guess. Since profii showed no hesitation and felt confident havo would be lynched.

Other than a chumba/profii scum team it may have made more sense for chumba to just "sit back" as scum there.

It’s cause I’m not scum. Town Chumba would step in when somebody is lying. Havo flat out lied. You and he can deny it all you want but it actually fucking happened.

Maybe profli/havo are a team and profli wanted to get on unnoticed? Why haven’t you considered that theory? Bussing happens

Done? Why are you giving up?

You have the sole right to command when conversations stop and start this game? Which ones get to go on and which ones get to be shut down? Who died and made you king?

Im showing hesitation and he still gives up.

If havo is scum there's 2 others and he refuses to chase that Avenue even if I was working towards that with him.

Unwillingness to work with others.

!!!As soon as I mentioned he's only scum with profii he went from not reading profii until day 2 to saying profii was bussing havo!!!

Funny how that works.

It sounds like we should lynch profii.

[Tchill13]

I completely agree with jodaxq.

This is why I asked chumba what his thoughts were on profii because I knew if myself and jodaxq could could see those 2 things sticking out like a sore thumb chumba should be able to also.

He said profii wasn't worth reading until day 2.

Then I said scum chumba makes sense only with scum profii.

Then chumba said profii was probably bussing havo after stating he wasn't gonna read profii until day 2.c

Im sure jodaxq can see the red flag there.

[Chickadee]

VOTE: tchill

I’m not being anywhere near a havo or chumba wagon as I’m pretty clear this is a personality clash not a manipulation. Tchil however isn’t clashing with personalities he is advocating a push on chumba for a play i expect chumba to make when scum hunting (annoying as he can be )

Tchil do you think where myself and chumba were commenting on our unusual agreements on reads very early on would be a scum play? I don’t know if scum openly buddy but I can’t think of a reason they would?

Scum openly buddy all the time.

[Tchill13]

VOTE: profii

I'm not getting caught up in chumba v havo.

We have a direction if profii flips scum. This is fine.

See ya sheep.

[Tchill13]

I'm fine with lynching Chumba, profii and... Schadd. in that order.

[Chickadee]

So, you're realizing there may not be enough interest in a Chumba lynch, and you're working down your list?

[Havo]

vt in chumba too

why did you feel the need to mention you think i am a vt?

Hmm....

[Chumba]

So, you're realizing there may not be enough interest in a Chumba lynch, and you're working down your list?

please ask tchill why he considered me/profli a team but he doesn't seem to consider profli/havo?

also ask him if he realizes that the definition of maybe and probably are actually different so by him saying I probably think they are scum together is not true at all and he is guilty of misrepping me yet again.

[profii]

vt in chumba too

why did you feel the need to mention you think i am a vt?

I think the whole thing was town vs town vs town. It wasn’t a random softclaim

[Tchill13]

I'm fine with lynching Chumba, profii and... Schadd. in that order.

This posts was made a while back. I realize there's a scenario where chumba and havo are town here.

Profii looks pretty scummy imo. He did then and he does now.

[Tchill13]

Chumba are you an English major IRL? Like seriously drop the grammar crap.

[Tchill13]

Profii could be scum piggy backing off town chumba.

Profii could be scum with chumba.

There's really not any major town incentives for the moves he's made so far imo.

[Jodaxq]

vt in chumba too

why did you feel the need to mention you think i am a vt?

I think the whole thing was town vs town vs town. It wasn’t a random softclaim

??? How does that actually answer the question?

[Chickadee]

I'm fine with lynching Chumba, profii and... Schadd. in that order.

This posts was made a while back. I realize there's a scenario where chumba and havo are town here.

Profii looks pretty scummy imo. He did then and he does now.

Ok, so you're not denying to just working down a list?

[profii]

I think eth0s is very strongly town from the 1v1. I agree with the points TChill made about not wanting to expose himself with a fit like this if he were scum.

Profii's behavior around the 1v1 is concerning to me. He popped in and out without trying to interfere with anything, he kept putting off having a reaction - "I'm not sure what to make about eth0s' breakdown," and he came in with a pretty opportunistic vote on Havo.

i agree that ethos comes off as town from the 1v1

but the fact that profii didnt interfere doesn't bother me at all because it's what i would've done if i were online at the time. sometimes you gain more information from just letting the game play out

no point searching for another scum now because they will use our discussion to fiddle the night kills/actions/etc.

