Mini 1990: Terror in the City (Game Over)

[brassherald]

VOTE: TFL

We haven't even heard from everyone yet. I have a bad feeling about someone asking for scum leans already.

[Chickadee]

VOTE: TFL

We haven't even heard from everyone yet. I have a bad feeling about someone asking for scum leans already.

That’s bad reasoning.

TFL is null for me so far, but I think all the votes on him are bad votes.

Since when can’t we scum hunt until everyone checks in?

[Hopkirk]

What do you think about TFL not having any clear scum leans himself?

L2 btw.

[Hopkirk]

@Brassherald: were you aware there were 4 votes on TFL already?

[Chickadee]

VOTE: TFL

We haven't even heard from everyone yet. I have a bad feeling about someone asking for scum leans already.

That’s bad reasoning.

TFL is null for me so far, but I think all the votes on him are bad votes.

Since when can’t we scum hunt until everyone checks in?

It's fine. I like that TFL is trying to get things going and asking questions. Not having scum reads does not prevent one about asking others about theirs.

[Hopkirk]

Do you have any scumleans?

[The Powerpuff Girls]

Powder
can you explain why Fritz is town bc of the whole Hopkins thing......Curious about your thought process here

it was more of a gut feeling than anything else – i would have expected scum fitz to react more strongly to the scumslip than he did before he realized it was a joke. i didn't get the joke at first either, so the confused reaction makes sense to me.

@TPG-Key: A four-person scum hydra has incentive to coordinate before posting. Based on experience, your town hydra partners posted a lot more while in hydras. I just finished a game where RC/North were a town hydra, and Cheeky was in a town hydra (and it read like Cheeky barely had a hydra QT). Despite RC/North dying n1, the two hydras accounted for over 50% of the posts in a 9 player game. Therefore, not posting much initially is definitely odd in comparison.

i'm not sure what you expect me to say. do you think

all

of the people in this hydra are the type to just lurk things out as scum? because what you're saying would only be consistent with that.

VOTE: brassherald

-bubbles

[Hopkirk]

Who's bubbles?

No, I'm not saying you'd all lurk as scum. I said you might want to discuss how to approach the game as scum, whereas you'd just post as town. That's what 'incentive to coordinate before posting' means.

Brass feels slightly different.

@Nero: you had three posts just after my joke. What were your immediate thoughts?

[Chickadee]

Do you have any scumleans?

I don't like your push on the Powerpuff Girls so far, but thats about it.


I like Fitz' responses to everything. I also like how we as a group are getting out of RVS early.

[Hopkirk]

What don't you like about it?
It's not a scumread.
It's a meta question based on having just played vs 3 of the 4 heads in town hydras.

[Hopkirk]

Why did you only mention my TPG push if you don't like my TFL push either? Or did you like it? If not, why?

[Hopkirk]

That should be 38%, not over 50% actually, but the meaning doesn't change.

[Chickadee]

I feel like I kind of already covered the TFL thing when addressing Brass. Didn't feel the need to bring it up again.

And I just don't think your meta has feet to stand on. I don't agree with it. I've also played with them in hydras. I've also played with some of them as scum hydras. Also considering that the game JUST started, like 24 hours ago, i don't think anyone can truly be called a lurker yet.

[Hopkirk]

At the time, it was a talking point/question.
It's still not AI.
That doesn't mean it's not worth discussing.

[Hopkirk]

My vote was for his sidestepping my questions. Why is that bad/illegitimate?

[brassherald]

@Brassherald: were you aware there were 4 votes on TFL already?

I was not.

UNVOTE:

[havingfitz]

sup

sorta forgot about the game. did I missed something interesting? XD

The game isn't even a day old yet and 2.5 pages long when you post this.

Why the need to excuse not posting sooner and why not just read 2.5 pages to form your own thoughts rather than ask if anything has happened?

[Hopkirk]

@Brass:
I asked since I saw you expressed reluctance to join early wagons in your completed game.
Thus, I like your response/consistency.

[Kop]

VOTE: TFL

We haven't even heard from everyone yet. I have a bad feeling about someone asking for scum leans already.

VOTE: Brassherald

That vote stinks. Opportunistic, and not worthy enough reason for me that warrants a vote.

[Hopkirk]

@Fitz: That's a good point. Looking at Y's complete game, he gets straight into it when making his first post a similar number of posts in (as town).

@Kop: how do you feel about TFL?

[brassherald]

@Brass:
I asked since I saw you expressed reluctance to join early wagons in your completed game.
Thus, I like your response/consistency.

Yeah, I just didn't check the vote, it's too early to pressure the dude right now.

[Nero Cain]

TFL is null for me so far, but I think all the votes on him are bad votes.

Could you talk more about your read on him?

@Nero: you had three posts just after my joke. What were your immediate thoughts?

about?

[Hopkirk]

About #8.
Fitz's reaction too.

[Momrangal]

I'm here. Hello. Ready to make a come back. Maybe.

[The Powerpuff Girls]

The only person in this Hydra who has a meta of posting less as scum is the head who has done the lions share of the posting so far: if anything I post more consistently often as scum than town.

I'm busy with RL and cheeky is in a lot of games. That's NAI.