Newbie 1846 - Game Over

[Lucky2u]

Na... Scum got this. Especially since one or both of ucv and Cabd are among them.

[Myloninja13]

Oh no... this means I'll be quick-lynched and mafia will win.

GRRR... this is not how I wanted my first proper mafia game to go.

Hmmm... I heavily dislike this post.

Lucky, wait until the dead thread to start attacking people. I'm sorry for being so harsh on you, but honestly I kind of trapped a town vs. town match between us and scum just clung to the sideline.

[Myloninja13]

Na... Scum got this. Especially since one or both of ucv and Cabd are among them.

??? Are you suggesting the virtually 100% confirmed JK as scum!?!?!

[Lucky2u]

Oh right lol, forgot he was confirmed. I'm kind of meh now that I'm dead.

[Myloninja13]

Okay, when day 3 happens expect Bad cop Mylo, because I am not letting this be the end of this.

[Myloninja13]

Lucky, whats your final read list?

[Lucky2u]

Im not attacking anyone mylon. I just don't think town can do it.

I've had nothing but bad experiences with confirmed town in games. Cabd was one of them in a game not too long ago. Nothing personal Cabd, you know what I mean.

[Myloninja13]

So, I'm assuming then it's out of brass/leeoon/cabd, although I'm removing my 100% town claim on Magik because I really can't afford to have that now.

I'm leaning towards Leeoon/brass, but honestly my thoughts are so muddled up right now I would be surprised if it was a Cabd/Magik team.

[Lucky2u]

I'm null on you mylon.

Id start with Yankee slot, his replacement towed the line coming after me. Leon is not that town either. Those are my top two scummers.

[Myloninja13]

I'm null on you mylon.

Id start with Yankee slot, his replacement towed the line coming after me. Leon is not that town either. Those are my top two scummers.

Okay, thanks.

[Myloninja13]

I have to go again, but a reminder that you SHOULD NOT VOTE ON DAY 3, AND SHOULD TALK FOREVER ON DAY 3.

[Lucky2u]

Welcome to the site btw. I'll see you around

[brassherald]

Wow, I was driving to my fiance's house and all hell broke loose, it seems. No early votes tomorrow is right, we need to solve this. But I think lucky may be taunting us still with his town talk

[MagikHorse]

Kaboom. Either way, Mylon is right that votes should be withheld. One vote on Town and scum can easily arrange a quickhammer. It's what I did in my first game, which ended up letting me win easily as Scum.

Actually starting to think of Mylo as null atm. I need to reread a lot of this, and it'll definitely be done in detail on Day 3.

[Huntress]

Vote Count 2.7

Lucky2u (4) - Leeoon, brassherald, Lucky2u, Myloninja13 [LYNCH]

Myloninja13 (1) - MagikHorse

Not voting (2) - Cabd, UC Voyager


With seven players alive, it takes four votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Two is Saturday 10th February, 11.40 pm GMT, (in (expired on 2018-02-10 23:40:00)).

[Huntress]

Lucky2u (Vanilla Townie) was lynched Day Two.

It is now Night Two.

Deadline for Night Two is Monday, 12th February, 11.30 pm GMT, (in (expired on 2018-02-12 23:30:00)).

[Huntress]

UC Voyager (Town Jailkeeper) was killed night two.

It is now DAY THREE.

With five players alive, it takes three votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Three is Monday 26th February, 11.30 pm GMT, (in (expired on 2018-02-26 23:30:00)).

[Cabd]

So this is LYLO.

Hold your votes; I'm going to explain how this all works.

[Cabd]

(I start my new job in the morning so I may not be around much for the next 24 hours; but converse all you'd like just don't vote)

[MagikHorse]

One stray vote means the Scum can put in two quick votes in succession, thus ending the game. This is the reasoning behind this vote withholding.

Meanwhile, I'm going to take a closer look over the wagon yesterday over a bowl of ice cream, so expect that momentarily.