I think I'm on Havo. I think Chumba should just vote and Havo can Havo himself

This post is really bad. Profii, who has made sure to let everyone know that Havo hammers at L-1 so we don't get a quick lynch, is talking in this post like Havo is a done deal and tried to push his lynch through quickly.

to be fair, i like the thought of havo havoing himself

osuka, you are exactly on my wavelength at this point.

havo havoing himself was an amusing thought than a push to lynch (this sentence aimed at Jodaxq criticism)

I've already pointed out the argument was becoming more insults than debate of facts so I stayed away. It just seemed tedious.

Does anyone else believe that profii's Havo Havoing himself post was just amusing? This was after he voted Havo and said there's no point in searching out another scum.

the bit about not finding scum was meant as in “let’s not get into pre conf bias on day 1”

Not “havo is the scum and I’m sticking til he dies”

[Jodaxq]

@Chickadee, didn't you say you'd be okay with a profii lynch earlier? What changed?

[Chumba]

vt in chumba too

why did you feel the need to mention you think i am a vt?

I think the whole thing was town vs town vs town. It wasn’t a random softclaim

I get you now think it is t v t v t, but that doesn't explain why you felt the need to point out you think I am a vt

[Chickadee]

vt in chumba too

why did you feel the need to mention you think i am a vt?

I think the whole thing was town vs town vs town. It wasn’t a random softclaim

??? How does that actually answer the question?

He's saying that he wasn't saying vanilla town.

he was adding on another "versus town" in Chumba.


Pedit: I did, and it's not off the table for me, but I'd like to ask some questions before blindly jumping in on the wagon, especially considering I'm currently voting Tchill, and Tchill just switched.

[Tchill13]

I'm fine with lynching Chumba, profii and... Schadd. in that order.

This posts was made a while back. I realize there's a scenario where chumba and havo are town here.

Profii looks pretty scummy imo. He did then and he does now.

Ok, so you're not denying to just working down a list?

There's a thing called a lynch pool. I got 3 ppl in mine right now. 2 of them I have actual reasoning for one is just 100 percent gut. So I'm gonna vote those 2 and provide a reason with it. So sure.

It's a list of 2 but yeah it's a list. No denying here.

[Chickadee]

vt in chumba too

why did you feel the need to mention you think i am a vt?

I think the whole thing was town vs town vs town. It wasn’t a random softclaim

I get you now think it is t v t v t, but that doesn't explain why you felt the need to point out you think I am a vt

He never said he thought you vanilla town.



This entire game is under some semantically challenged curse.

[profii]

Jodaxq seems like a logical poster, I get why she had concerns over some of my posts, but I'm glad that Osuka totally got where I was coming from- sometimes I worry that I'm terrible at written English and say stupid things, but if Osuka read it perfectly, it wasn't that bad. Either way I'm happy with both of them.

Yeah I don't like this at all. In what post did Osuka totally get where you are coming from? He said he didn't mind you not interfering with the 1v1 and then said he thought Havo Havoing himself was amusing (which I don't think he said that to defend you).
The biggest problems are your extremely opportunistic vote on Havo and your post where you say there's no point in hunting other scum. You dropped a vote on Havo and said you'd be away for awhile. Why the rush to vote Havo then? Why not wait until you came back to catch up and vote? Then, you come back, clarify you're still on Havo, and say there's no point in hunting like Havo already has enough votes to be lynched.

Re: osuka- that was it. Havo havoing himself was tongue in cheek. I couldn’t be bothered adding to the drama

That’s all those posts meant and osuka got it

You questioned it - I can see why but we are venturing into the point where you are looking for scum , you are either pressuring me to see if I slip or you sense a wagon approaching with tchills assistance.


I’ve stated my reason for voting havo and I’ve stated it was irrelevant to the drama. If you continue to not accept that then I have an issue with you slot

[Tchill13]

Profii could be scum with chumba.

Profii could be scum piggy backing off town chumba.

Profii (from Chumbas perspective) could be scum bussing havo.

So please tell me why I shouldn't vote profii?

Why can't I scum read profii and chumba?

[profii]

VOTE: profii

I'm not getting caught up in chumba v havo.

We have a direction if profii flips scum. This is fine.

See ya sheep.

Profii could be scum piggy backing off town chumba.

Profii could be scum with chumba.

There's really not any major town incentives for the moves he's made so far imo.

great direction there if you are going to get the town lost, don’t lead