[MagikHorse]

The wagon on Lucky consisted of Leeoon, BrassHerald, Lucky himself, and Mylo.

Leeoon was on this wagon because of Lucky's sudden 180, putting a fair amount of pressure on Lucky over it.

BrassHerald was on this wagon after pointing out Lucky's deflections, anti-meta speech, and for putting so much pressure on Mylo without a sufficient amount of evidence.

Lucky voted himself just to get it over with, going out the door saying Mylo seemed null now.

Mylo was on the wagon partially because it was either him or Lucky, partially because Lucky went all defeatist on us, partially because of things they said in 483.

For the remaining 3 of us not on the wagon, things go as follows:

I was on Mylo's wagon, but waited for a chance to jump on the Lucky wagon and called out an intent to hammer Lucky right before a vote was removed. Perhaps a bit sheepishly I was thinking along the same lines as Brass, compounding it with my constant disbelief at Lucky's u-turn strategy. Should've probably unvoted first, but that's hindsight for you.

Cabd removed their vote to avoid a quickhammer on Lucky, even though a quickhammer would've been incredibly scummy to begin with.

And UCV was kind of only half there yesterday, but got cut off from giving us a detailed read on Brass by the chaos that was the end of Day 2. Really, we should've waited until there were a few hours left on the clock, not an entire day. If he hadn't gotten back to us by then then it'd be him being slow, not us rushing the lynch by almost an entire day.

Overall, Cabd seemed way too cautious about it. Didn't they know that a quickhammer would be incredibly suspicious to begin with to the point of almost being a guaranteed Day 3 lynch for trying it? This fear seems a bit overly paranoid and not very well founded given the suspicions it would cause.

Mylo's hammer vote was the simplest to place and the most complicated to explain, but at least they had some reasoning behind it beyond "it's me or the other guy".

[brassherald]

Let me start with this that I have said in all my other games: I actually have a chain of big cases coming up this week and next week, with my boss being on vacation, actually replaced out of games where it was not yet through day 1 because of this, not going to be replacing out of here unless one case next week goes to trial (Fingers crossed that we get another month) but, my posting is definitely going to be going down in volume.

So, this may qualify as a semi VLA status.

Thoughts coming soonish.

[MagikHorse]

Since it's a new day, I'll update my readlists to match.

{BrassHerald} He's been making a lot of reads and giving a large amount of detail behind every one of them. I like that, even if his two predecessors were neutral.
{Leeoon} Was poking at Mylo for their lack of scumhunting and poking at Lucky for their ineffectual arguments.
{Myloninja13} Rising up into neutral territory, and is showing at least a slight amount of scumhunting now. It's hard to tell if their Townslip in 495 was an actual slip or crafted to look like one, and my earlier suspicions are still lingering about.
{Cabd} I find their reason for unvoting to be too paranoid. Even if you did something like that recently, this Town would eat anyone that tried to lolhammer up in an instant with the way we've been going off of every little thing, leaving these fears unfounded. It's a reason that sounds good at first, but is mostly air when you think about it.

[brassherald]

Leeon talking about it being scum v. scum seems a bit off to me, I mean, it's common sense that the scum are not going to go at each other like that. He was making me uneasy from that point. I do not think he's said anything since then, either.

I almost feel like Cabd was playing specifically to me by pulling his vote off, maybe it is just my paranoia that comes naturally in these games, especially later, but I am not sure that he's quite on the level with that.

Mylo's actions on jumping on a Lucky lynch literally a minute after he is at L-1, then immediately just believing the guy he supposedly mislynched is town feels off to me. The entire twilight just feels like him trying to expand the lynch pool, as well. 519 is also super LAMIST.

And, Magik if you are scum, you deserve to win, honestly, because even my paranoid brain looks and says that the worst thing you said was you were eating ice cream which I miss from the time before I was lactose intolerant.

I'm leaning most towards a Leeon/Mylo scum team, but could see Cabd with either of them at this point.

[Myloninja13]

I am here, just let me read through this all.